Topic started by xml (@ 128.148.68.110) on Sat Jan 17 18:46:32 EST 2004.
All times in EST +10:30 for IST.
I want prove that apart from western artist ARR has copied many song from indian MD's.Many of the songs were composed by HJ when he was with him.Let me give the details of them.
Arasatchi: Mr.Romeo:
Saiyo Saiyo(Style,Inspried) Muthu Malai
Arasatchi: Baba:
Chant of Arasatci(Starting same) Theme
Arasatci: Mr.Romeo:
20 Vayasu(Style,Backing) Melisaiye
Arasatchi: Kadhal Virus:
20 Vayasu(Starting same) Bailamore
Arasatchi: Jeans:
Mohalai(Usage of Instruments) Hairabba
Ullam Kekumea: Muthu:
Mazhai Mazhai(Just listen) Meena's Intro(BGM)
Ullam Kekumea: Uyire:
O Maname (Backing) Poongratrile
Ullam Kekumae: Kadhalan:
Dho Dho(2nd Interlude-Same style/beat) Urvasi
Saamy: May Maadham:
Veepamaram Madras Suthi Paaka
(Style & Heavilly Inspired by Beats from ARR)
Kaake Kaake: Thenali:
Ooru Ooril(Backing -One Part) Swasame
Kaake Kaake/RHDTM: Vandhe Madharam:
Ondra Renda/Dilko(Backings) Only You
Saami: Taj Mahal:
Thirunalveli(Heavily Inspired) Thirupatchi Aruvale
Saami: Sangamam:
Idhuthana(The style & feel of the song) Marghazhi
Saami: Karuthamma:
Pudichirukku (interlude) Thenmerku
Saami: Vande Madharam:
Ithudhan(1st part) Only You
Minnale: Alaipayuthey:
Venmathiye(same instruments) Evano Oruvan
Minnale: Kadhal Dhesam:
Azhagiye Theeye(Interlude) Mustafa
Minnale: Thakshak:
Poopol(Backing) Dheem Dhirana
Majunu: Advertisement:
Mudher kanave(small part) Leo Coffe
Majunu: Alaipayuthey:
Gulmore Malare(same) Pachai Nirame
Laysa Laysa: Lagaan:
Laysa Laysa(small part) Opalanhare
Laysa Laysa: Thiruda Thiruda:
Ilimai Inimai(interlude) VeerapandiKotayille
Laysa Laysa: Rhthym:
Aval Uzhaga Azhigye(backing) Anbe
Vaasu/Vetri & RHDTM: JEANS:
OPrema & Rehna Rehna Tere(backing) Hairabba
Samurai: Kandukoinden 2:
Athithadi Appatha(interlude 1) BGM
Samurai: Thakshak/Star:
Athithadi Appatha(interlude 2) Dheem/ThomKaruvil
Samurai: Mr.Romeo:
Athithadi Appatha(interlude 3) Romeo Attam Pootal
Majunu: Pukar:
Mercury Melea(simular) Humrahi Jabho Mastana
12b: Iruvar:
Oru Punnagai(Backing) Kannai Kathi Kolathe
Songs copied from IR
Maveeran:Enswasakatre
Othungu othungu:Jimbalakka
Valter vetrivel:gentleman
Chinna rasave:ottahathai kattikko
Athma:Puthiyamugam
Ninaikkindra thendrale:Kannukku mai azhagu
Nooravathu naal:alaipayuthe
Vizhilieley:snehithane
Songs copied from MSV
Thangapathakkathin meley:Ennavizhzi azhage(kathalar dinam)
song-Sippi irukkuthu(varumaien niram sigappu):roja roja(kathalar dinam)
Song copied from YSR
Kunnuru poochatti(velai):Dolna(Parasuram)
and many more!!!
Responses:
- From: Piratheepan (@ 68.88.236.88)
on: Sat Jan 17 20:33:48 EST 2004
wat an idiot....lol those ARR songs came waaaaay before HJ's songs.
