Topic started by Gandhi (@ 210.186.60.16) on Sat Mar 1 10:52:00 EST 2003.
All times in EST +10:30 for IST.
Vaanavil Talent Quest is a prestigious talent quest for amateur singers, with the top prize being a Kia make car. VTQ No. 1’s winner was Sheila Raman who got to sing a song under Bharadwaj in the movie Engey Enathu Kavithai. Bharadwaj was one of the judges of the finals.
Last year’s winner was Alinda Alphonse and she is expected to sing under Harris Jeyraj’s music, who was one the judges of the finals. She sang Rukku rukku rukku splendidly and was a good comedienne too.
Who will be the winner of VTQ 2003 and who will be the MD for the finals?
As usual we will have to wait for Tamil new year to know the results. In the meantime, share your thoughts here.
Responses:
- From: Gandhi (@ 210.186.60.16)
on: Sat Mar 1 10:53:03 EST 2003
The first heat was shown just now. The songs sang, the singers and the points they obtained are as follows -
1. Unnai paartha pinbu naan - Poobalan (6.11 pts)
2. Hello Mr. Ethirkatchi - Revathy (5.924 pts)
3. Evano oruthan yaasikkiraan – Shantha Kumari (6.368 pts)
4. Ithukkenna artham – Sethupathy (6.251 pts)
5. Athimara poovithu - Shoba (6.284 pts)
6. Siragu illai naan poovillai – Punitha (5.95 pts)
7. Pattu vanna rosaavaam – Mathan (6.917 pts)
8. Poosu manjal poosu manjal – Nageswari (5.974 pts)
9. Konjum thenkaasi thamizh paingkili – Parvathi (6.177 pts)
10. Raaja raja cholan naan – Sivabalan (5.993 pts)
11. En vaanile ore vennilaa – Amutha (6.583)
12. Minnalai pidithu minnalai pidithu – Ganesan (6.936 pts)
13. Machaan meesai veesaruvaa – Helen (6.477 pts)
- From: Gandhi (@ 210.186.60.16)
on: Sat Mar 1 10:55:15 EST 2003
Some comments -
The host Govind and Sumitha were okay, but I don't understand why Govind needs to laugh at his own jokes.
Surprisingly there were a couple of fast songs sung as opposed to melodies. Helen was very good.
If given a choice I would have picked Evano oruvan as the best song sung.
- From: Prabhu (@ 61.11.21.142)
on: Sun Mar 2 01:39:52 EST 2003
Gandhi, is this a TV or live prog and where is it taking place?? I assume its in malaysia
- From: Paran (@ 210.193.13.185)
on: Sun Mar 2 03:15:39 EST 2003
GUys....
Vaanavil is a channel in Malaysian Sattelite TV (similar to cable TV)...
it is a recorder programme...(for most of the legs)...only Final will be LIVE....which, so far being judges by famous Musicians from India...
as said,
First Year - Bharadwaj
Second Year - Harris Jeyaraj, Harri Raghavendra
Third Year - Any idea guys?
It is the best talen searching competition I have ever seen in this region (South East Asia)....as it involves, in Singing, Acting and/or any other talents.......
Kudos to Vaanavil for bringing such a good show...
- From: Paran (@ 210.193.13.185)
on: Sun Mar 2 03:16:42 EST 2003
CORRECTION
*******************
it is a recorder programme...(for most of the legs)...only Final will be LIVE....which, so far being judges by famous Musicians from India...
*********************
SHOULD BE :
it is a recorded programme...(for most of the legs)...only Final will be LIVE....which, so far being judged by famous MDs/Singers from India...
- From: SingerInMalaysia (@ 210.186.52.28)
on: Fri Mar 7 03:57:33 EST 2003
Shantha Kumari has done a great job but no chance for semifinal round. The judges are all O.K except K.J Babu. he is a blady idiot who never like to give chances to new faces but has been announced " puthu muga kalainyargalai nereya arimugam seytha perumai ivarai serum". I dont know why Vaanavil let this stupid bugger to be the judge "enname perusa kilichitta mathiri" He is only a keyboard actor with playing disks on his keyboard and act like playing..
