Home   Forum   Wiki   Notes   Register   FAQ   Sitemap   About Us   Contact Us  

Did MSV have ANY musical defects?

Topic started by SR Kaushik (@ nova1.cs.wisc.edu) on Wed Sep 30 15:21:55 EDT 1998.
All times in EST +10:30 for IST.

Let me make one thing clear: I am not against MSV, but am merely curious about this topic.

I have made an interesting observation. We have so many criticisms of IR and ARR, but I've not seen any criticism of MSV. I haven't listened to many MSV songs, but I wasn't very impressed by whatever I have heard on TV. Whatever it is, I cannot imagine that he did not have any musical defects. Could anyone point them out? I am very interested. It might test the "objectivity" of certain "objective" people regarding the IR-ARR "war"(I'm not hinting at anyone, please do not misunderstand this), but nevertheless, I want to pursue this.

---

Responses:

• Old responses
  
• From: God (@ 161.142.100.86) on: Mon Sep 16 22:33:09 EDT 2002
  
  Uthaman, better take your medicine again.
  It just looks like you enjoy being insulted. I really thought you would have learnt a lesson and start behaving, but then you can't teach new tricks to old dogs.
  
  Satish, that's okay. We are quite used to dogs like Uthaman. The reason for his bark is nothing but soreness that IR is not in the running any more. We all know about IR's ego and hot headedness. It is natural that some of his fans will also acquire these attributes.
  
  Speaker, matured rasanai is enjoying one's own liking without deriding others'. Uthaman maathiri jenmangalukku suttupottaalum varaathu.
  
  
• From: Awe (@ 65.69.58.25) on: Tue Sep 17 00:51:46 EDT 2002
  
  Satish.. music means just songs for you guys... ok grow up beyond your age man.. re-recording was discussed by school guys as early as in 80s.. Still you do not know what it is.. So your highly limited exposure to music just like every other ARR fans..including some morons like 161.142.100.86.. For you 'Kadalukku Mariyathai' is not a hit.. So it is another .. If you include 1992... Avarampoo, Chembaruthi, Chinnavar, Nadodi Thendral, Thevar Magan, Chinna Thayee, Deiva Vakku, Chinna Kounder, Innisai Mazhai, Meera, Singara Velan, Senthamizh Pattu, Unnai Vazthi Padukiren, Vanna Vanna Pookkal all these movies came in 1992.. in one year it came.. So don't talk like a 'genius' with an ulterior motive which is attacking IR.. You know what.. we don't care.. Even though your intentions are different, i assumed that you have more knowledge about Telugu, Kannada music than Tamil music, i have answered you... Let me see what kind of response you come up with.. Probably your taste has not crossed the level of 'dippu dippu' 'maya chaya' songs.. So don't ask IR fans to come to your low level.. We don't ask you guys to come to our higher level.. If you seriously feel IR music is not good after 1992, for heaven's sake don't listen.. instead of worrying.. You don't have to compare anybody to anyone..
  
  
  ". MSV in his s'pore trip said ARR is his "SON" (please underscore it). Deva is just a XEROX of IR. BW is another upcoming Photocopier!! ARR is another MSV. I cant compare ARR to IR as I did for MSV. So now tell me whom I should compare IR to? It is none other than our XEROX and Photocopier. " - Satish
  
  
  Indha pethalukku logic vera.. kashtam.. Go and settle down with english songs like
  
  Oorvasi Oorvasi Take it policy, Mustafa Mustafa don't worry mustafa, No Problem, Hello doctor, Shakalaka baby Shakalaka baby.. Yea as you say you cannot compare IR with ARR.. IR is the best trend setter in Tamil movies. ARR is the worst trend setter in Tamil movies. The trend he set was
  asking singers without bhavam, ucharippu and using keyboard for everything.. No wonder HJ have eclipsed ARR. Now i can see HJ is a far better keyboard player than ARR. He can't even compose chamber music let alone symphony. Has he given any memorable orchestration like Illayaraja did in Dalapathi? Oh sorry people like satish and animals like 161.142.100.86 don't know anything about BGM.. He would use Kadari Gopalnath for sax, Prasanna for Guitar, Sabesh Murali for rerecording what the hell he is doing there? He would just sit there and mix and match the music.. He is the most over rated musician tamil field has ever seen.. But for Maniratnam he would be still scoring jingles..
  
