Illayaraja or Rahman ?
Topic started by Pras (@ 193.56.241.19) on Thu Dec 7 09:06:29 EST 2000.
All times in EST +10:30 for IST.
waiting for ur answers :)
Responses:
- Old responses
- From: kiru (@ 192.138.149.4)
on: Fri Dec 15 18:02:18 EST 2000
SL,
Theva is trying to assimilate himself into the North American culture. He is starting with pronounciation/spelling. He does not want to speak English with a tamil accent like the way Irish Americans spoke with an Irish accent or the Italians with an Italian..Tamils bad..the African-American lingo of the inner city is the way to go :( .
- From: hihi:-) (@ 134.124.160.10)
on: Fri Dec 15 18:34:32 EST 2000
thEvA wrote:
Hmm .. seemz ARR vs. IR threadz r da most popular ones. Even if the thread is about something elze, somehow ppl manage to get IR vs. ARR goin'. Y's dat in here???
that's a fruedian slip, i suppose. one can keep running but never hide?!? :-))))
take it easy Urvashi.
- From: SL for Theva (@ 15.255.104.11)
on: Fri Dec 15 19:05:28 EST 2000
hihi:)),
hihi:))
- From: Theva (@ 209.183.134.106)
on: Sat Dec 16 00:43:57 EST 2000
Watz UP??
Nah, I don't talk like this. OK, so I come in and it means you guys gang up on me? Datz cool w/ me. You ppl annoy da hell out of me too. Comin' and doin' diz IR vs. ARR krap all da time. I don't have an accent when I speak tamil, english or german. You ppl got a big problem w/ my writing style eh? Hmm, should I change dat just for u hypocrites? Nah, letz annoy some more out of u ppl. Itz quite fun.
Ciao..
- From: Rags (@ 204.114.255.2)
on: Sat Dec 16 12:51:22 EST 2000
Dont ever compare Ilayaraaja with the other COPY CATS like ARR, Deva, SA RAJKUMAR...
IR is evergreen...ARR and others r just passing clouds....
Dont make people go wild...asking such silly questions asking to compare "Great" IR with
"Xerox Copier" ARR
- From: Ahmed (@ 203.199.233.28)
on: Sat Dec 16 13:27:49 EST 2000
ARR--IR...Both are in demand always..ARR is all India Demand and IR is and was in Demand only in South India..That shows ARR is better and more fans want him in HINDI belts also...
Hence the Logic is ARR is superior...
England um Island Than...Andhaman, Fiji um Island Than....OPPIDA Mudiyuma??? ARR is England...Popularity wise....Ali Ahmed
- From: rags (@ 204.114.255.2)
on: Sat Dec 16 13:50:06 EST 2000
Hey...
Keeping telling it and have some solace...but the truth is IR is the BEST....
- From: Divya (@ 161.142.100.81)
on: Sat Dec 16 14:06:26 EST 2000
ARR or IR...both are great MD's ..why bother to discuss who is greater , when the real fact is that u actually listen and enjoy both their works?
- From: Vij (@ 156.153.255.195)
on: Wed Dec 20 07:11:21 EST 2000
Doubter:
I cannot accept your argument on HJ. He has just given one film, and most of the song except the awesome "Vaseegara" are good lifts from some of ARR hit songs. He is just a kid to be compared with anyone like IR or for the matter ARR.
- From: Vij (@ 156.153.255.195)
on: Wed Dec 20 07:14:11 EST 2000
Divya: If we haven't bothered, we wouldn't have had a pile of ARR, IR hits, new releases etc, etc. These topics are on "Popular Demand".
- From: Thilak (@ 212.26.19.156)
on: Wed Dec 20 08:35:54 EST 2000
Kootai Samy from Thirunelveli - Yaelae, niruththungalae. Yaaroda yarai sambaththappaduthi pasearava. IR rasalae. ARR podiyanlae.
Rangachchaari from Adampakkan(new Mylapore) - Kali muthtiduththu. Isai pagavanoodae, chinna payiranai compare pannara. Pagavaanae ithu adukkuma.
Veeran from Ramnad - Appu, yenna appu, ithu adukkuma. Rasavodap poi antha chinnap payalai compare pannarathu. Konja niruththappu.
Fernandaz from Nagerkoil - yalae makka, seeviduvaen. Raasa-vai oram kattip pasina vaiya vettiduvombla.
- THilak
- From: Rags (@ 204.114.255.2)
on: Wed Dec 20 12:12:09 EST 2000
Thilak...great man i like it....