- From: STONE COLD (@ 210.186.79.171)
on: Sat Jan 17 21:03:36 EST 2004
very funny,
why don't u post it here?
http://www.newtfmpage.com/forum/14474.14.06.09.html
- From: : ) (@ 202.156.2.218)
on: Sat Jan 17 22:04:56 EST 2004
hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha
- From: curses (@ 219.65.96.227)
on: Sat Jan 17 22:22:56 EST 2004
Piratheepan..
cudnt have put it better! :)
- From: C~P (@ 61.1.200.152)
on: Sat Jan 17 23:23:28 EST 2004
those ARR songs came b4 HJ songs...yeah...so?? ... wat does that mean?? ... xml thaan sollaraar-la!! ... ellarum kaelunga!!
btw Roja Roja copied from Sippi Irukkuthu??!! yeah, right! .... dont u know that Chinna Chinna Aasa is an outright copy from Raakkamma Kayya Thattu?! ...u missed it perhaps ... i'll suggest one more song that u can add..
ARR copied 'Ennuyire Ennuyire' song fro 'Thu Hi Thu Sathrangi Re'! .. copied from Hindi!! ;-)
- From: jokes please (@ 210.214.131.15)
on: Sun Jan 18 00:42:42 EST 2004
Also Vandemataram copied from Vande mataram sung in schools ;)
- From: dinesh (@ 210.186.42.74)
on: Sun Jan 18 07:21:46 EST 2004
hahahahha,this is really a biggest joke in newtfmpage.com...hahahahha,xml,i taut u were briliant,didint know u will turn up to be a dumb guy...those songs were copied by hj...not arr u fool!!
- From: cell (@ 202.156.2.218)
on: Sun Jan 18 08:52:06 EST 2004
i'm rollin on my floor.... and havin a terrible stomach pain....
- From: Cowboy Maadasami (@ 213.42.2.13)
on: Sun Jan 18 09:27:26 EST 2004
xml is right.Subbudu confirms that ARR is using the same Sa,ri,Ga,ma,pa,dha,ni,sa as in saraLi varisai.
www.subbudu.com/saraLi/ARRcopy.html
- From: C~P (@ 61.1.201.90)
on: Sun Jan 18 09:53:53 EST 2004
Cowboy,
xml-kkae link-a?! ... romba thaan nakkala poachu ungalukku!
- From: paran (@ 203.123.16.168)
on: Sun Jan 18 21:47:05 EST 2004
XML...are u by any chance a son of Crazy Mohan...ivvalo superb-a comedy screenwriting seiringale..
wow..
- From: XML (@ 151.205.116.54)
on: Sun Jan 18 22:34:41 EST 2004
This just in...
This Rahman guy copied some "Lakeer" songs in to his Tamil movie "Rhythm"..
Can you believe it???
XML
- From: C~P (@ 61.1.201.178)
on: Sun Jan 18 22:36:33 EST 2004
Paran,
avar namma NSK-oda marupiravi....illaena ippadi sensible comedy panna mudiyuma?! ... konnuttaru pa!
- From: XML (@ 151.205.116.54)
on: Sun Jan 18 22:37:56 EST 2004
Well couple of those ARR songs came before HJ but the music is HJs....and this proves that ARR copied HJ :)
XML
- From: XML (@ 151.205.116.54)
on: Sun Jan 18 22:40:11 EST 2004
ARR even copied some english songs too...
If you dont believe me please listen to "Bombay Dreams"
XML
- From: SDJ (@ 151.205.116.54)
on: Sun Jan 18 22:42:10 EST 2004
XML:
I didnt see any reply from you for these senseless ARR fans. So i used ur name for couple of posts. Hope this helps...
S D J
- From: paran (@ 203.123.16.168)
on: Sun Jan 18 22:42:41 EST 2004
XML.....pothumma unnode timed-comdey script...
yennale sirike mudiyille...please...stop it...
- From: paran (@ 203.123.16.168)
on: Sun Jan 18 22:44:46 EST 2004
SDJ..u forgot another thing
*************** on behalf of XML************
that stupid Rahman..shamelessly copied a CHinese song to.....
maan..this guy knows nothing but copying?!!!!
**********************************************
adn it comes from HJ -fan..hehehehe
anyway..if true HJ was teh reason behing all the tunes used by Rahman...shouldn't we be calling HJ as a RECYCLER..coz he never moved from his old tunes...did he?
