Topic started by Ravy (@ eagle.vapower.com) on Tue Dec 23 13:05:56 EST 1997.
All times in EDT/EST +9:30/10:30 for IST.
Responses:
- From: Ravy (@ eagle.vapower.com)
on: Tue Dec 23 13:34:13 EST 1997
When it comes to songs, Sridhar never disappoints (oh! Manju is an exception). Whatever be the theme or whoever the MD was he always made sure that they had good songs. When he directed MGR in Urimaikkural he had to include a handful of Typical-MGR songs but still managed 2 good melodies (vizhiyae kadhaiyezhudhu and Kalyana vaLaiosai) thanks to KVM. Some of the MDs he worked with are;
1. A M Rajah - (Kalyana Parisu, ThEn nilavu)
2. MSV (Nenjil ore alayam, Kadhalikka neramillai,
Nenjam marappadhillai, Policekaran magaL,
kalaikkoil + some more. Some of these
include TKR in them)
3. Chalapathi Rao (meenda sorgam - not sure)
4. KVM - Urimaikkural
5. IR - Ilamai O, Azhagae unnai.., Thendralae
ennaith thodu, Ninaivellam Nitya.
Let us start discussing the songs...
over to you guys & gals
- From: Kanchana (@ ww-to02.proxy.aol.com)
on: Tue Dec 23 16:49:04 EST 1997
Ravy:
Some of my observations (with input from my parents) on Director Sridhar:
1. Targeted the younger audiences more, relative to his contemporaries, by focusing more on romance-related plots.
2. Has directed some real tear-jerkers like policekaaran magaL & nenjil oar aalayam, and also some unforgettable comedy classics like kaadhalikka naeramillai & uththaravindri uLLae vaa.
3. Belongs to that special class of directors who excel in great teamwork with the lyricist and MD's, leading to great songs which serve to enhance the mood & drama of the situation thru a blend of meaningful lyrics and good music (with some exceptions).
4. As you pointed out, has worked with a wide range of MD's (yes, T.Chalapathi Rao is the MD for meeNda Sorgam.)
5. Always steered away from the traditional in storylines & direction, introduced new talent in acting(Jayalalitha, Ravichandran, Kanchana, Srikanth, Nirmala, Moorthy), and used PBS/KJJ/SJ more for playback singing for the softer, romantic numbers.
veNNira aadai
This movie saw the acting debut of Jayalalitha, Srikanth, Nirmala, Moorthy and Asha. Lyricist: Kannadhasan. Music: MSV-TKR
Storyline:
The main characters are psychiatrist Chandru (Srikanth), his girlfriend Geetha (Nirmala) and his patient Shobha (Jayalalitha). 15-year-old Shobha becomes a mental patient when she sees her husband die in a car accident two hours after their wedding. She is placed under Chandru's care 2 years after the incident, and returns to normal, thanks to his genius. She promptly falls in love with him. Chandru is aware of this, but does not say anything for fear of upsetting her delicate mental balance. Shobha's parents want Chandru to get married to their daughter, but he declines since he does not wish to desert Geetha who is relying on him, Shobha discovers he is in love with Geetha, and helps Chandru & Geetha get married by overcoming Geetha's parents' objections. On Chandru's wedding day, she wears a widow's conventional veNNira aadai, NOT because knows she she is a widow by convention BUT because the person in her heart cannot be hers anymore.
I was too young to watch this movie when it was released, but ever since I watched this movie for the first time a few years back I've always wondered how the movie audience of the late 60's(?) reacted to the strong dialogue and non-traditional symbolic behavior in the last scene.