  
• From: God (@ 161.142.100.86) on: Tue Sep 17 01:49:43 EDT 2002
  
  Frankly IR cannot touch the dust of the feet of MSV.
  Only undeveloped morons and mentally retarded beings like Uthaman will acclaim his music.
  People with class know where IR belong, which is the slums.
  
  Whatever good songs that came out when IR was ruling was because of uncredited people like Gangai Amaran. IR was one helluva greedy totally untalented guy. Only idiots with retarded brains will glorify his music.
  
  IR is best only in lewd and vulgarity. TFM fell into disgrace with his advent and with songs that any child will get smacked for having the audacity to sing.
  
  Tamil culture was murdered and buried by IR with songs like nethu rathiri yamma, maamen orunaal malliyapoo, kattavandi kattavandi, nilaa kayuthu, ithu oru nilaa kaalam, orampo orampo, oru manja kuruvi, etc.
  
  If only ARR had not entered the scene in the 90s, we will all have to shed ratha kanneer for the fate that has fallen upon TFM.
  
  Civilised people will obliterate the late 70s and 80s from their minds, so that they can go on living a decent lifestyle.
  
  But like viruses and other pollutants of this world, pests like Uthaman will creep up now and then using Satanic pervesion to hail the devil.
  
  But we all know thetruth, don't we?
  
  
• From: God (@ 209.245.41.80) on: Tue Sep 17 02:12:29 EDT 2002
  
  161.142.100.86 in suya roopam theriya arambithu vittadhu.. 161.142.100.86... You have taken 100s of names like Sheela , Vaidegi.. so go back to your gay conference.. Nobody listens to you.. you are born to get bashed by IR fans.. alias is trashiest person in the TFM forum. 161.142.100.86 go to koovam river and put your face inside the river and drink it fully.. you are the most idiotic person in this forum man.. you don't know anything about music.. you don't know english.. you only know about ARAI KIRUKKAN ARR SONGS. ARRukku kirukku pidichu rottorama alayum katchiya parungal.. oh shoe thudaithu viduvathu yar.. oh 161.142.100.86 aaa...
  
  Interviewer: What is your secret of failure?
  
  ARR: My secret is to copy all the western tunes.
  I tried my best not to copy songs. But i
  am not able to avoid it. I consulted with
  Deva and Anumallik about copying. They told
  me 'don't worry indian fans are not smart
  enough to find those things'. So i followed
  their advice
  
  
  Interviewer: How did then people find out?
  
  ARR: What to do? I totally forgot there is a group
  called Illayaraja fans who seem to know all
  the music in the world. They exposed me like
  clinton was exposed.
  
  Interviewer: What is your next plan?
  
  ARR: To continue copying..
  
  Interviewer: What?
  
  ARR: I just said Illayaraja fans found out. My
  fans are fools.. They have not found out yet.
  Directors and Producers are yet to find out.
  
  Interviewer. Do you think Harris is a threat to u?
  
  ARR: No..
  
  Interviewer: Why
  
  ARR: Anyway i am slow. no problem
  
  Interviewer: Why are you slow?
  
  ARR: See i am not genius like Illayaraja to
  compose 9 songs in 40 minutes. I have to
  search internet mp3s and rip music from them
  and join them to form a song. It takes more
  than 20 days for me
  
  Interviewer: What is your goal in your life
  
  ARR: To score music for 70 movies before i die
  
  Interviewer: Do you think you can do it?
  
  ARR: Konjam kashtamdhan, but hope i will improve
  my speed in copying
  
  Interviewer: Good luck with your copying Thanks
  
  ARR: Thanks
  
  
• From: God (@ 161.142.100.86) on: Tue Sep 17 02:49:43 EDT 2002
  
  The above is another example of an undeveloped moron and mentally retarded being.
  
