Topic started by Jay (@ 203.124.234.164) on Thu Mar 13 00:36:06 EST 2003.
All times in EST +10:30 for IST.
R P Patnaik, the name may be new for TFM listeners, but he is considered as the Number ONE music direcor in Andhra Pradesh (Telugu Industry). R P Patnaik is so famous in Telugu, that Mega Star Chiranjeevi asked him to compose one song last year for his previous film Indra, which had music by Mani Sharma.
R P Patnaik has super hits in Telugu for films such as;
Chitram (which was dubbed in Tamil).
Nuvve Nenu (which is remade in Hindi with Tushar and Anitha as Yeh Dil).
Eashwar.
Jayam.
Now Jayam which was directed in Telugu by Tejaa, is being remade in Tamil as; Jayam starring new comers (same heroine Sada). The same music scores from the Telugu Jayam will be used in Tamil Jayam as well. The Telugu Jayam, song, Naanu Raanu... was used by our own copy cat Deva in Vijay's, Bhagavathy as Kai Kai vakkira..., a straight lift.
Telugu music lovers accepted, Vidhyasagar, Deva, Ilayaraja, A R Rahman, Harris Jayaraj. Will Tamil music lovers accept R P Patnaik, like Mani Sharma??
Post Comments.
Responses:
- From: dinesh (@ 210.186.42.83)
on: Thu Mar 13 05:21:25 EST 2003
His beautiful scores in Chitiram was not accepted by TFM..wut more u wanna expect from them????
- From: Genius (@ 65.205.71.101)
on: Fri Mar 14 16:53:27 EST 2003
Dubbing songs never work in any language for that matter. Eg. Super Police, Asokan, Ootam etc. by Ar Rahman.
Original songs always have their place. Let RBP score atamil original and lets see.
Lets not hype his music capabilities and be his own demon..
- From: Bala. (@ 4.37.102.100)
on: Fri Mar 14 17:09:45 EST 2003
R.P.Patnaik doesn't have that much calibre like Mani Sharma.His songs are monotonomous.He didnt even work in 25 movies before that people start thinking that he is repeating the tunes.The bad part is that he use to sing most of the songs in his movies which is really absurd.Already we have hell lot of composers in our industry.. I dont think RPP has something unique to stand in our industry which has rich knowledge on music.
- From: raghuram (@ 63.193.193.190)
on: Sat Mar 15 07:40:49 EST 2003
RP is big con man. He recycled cleverly for few movies. And the secret is out. Right now is no more. He is just banking on one director Teja who gives hime life. Rest all his films the music sucked big time.
His problems:no versatality. same set of instruments, he sings all songs (he has a female voice), and very few tunes and uses them again and again.
SA Rajkumar is much better.
Mani Sharma is number one.
- From: Pranav (@ 202.142.68.94)
on: Sun Mar 16 00:03:14 EST 2003
RPP is good . Can you name any MD who does not uses his old tunes with some modifications..?
There is a lot of MDS who do that..
like --
ARR
SAR
HJ
Mani Sharma
Anu Malik
IR
MSV
YSR and most of all the MDs do thaat. Don't say only RPP does that. You can enjoy his songs..
- From: suhas lakshmi (@ 12.22.60.1)
on: Mon Mar 17 19:13:45 EST 2003
http://movies.indiainfo.com/telugu/chartbusters/8.html
says that RP has a string of flops and nobody is touching him with a barge pole.
Tamil film is dominated by Vidyasaga, Yuvan, ARR, IR, Deva, Harris etc. It is very difficult for a new MD. Mani Sharma had to struggle (his Narasimma) was flop, but he had to give a melodious album like Shajahan to settle. So it is not easy to straight away take a telugu song and put in tamil. RP may not survive.
- From: shysun (@ 61.11.81.141)
on: Mon Mar 17 21:09:28 EST 2003
rpp has already faded in telugu ,there is a bleak chance for him to create a scare of sorts anyways goodluck to him he has direct lifted a few raaja songs for your info
- From: A,RAJKUMAR (@ )
on: Fri Jun 20 09:07:31 EDT 2003
TO
Telugu film industry
Music Director RP. Patnaik
Dear sir
I am working osmania university .I am trying film industry job please kindly help him
Than you
A,RAJKUMAR
HNO 5-2-84
premavathipet
Rajendranagar
pin 500030
- From: A,RAJKUMAR (@ )
on: Fri Jun 20 09:10:18 EDT 2003
TO
Telugu film industry
Music Director RP. Patnaik
Dear sir
I am working osmania university .I am trying film industry job please kindly help him Wating for reply
Than you
A,RAJKUMAR
HNO 5-2-84
premavathipet
Rajendranagar
pin 500030
- From: ha ha (@ 157.95.211.50)
on: Wed Jun 25 01:51:59 EDT 2003
gults have no orginality
- From: Teja (@ 12.240.72.64)
on: Wed Jun 25 02:12:47 EDT 2003
RP is a history even in Telugu now.