Songs:
1. PBS/SJ (Srikanth-Nirmala)
chiththiramae solladi muththamittaal ennadi
niththam niththam thendral vandhu thottadhillaiyoa
thottu thottu nenjil inbam pattadhillaiyoa
2. LRE (Jayalalitha)
nee enbadhenna naan enbadhenna
oru ninaivu enbadhenna
nilai illaadha oru ulaga maedaiyil
naamum vandhadhenna
3. PBS/PS (Srikanth-Nirmala)
oruvan kaadhalan oruththi kaadhali
uravu vaa vaa vaa endradhoa
endradhoa endradhu
4. PS (Jayalalitha)
ammammaa kaatru vandhu aadai thottu paadum
poovaadai koNda maenidhannil aasai veLLam oadum
5. LRE/Raju (Moorthy-Asha)
alli pandhal kaalagaL eduththu aattam aadida vaa
angoru malligai kiLLi eduththu paattu paadida vaa
6. PS (Jayalalitha)
enna enna vaarththaigaLoa chinna vizhi paarvaiyilae
solli solli mudiththu vittaen sonna kadhai puriyavillai
7. PS (Jayalalitha) (full lyrics since it's my favorite:)
kaNNan ennum mannan paerai solla solla
kallum muLLum poovaai maarum mella mella
eNNam ennum aasai padagu sella sella
veLLam perugum peNmai uLLam thuLLa thuLLa
thendral indru paadum paadal enna enna
chinna kiLigaL sollum kadhaigaL enna enna
kaNNum nenjum ondrukkondru pinna pinna
ennai thunbam seyyum eNNam enna enna
akkam pakkam yaarum paarththaal vetkam vetkam
anbae unnai naeril kaNdaal naaNam naaNam
aasai nenjai solla poanaal achcham achcham
andrum indrum adhudhaan nenjil michcham michcham
More later.......
- From: Ramki (@ pm138-14.dialip.mich.net)
on: Tue Dec 23 17:11:30 EST 1997
Ravy 'urimaikkural'is by MSV and not KVM.sridhar-KVM combinationle padam vandhadhaannun theriyalai.
Kanchana i happended to watch venniradai during my last trip to india. A nice film but i couldnt agree with the climax. And according to my mother the film was not a hit bcoz of the climax. Neengal oru azhagaana paadalai vittu vitteergal kanchana
Neeradum kangalingae poraadum nenjamingae(Psuseela)-but indha paadal padathil idamperavillai endru ninaikkiren
Let me discuss abt Sumaithangi songs:)
Story line:A middle class family. Muthuraman periya annan,Gemini thambi and oru thangai. Muthuramanin sambadhyathil kudumbam.College padikkum Gemini.Avaroda classmate Devika. Modhalil
thodangi kaadhal.Oru naal dhideerendru muthuraamanin velai poividugiradhu.Kudumbamae kashtathil.Gemini padippaiye vidugiraar.Idhil geminiyin thangai oru panakkaranai kaadhalikka andha paiyan veetil avargal veetil penneduthaal dhan penn koduppen endru condition podugiraargal,aenendraal andha pen oru epilepsy patient. kudumbatharin compulsionil Gemini kalyaanathukku othukolgiraar,andha penn devikavin
friend endru theriyaamalae.aanal andha penno ivargal kaadhalai therindhu kondu kalyaanathaiy niruthividugiraal.Ippodhu geminikku oru velaikidaikkiradhu.Aanal Muthuraman thanakku andha velaiyai kudukkumpadi kettu petrumviduvaar.Thangaiyin kanavano office panathai kaiyaadividuvaar.Andha kadanai adaikkum poruppum gemini thalaiyil. idhil ivarukku than kaadhale marandhuvidum.Kaathu kaathu nondhu pona devikavum
Balajiyai thirumanam seidhu kolla othukkolluvaar aanal adharkku munn geminiyidam oru varthaiyaavadhu pesavendum endru thudippar.Avaraiye thedi povaar..aanal adharkkul geminiyo oru paadhariyaagividuvaar.
Songs:
Mambazhathu vandu vaasamalarchendu:PBS,SJanaki.
(indha paadal padathil irukkiradhannu theriyalai)
en paruvathin kezhvikku badhilenne solladi radha-PBS,Sjanaki
radhaiketho kannano seethaiketha raamano-SJanaki
manidhan enbavan deivamaagalam - PBS
Mayakkama kalakkama - PBS
en annai seidha paavam - SJ
- From: Ramki (@ pm138-14.dialip.mich.net)
on: Tue Dec 23 17:13:47 EST 1997
WE should add these films too to the list
kodi malar
avalukkendror manam
nenjirukkum varai
- From: Kanchana (@ ww-tp01.proxy.aol.com)
on: Tue Dec 23 19:51:40 EST 1997
Ramki:
Interesting comment on the veNNira aadai ending. Note that the movie does not advocate that ending--all the other characters, including her traditional parents, the hero and the rest of the world feel she should go on with her life. She clearly states it's her personal choice.