- From: venki (@ 12.35.64.19)
on: Wed Dec 20 12:59:46 EST 2000
That is nice Thilak,
I enjoyed reading
- From: Subbu (@ 193.113.185.164)
on: Wed Dec 20 13:41:35 EST 2000
Thilak - that was a nice one.
Ahmed - Pls listen to Minnalae... Hasn't Harris broken the myth that is ARR's music ? (or sophisticated recording of patterns with an odd good tune in one of the songs...)
Is there anyone who can match Raja's composing power - be it tunes/Harmony/BGM/Speed ? Not yet my dear...
- From: UV (@ 134.113.200.17)
on: Wed Dec 20 14:36:28 EST 2000
HJ is here to stay,like our Deva you cant ignore him from now on he will be the pain in btt for ARR just like the mega copier Deva for IR and just like how people left IR to Deva same way people who wants things done fast and dont want postpone,and wait for unknown time will go for HJ as such tamil industry needs some change had enough of SAR,DEVAS,hope Karthik Raja gives that break or may be HJ will do it
way to go HJ.
Atleast HJ had lot of hype around him because of his friend or ex-friend ARR
read from one of the magazines that ARR threw him out!!
- From: Thilak (@ 212.26.19.156)
on: Thu Dec 21 04:26:02 EST 2000
Hi Rags/Subbu/Venki,
Thanks for your comments.
- Thilak
- From: afcn (@ 63.196.0.126)
on: Thu Dec 21 12:24:51 EST 2000
hey guys will u ever stop cribbing about ARR and the others..viv a vis IR.if IR is the greatest ever then why even care talking about who is better and who is best...shed such insecurity guys.
- From: Pras (@ 193.56.241.19)
on: Fri Dec 22 03:45:07 EST 2000
hello afcn,
I posted that topic just because some of us think that ARR is better than IR, and I wanted to show them that their thoughts were wrong ! and not because i am not sure that IR is the best as u think !!
- From: a.a (@ 203.197.135.203)
on: Fri Dec 22 12:35:56 EST 2000
Take the case of Keralites in and out Kerala...For the last forty years KJY is the Best singer in the World. Even one argues with them , they will end up saying Jesudoss is the world's Best...
Adhey Vyathi...than namma IR fans Kitteyum...For another forty years IR fans will say IR,IR,IR...Pakkathu oore PAZHAKKAM....Sounds really stupid?? A.A
- From: RameshG (@ 206.175.176.2)
on: Fri Dec 22 13:14:41 EST 2000
Anything new is better than old - Why becuase it is the trend. Attumandhai kumbal. Very stupid too.
GR
- From: S (@ 208.24.179.211)
on: Fri Dec 22 15:15:29 EST 2000
Keralites don't know who Jesudoss is. They know one singer whose name is very familiar to it(YesuDas).
- From: Rags (@ 204.114.255.2)
on: Tue Dec 26 14:34:29 EST 2000
Listen to "Thendral varum" song from Friends....
Ultimate piece....
Good composition...
any comments...
- From: IR Fan (@ 35.9.50.117)
on: Tue Dec 26 22:42:35 EST 2000
all songs in friends are superb.
ARR fans keep saying IR's time is over and he should move over and let ARR take over and then what?? . at this stage his compositions are still stunning.. if ARR can deliver what IR has done over all these years, then he can take over. looking at the quality of music he has been giving of late I think the guy is saturated maybe ARR has had his time and should move over now!. IR's place is stead fast as his music for years to come. You can't beat legends,to be compared to a legend you have to be one yourself ie ARR has to be.Is he ?? ARR fans justify.