  Poor idiots. Now they know the meaning of FEAR!
  Hehehehehehe.
  
  
• From: a (@ 166.90.34.146) on: Tue Sep 17 03:09:55 EDT 2002
  
  Idiot, Moron, Mentally retarded these are the only words you use in all forums... Are you born to curse people.. get a life.. man.. i sympathise with the way you get victimised.. More one curses more he is insecure. on that scale God.. you are awfull insecure.. as you scold every IR fan in every thread.
  
  
• From: God (@ 161.142.100.86) on: Tue Sep 17 03:14:40 EDT 2002
  
  Who he eats the chilly, tastes the spiciness.
  If you are not guilty, my words won't hurt you.
  
  
• From: Are Yaar (@ 203.197.141.186) on: Tue Sep 17 06:37:57 EDT 2002
  
  uppu thinnavan thanni kudippan.
  Thappu senjavan dandanai kolvaan
  
  
• From: A.R.Rahman (@ 209.245.42.37) on: Tue Sep 17 10:52:31 EDT 2002
  
  Are Yaar.. unnudiya soot*ai moodi kondu veliye pogireerkala.. unga vilakkathukku nandri mr.pandri. Are Yaarum , Goddum gay partners huh? oruvarukkoruvar jalra adichukittu...
  Rahman gaalidi.. baba oothikichu.. idhaivida kevalamana songs vandade illai tamil ulagathil.
  all magazines said baba music are very bad.. illayaraja never got bad reviews from all magazines for his music like this. Ethana dadava nayadi peyadi vanginalum soraniye illadha jenmangal Are yaar and 'Godd' ..
  
  
  
  
• From: ARR_stinks (@ 209.244.69.147) on: Tue Sep 17 11:08:48 EDT 2002
  
  Now we have found..Are Yaar, God they are all ONE AND THE SAME. THEY CONGRADULATE EACH OTHER. ARE YAAR ASKS GOD TO CONTINUE ATTACKING IR FANS... HE WILL CONTINUE.. NOW IT IS PROVEN BEYOND REASONABLE DOUBT THEY ARE ONE AND THE SAME.. Are Yaar mattikiniya? Then there is ST and Ayo are one and the same.. Get outta here you kirukkans..
  
  Kirukkan No. 1 Are Yaar (also) God
  
  Kirukkan No. 2 ST (also) Ayo pathikichu
  
  
• From: Balu (@ 63.208.244.247) on: Tue Sep 17 11:44:51 EDT 2002
  
  Are Yaar and God.. why are you here.. I find you guys all over without any contribution. You keep abusing everyone in all threads. why don't you show some class in your behviour? If you are seriously music fans, you should have the tolerance to ignore comments.. not like posting everywhere.. I am yet to come across one useful posting from you two guys. Not even a single musical analysis from you two other than abusing others. Awe you can also show restraint.. you used to make class posts like 'symphony' explanation and examples for that. Now you are becoming like them.. control yourself guys.. It has become a street fight now. No matter who wins, TFM forum is the loser.
  
  
• From: God (@ 161.142.100.86) on: Tue Sep 17 20:48:42 EDT 2002
  
  Balu
  I don't know about Are Yaar, but God was created by Uthaman whose latest avatar is Awe.
  If Awe just remained a IR fan, God would not have appeared.
  God's purpose is not to merely discuss for God has seen all and knows all. He is not some aravekkaadu who knows little about TFM.
  
  It is better if you learn some history before you begin lecturing.
  
  
• From: Awe (@ 65.69.57.209) on: Tue Sep 17 21:59:40 EDT 2002
  
  Balu, useful posting and posting from God are oxymorons.. He took this name.. because he thought nobody would scold him.. But yet he with the name of Almighty, he managed to get pounded by everybody. If someone scolds god, then he is directly responsible.. He is taking Gods name in vain.. He will sure go to hell.. With millions of names around in the world.. look what he has chosen.. ugly coward.. gutless pig..
  
  

---

List all pages of this thread

Post comments