- From: Nalla Sivam (@ 219.92.48.192)
on: Wed Mar 12 11:18:10 EST 2003
I donno y fast song w/o good pronouncition got higher marks like Ithukkenna artham song
- From: chitra (@ 203.106.144.107)
on: Fri Mar 14 00:59:20 EST 2003
i think i know who is going to be this year.its anuradha sriram and thenisai thendral deva.
- From: LP (@ )
on: Fri Apr 11 21:26:29 EDT 2003
The VTQ Finals will be held at Gentings tonight.
Judges will be Deva and Anuratha Sriram
Bhardwaj is making a guest appearance.
The ten finalists and the songs they will sing are:
1. Pathiyil Ravidass Narayanan
- Andhi mazhai pozhigirathu
2. Shamini Ramasamy
- Ival oru ilankuruvi
3. Saravanan Subramaniam
- Poo poley maan poley
4. Amutha Mohan
- Kalaimagal kai poruley
5. Jegathisan Nagarajah
- Sakthi kodu
6. Valarmathi Arumugam
- Palamuthir solaiyil paarthavan
7. Saravana Kumar Narayanan
- Palamuthir solai enakkaagathaan
8. Anuradha Murugesu
- Etho minnal
9. Madan Raj Nagarajan
- Thanga thaamarai magaley
10. Kavitha Subramaniam
- Athaan varuvaaga
Who will walk away with the KIA car?
- From: Guru (@ 202.188.228.94)
on: Sun Apr 13 02:01:13 EDT 2003
This years Vaanavil Talent Quest really sucks!! and y'all know what I mean....it's like all the judgements from the beginning till the GRAND FINALS are full of crap. Even the lead judge "thennisai thendral Deva" desicion was backened up...I wonder how the local judges can make Anuradha the winner....She is a good singer...but we all know that there are finalist that were better than her.
Anuradha was in the 7th rank when she entered final round (6.5 something)....and you can see that Madhan raj, saravana kumar, kavithas....their marks from the beginning was high even in their finals.... hey man.... I can say that most of the songs "Easy" even no "sarigama".My choice was jegathesan.....he was awesome! I disagree with his points from the beginning...he should be the winner if you ask me....look at this one ...easy songs get high marks...tough ones get low marks....c'mmonlah waey....I suggest that we have a public voting next year..coz only public have the power to predict a singer's destiny....only they can create a successful singer....And about our local judges this year...the point giving was disappointing.. PUBLIC VOTING IS THE BEST...2002's VTQ was a good example...this year was totally out...OUT.
- From: MR.MC.GOO (@ 210.186.172.21)
on: Sun Apr 13 06:08:16 EDT 2003
Very very sad this year's PTP coz Deva's rejected choice was announced as the first prize winner. All the audience was shout for Madhan.That should follow the prosedure. The winner from all SMS and local judge must go for the final round with Deva & Deva should pick up the winners. I also think they should tell the viewers how the points are calculated. The sad thing is the best not been selected... Anurada Sriram also sad coz the winners are lost from the list. I think Kavita should be the winner. This year's PTP is really insulating Deva as chief judge. Anurada 's points were low in begining, only 6.598 at 7th place. I THINK DEVA'S FANS MUST BE ANGRY NOWWW. I hope if Vannil wants to do a contest like this again, must think many times.....and give good results
- From: MR.MC.GOO (@ 210.186.172.21)
on: Sun Apr 13 06:16:31 EDT 2003
Can we have vote 4 PTP here?? ?Or send me ur votes to me pls >>>
- From: MR.MC.GOO (@ 210.186.172.21)
on: Sun Apr 13 06:26:33 EDT 2003
Lets look for Anurada's details:
Contestant: 9
Name : Anuratha D/O Murugagoo
DOB: 3/1/1979
Remarks: Like Drawing
of heat 4
Her score in heat 4 is 7.275 at 2nd place
Her semi final score was 6.598 at 7th place
Her final was unknown score at 1st place.