- From: Saitan (@ )
on: Sun Feb 4 07:11:34 EST 2001
hehe rombe nanna iruku hehe. IR ode AR.R oppiduvatha? hehe pongada poi soliyai parungeppa athan sami hehe ;-D. Rasa, ayya,IR innum isainyanithanpa athule santeghame ille. Avar ode love songs, sentiment songs ellam AR.R tottu parke mudiyumapa? AR.R etanai sad songs tune panirukar? Avarode sad songs ellam ore mathirithan iruku, rombe fast bits, etho oru song than manasule nikkuthu,but Ir ode sad songs and sentiment songs ellam innum kathule olikuthu. Inime yarrachum IR ode AR.R compare panininge mavene vaayileye kuthuven.Ir the greattttttt
- From: Saitan (@ )
on: Sun Feb 4 07:12:04 EST 2001
hehe rombe nanna iruku hehe. IR ode AR.R oppiduvatha? hehe pongada poi soliyai parungeppa athan sami hehe ;-D. Rasa, ayya,IR innum isainyanithanpa athule santeghame ille. Avar ode love songs, sentiment songs ellam AR.R tottu parke mudiyumapa? AR.R etanai sad songs tune panirukar? Avarode sad songs ellam ore mathirithan iruku, rombe fast bits, etho oru song than manasule nikkuthu,but Ir ode sad songs and sentiment songs ellam innum kathule olikuthu. Inime yarrachum IR ode AR.R compare panininge mavene vaayileye kuthuven.IR the greattttttt 4 eva
- From: Saitan (@ )
on: Sun Feb 4 07:16:07 EST 2001
hehe eh eh hehe saitan is here. vanakampa__/\__. aporam oru vishyam solle maranthutten. Yarupa Deva fans? hehe eh eh hehe AR.R copycat na Deva copycat ode appan. hehe eh eh hehe. saitan unmaiye soluthu IR music oru thani ragam. AR.R rombe western music copy adikuran,Deva- IR music copy adikuranpa. Ithil unmaiyane musician nambe IR thanpa avar vali thani vali hehe eh eh hehe:-D.
- From: kavuNdamaNi (@ 192.135.244.69)
on: Mon Feb 5 03:43:37 EST 2001
saitan,
mariyAdhayA indha edatha vuttu 'yescape' Ayiru...illa 'butti' la adaichiduvEn.
- From: pras (@ 193.56.241.19)
on: Tue Feb 6 10:25:44 EST 2001
test
- From: sloshed (@ 64.154.26.250)
on: Wed Feb 7 22:41:57 EST 2001
hi guys...well i am new to all this ...but one thing makes me feel i am a part of you ...IR...
i feel proud i am born in an era ...where i could listen to illayaraja....who could ever come out of his enchanting melodies..the instrumentations..the interludes...(i am listening to the song.."kathakelu "from michel mmk...) awesome work.....
i find most of the arguements based on IR vs ARR ..gimme a break...IR is an ocean of music...THAT IT...nothing more to it...NO reason to compare him with anyone
but as i am equally happy about IR...as a tamil i feel equally proud of ARR...He made the whole india turn to tamil films...he brought a new sound...lets appreciate him ...he is a talented guy...he made the cassette industry rise...the so called BOLLYWOOD.. had to wait for him...he made tamil music go global...he sung with MJ at munich...he may not be a genius as IR...but the truth of the matter is ...he's done what no tamil could ever do...not even BHARATHI..COULD DO IT..he spread tamil music the world over....i have seen hindhi ppl buying tanil cassetees in bombay just becos its ARR..
you may blame it on marketing in his age..but still you have to reach the ppl...ARR knows how to doit...IR is evergreen as ever....his HEYRAM would certify it...i wouldnt know how many ppl appreciated the song "isayil thodagunthamma"..i thought that was a master piece..
ARR sings his heart....his "dil se re"..was a classic too...what ARR doesnt know is BGM'S .interludes....maybe his way is different...he's doing it becos...people are accepting it...
for those who appreciate good music...THERE IS NOONE LIKE IR....
IR is a genius..ARR is talented...knows the trade..
i maybe rong ..correct me..
- From: rags (@ 162.48.138.249)
on: Thu Feb 8 08:51:39 EST 2001
sloshed,
i agree with u....
n...one of my favorites is "isayil thodanguthama" song from hey ram....its a master piece....
List all pages of this thread
Post comments
Sections:
Home -
TFM Magazine -
Forum -
Wiki -
POW -
oPod -
Lyrics -
Pictures -
Music Notes -
Forums: Current Topics - Ilayaraja Albums - A.R. Rahman Albums - TFM Oldies - Fun & Games
Ilaiyaraja: Releases - News - Share Music - AR Rahman: Releases - News - AOTW - Tweets -
Discussions: MSV - YSR - GVP - Song Requests - Song stats - Raga of songs - Copying - Tweets
Database: Main - Singers - Music Director's - Lyricists Fun: PP - EKB - Relay - Satires - Quiz
Forums: Current Topics - Ilayaraja Albums - A.R. Rahman Albums - TFM Oldies - Fun & Games
Ilaiyaraja: Releases - News - Share Music - AR Rahman: Releases - News - AOTW - Tweets -
Discussions: MSV - YSR - GVP - Song Requests - Song stats - Raga of songs - Copying - Tweets
Database: Main - Singers - Music Director's - Lyricists Fun: PP - EKB - Relay - Satires - Quiz