- From: C~P (@ 61.1.201.178)
on: Sun Jan 18 22:47:35 EST 2004
HJ = recycle
Deva = tricycle
SAR = unicycle
manisharma = bicycle
scooter, car ellam yaaru? ... yaen? .. start pannuvoma??!
- From: paran (@ 203.123.16.168)
on: Sun Jan 18 22:53:04 EST 2004
appo HJ thaan Cycle, Cycle, Cycle Jackson-a?
- From: C~P (@ 61.1.201.178)
on: Sun Jan 18 23:00:13 EST 2004
HJ is Cycle Jackson - Cycle Jackson (recycled!)
Deva is Cycle Cycle Cylce Jackson (tricycle!)
intha varusaiyila poagum...
- From: paran (@ 203.123.16.168)
on: Sun Jan 18 23:06:42 EST 2004
ops..sorry paa....konjam Logic-le Half Boil pottuten...
- From: C~P (@ 61.1.201.178)
on: Sun Jan 18 23:24:08 EST 2004
Half Boil-a? ... enna OTMP-a?! :-)
- From: paran (@ 203.123.16.168)
on: Sun Jan 18 23:29:13 EST 2004
last nite OTMP-pa...innaikum OTMP yennaku yen GF kudupange-ne ninaikiren
- From: S D J (@ 151.205.116.54)
on: Sun Jan 18 23:30:09 EST 2004
Man..... that was funny..I am laughing my A$$ off...
Now coming back to reality:
As far as I know HJ is ok. I don’t know anything about him copying (i didn’t hear any complete copies...to me bits and pieces does not count as COPIES). But he is heavily inspired by ARR and I think that’s a good thing. Nowadays ARR is trying to stay away from his 90's style and HJ is filling up the void.
Now all of us have to admit that HJ produced some excellent music and he has talent. I wish all the best for him.
To me in tfm these are the people who can produce music.
ARR (BOYS...E20U18...KKS...)
HJ (couple of good songs)
YSR (Kadal kondean was amazing)
VS (couple of good songs)
This is just my opinion. You have all the right to disagree. But just don’t try to prove that your music knowledge/taste/preference is better than mine :)
- From: Nattamai (@ 64.246.11.20)
on: Mon Jan 19 03:30:29 EST 2004
Yo Xml, (arr vs hj, ysr : antha threadai kanomaiya, enga pochchu)
inna naina ippdi solre. namma mannan inge irukka vendiya aale illappa. avaru tamil nattula porannthathu thaan thappu, mukkiyama tamil padaththukku muzic pottu time ellaththaiyum waste pannittaaru. tamil padaththukku muzic pottu jeyikarathellam velai vetti illatha pasanga seirathu. londonkaran, chinakaran thanya vishayam therinjavan. english karane avara mozart-nu solran, namma sanangalukku puriyaathu ithellam. evlo arbuthama muzic (baba, parasuram, udaya, boys, e20u18, kks nnu) podararu annaththe, sanangalukku ithuvum puriya mattenguthu. sari hindikaran pinnadi ponavathu paravaillainnu pona; nayak, tehzeeb, lakeer-nnu avangalukkum puriya mattenguthu. sari cd, cassette ellam yen vikka mattuthunna, piracynnu solli solli puriya vaika vendiyatha irukku. ennaththa solla.
oru vishayam annaaththe, singapore, malaysia-vila boys cd audio industrya revive panni irukkunnu namma paran annaaththe solraaru. singapore, malaysia, burma, srilanka-nnu Gopal pulpodikku appuram namma thundu mannan than pamous ippa. enna purinjitha?
vartta :)
- From: xml (@ 128.148.68.110)
on: Mon Jan 19 10:58:27 EST 2004
Yeah
I made a mistake with the title.
It should be HJ's composed song in ARR's name.They are not copied song,but composed by HJ.Is that OK.
List all pages of this thread
Post comments
Forums: Current Topics - Ilayaraja Albums - A.R. Rahman Albums - TFM Oldies - Fun & Games
Ilaiyaraja: Releases - News - Share Music - AR Rahman: Releases - News - AOTW - Tweets -
Discussions: MSV - YSR - GVP - Song Requests - Song stats - Raga of songs - Copying - Tweets
Database: Main - Singers - Music Director's - Lyricists Fun: PP - EKB - Relay - Satires - Quiz