He is just 3 film wonder and after those 3 films, he started lifting IR, Vidyasagar tunes, folk songs from other languages and finally his own songs.
- From: PALLAVI (@ 68.50.133.106)
on: Fri Jun 27 15:08:45 EDT 2003
Hope this mail goes to R.P Patnaik.
Hello R.P Patnaik garu my name is Pallavi. I know you. Do you remember you used to come to Punjagutta house. Do you remember gopi and radhi from punjagutta and I met you there. Anyway you are really doing good job. Email me. Thanks
- From: sena (@ 128.148.68.110)
on: Fri Jun 27 22:14:38 EDT 2003
RPP is not very great MD.Manasantha nuvve is a hit movie.So th songs are popular.
His music is nod good as DEVI SRI PRASAD,MANI SHARMA,KOTI.These three MD's are excellent.
- From: sena (@ 128.148.68.110)
on: Fri Jun 27 22:17:00 EDT 2003
RPP copied VS malayalam song as duniha duniha.It was a big issue in telugu film industry.
- From: jibi (@ 67.31.6.220)
on: Fri Jun 27 23:49:53 EDT 2003
i saw tht in news ..which telugu movie is that song from ... i'll confirm which mal song is it
- From: kIRAN (@ 161.142.100.87)
on: Sat Jun 28 01:00:10 EDT 2003
His tunes more suit HINDI than TFM
- From: sena (@ 128.148.68.110)
on: Sat Jun 28 17:51:19 EDT 2003
In manasantha nuve tooniga tooniga RPP copied from VS's malayalam music.
http://www.raaga.com/channels/telugu/movie/A0000217.html
RPP is not a great MD. To me DEVISRI PRASAD,MANISHARMA,KOTI are the best.
- From: Sai Sekhar (@ 57.66.8.14)
on: Tue Jul 1 14:01:15 EDT 2003
Yes MR. RP Patnaik is a genius in Music since his childhood. His compositions has been superb, which proves the same. Hope he reaches new heights in the coming days.
Sai Sekhar Patnaik
- From: jibi (@ 67.31.29.135)
on: Thu Jul 3 00:44:43 EDT 2003
just listen to the original song in mal by vs released in 1998
listen to kannadi kudum by kjy and chitra
http://www.musicindiaonline.com/music/l/VV000F00
and by r.p patnaik in 2001 listen to tunooega tuneooga
http://www.musicindiaonline.com/music/l/XY00000C1A
- From: as (@ 128.148.68.110)
on: Sat Jul 5 19:15:15 EDT 2003
http://www.telugu.cinesouth.com/english/specials/interviews/devisriprasad.shtml
- From: MS (@ 129.252.25.241)
on: Wed Jul 9 20:38:20 EDT 2003
jibi:
hmm..what a pity ! I was of the opinion after hearing the song "nee tolisaariga" frm telugu movie "santhosham" that Patnaik is one of the music directors to watch. Seems like VS is the only dependable music director for melodies.
- From: S.nazir basha and reshma (@ 202.54.133.68)
on: Tue Jul 15 10:15:49 EDT 2003
mr.rp,
you have earned the fame in tonnes and soon followed the jealousy as well and now people are spending more time to find out how and from where you made a tune than what you spend to really make a tune. we have watched your tv episode in nijam (court concept) the questions posed at you were simply unfair. we watched your hurt feelings and be brave to face the unfair world. success is yours fame is yours spotlight is yours. you are success by all means. you are doing an art and not charity for giving opportunities to all and sundry. go ahead and scale new heights the world will follow you. your fans will follow you. hope to see you at higher heights with all the distractions of a football game and with all them countering you, you should reach the goal.
be happy.
we will be too happy to receive a response otherwise also we will be happy.
thanking you,,,
nazir basha and reshma, nellore
cell. 94402 75293
e.mail: nazir28@yahoo.co.in
- From: Rama Krishna (@ )
on: Thu Sep 11 06:23:17 EDT 2003
Dear RP Patnaik Garu
I am really deligthful to listen your songs. But you please do not sing all songs. people need change. your tunes are really great.
- From: dundi22@hotmail.com (@ 203.193.149.188)
on: Thu Sep 11 06:26:27 EDT 2003
Dear RP Patnaik
Please prove your ability in your coming project with pavan Kalyan
- From: KRISHNA VENI (@ )
on: Sat Oct 4 01:40:20 EDT 2003
TO
TELUGU film indursty
music director R.P patnaik
iam great fan of u.iam really enjoy u r songs .iam eager to join with u and sing with u.i think u will mail me .please mail me.
one of u r fan.
List all pages of this thread
Back to the Forum
Post comments
Forums: Current Topics - Ilayaraja Albums - A.R. Rahman Albums - TFM Oldies - Fun & Games
Ilaiyaraja: Releases - News - Share Music - AR Rahman: Releases - News - AOTW - Tweets -
Discussions: MSV - YSR - GVP - Song Requests - Song stats - Raga of songs - Copying - Tweets
Database: Main - Singers - Music Director's - Lyricists Fun: PP - EKB - Relay - Satires - Quiz