Deva's selection
1st : Kavitha Subramaniam
2nd: Shamini Ramasamy
3rd: Madan Raj Nagarajan
- From: Paran (@ 203.123.16.3)
on: Sun Apr 13 08:38:54 EDT 2003
This is ridiculous
How could u call someone as high profile as Deva to be Head of Judges...but then he have no final say.....it is insulting...
Astro spoilt the show by humilitaing Deva...
If they want to decide by SMS then just let he judges to select 10 ten that's all
not to select the winner, but so-called SMS entries superceeds their decision...
so stupid.
- From: ABINAYA (@ 202.188.228.88)
on: Sun Apr 13 11:17:07 EDT 2003
I really agree with u all guys! The final result was really insulting our great tennisai tendral Deva. How can a contestant who was at rank 4 suddenly jump to 1. Unbelieveable, ya! Don't you all agree with me? We are not so stupid ,ya. The prize should go to Kavitha or Shamini. I don't mind if Mathan got it.He is a talented singer. But I don't know how....... WHAT HAPPENED THERE, HA? Anyone know?
- From: Abinaya (@ 202.188.228.88)
on: Sun Apr 13 11:24:46 EDT 2003
Hi guys,
As far as I know, most of my friends don't agree with the final result of VTQ. What happened to our SMS voting?
- From: dell (@ 219.95.24.111)
on: Sun Apr 13 11:43:08 EDT 2003
I think Deva was not supposed to tell in public his ranking of the singers. Harris Jeyaraj and Bharadwaj didn't do that. Maybe Deva misunderstood the instructions but it gave us the oppurtunity to see that the results for the 2003 contest is fixed. A music director of Deva's experience had already chosen Kavitha as the winner. What is the point of including SMS votes? Vanavil wants to do a PopStar type of contest. But in PopStar, the final contest is determined 100% percent by public votes - NO JUDGES!!! The 7 judges were puppets.
"BAD DAY FOR MALAYSIAN TAMIL MUSIC INDUSTRY"
- From: renga (@ 202.188.40.104)
on: Sun Apr 13 12:55:05 EDT 2003
Vaanavil sholuld based either on the pannel board of the judges or sms selection .... Anyhow Astro Vaanavil should release their final decision based on the pannel board of the judges & final decision should be ULTIMATELY based on the CHIEF JUSTICE (who is a respectfull person & well experienced in this field steadily for no. of years) ... then what is the point bringing such experts from overseas by incurring heavy costs... i really just cant believe it ... WHO DID THE MISTAKE ... no matter did it ... how VAANAVIL can based on the SMS... who knows that the SMS were forwarded from the RELATED PARTIES (still HOME VIEWERS ARE NOT MUSICAL JARGONS ... only kelvi nganam) ill go for SARAVANA KUMAR, SHARMINI, KAVITHA, MADHAN RAJ / JEGATHESAN ,,, ANYHOW PAST IS PAST i hope so Vaanavil will rectify their mistake asap and will produce WELL STRUCTURED EVENTS & PROGRAMS.
- From: renga (@ 202.188.40.104)
on: Sun Apr 13 12:58:35 EDT 2003
VTQ 2002 was the BEST EVENT ,,,, unforgetable program
List all pages of this thread
Post comments
Forums: Current Topics - Ilayaraja Albums - A.R. Rahman Albums - TFM Oldies - Fun & Games
Ilaiyaraja: Releases - News - Share Music - AR Rahman: Releases - News - AOTW - Tweets -
Discussions: MSV - YSR - GVP - Song Requests - Song stats - Raga of songs - Copying - Tweets
Database: Main - Singers - Music Director's - Lyricists Fun: PP - EKB - Relay - Satires - Quiz