Now, why does the hero become a priest in Sumaithaangi? I haven't watched this movie at all, but feel that there is some similarity between the endings of veNNira aadai and Sumaithaangi.
Sridhar did specialize in tragic/shocking endings in several of his movies....
- From: Sathiya Keerthi (@ synergy.nus.edu.sg)
on: Tue Dec 23 21:03:40 EST 1997
Kanchana & Ramki:
Thanks for reminding about veNNiRa aadai and
sumai thaangi. Thamizh audience is quite
unpredictable. When kalyaaNap parisu can
be such a big hit, I don't understand why v. aadai
can't be! Actually I think the ending in v. aadai
is quite natural.
Sridhar typically alternated between serious and
light themes very nicely, to keep all kinds of
audience captivated. Usually he did in pairs:
kalyaaNap parisu & thEn nilavu
nenjil Or aalayam & nenjam maRappadhillai
veNNiRa aadai & kaadhalikka nEramillai
avaLukkendru Or manam & u.uLLE vaa
His command over the audience ended in 1971 with
u. uLLE vaa. Then alaigaL (1973),
vaira nenjam (1975) and O Manju (1976)
were rejected by the audience. So, what did he do?
Switched to MGR! He did urimai kural
and meenava naNban (can someone say whether
Sridhar directed the MGR movie, navarathnam?
the MD was Kunnakkudi Vaidhyanathan, I think.)
Although these and some later ones such as
iLamai O were hits, I think the last movie
with the real Sridhar touch was u.uLLE vaa.
Two movies not mentioned above:
thandhuvittEn ennai
aalaya dheepam
are also by Sridhar.
- From: Pagalavan (@ pkrishna-pc.cisco.com)
on: Tue Dec 23 21:21:01 EST 1997
Another Sridhar/Sivaji combo which failed was mohanap punnagai One good song I remember is : thalaivan..thalaivi..ennai neeraattum aanadha aruvi.. MD : MSV
- From: Sathiya Keerthi (@ synergy.nus.edu.sg)
on: Tue Dec 23 21:27:21 EST 1997
An unforgettable song from kalyaaNap parisu
is kaadhalilE thOlviyutraaL kanni oruththi (PS) which
later continues as kaadhalilE thOlviyutraan kaaLai
oruvan (AMR). Than kaadhalan (Gemini)-yai than
akka (V.Kumari)-vum kaadhalikkiRaal endru therindhadhum
than kaadhalai thyaagam seydhu, Geminikkum V.Kumarikkum
maNam mudiththu avargaLai vERu oorukku train-il
anuppi vittu varum S.Devi, railway station platform-il
sOgaththudan nadandhu varum pOdhu background-il
varuvadhu PS version of the song.
Pinnar, padak kadaisiyil, V.Kumari iRandha pinnar,
S.Devi-kkum Nageswara Rao-ukkum kalyaaNam nadakkap
pOvadhai aRindhu, adhai niRuththa avasaramaaga
varum Gemini-kku adhirchchi: avargaL thirumaNam
mudindhu vittadhu. sOgam avan nenjai adaikka, thanakkum
V.Kumari-kkum piRandha kuzhandhaiyai avargaLukku
kalyaaNap parisaaga koduththuvittu oru vetrup
paadhaiyil thani manidhanaaga nadandhu selvadhu
padaththin mudivu. The hero is shown walking
towards a sunset background depicting the sadness
that, for him everything is over. indha nilaiyil
varuvadhu AMR's version of the song. The orchestration
and the depth of AMR's singing give a bramhaaNdamaana feeling. The audience get
choked with emotion and sadness hearing the song
and seeing the picturization. If you haven't seen
the movie, you have to see it to personally feel
this. Typically, I am told, that many who come out
of the theatre after this song curse Sridhar in
all kinds of abusive language for having made them
cry; more, to carry a heavy heart for several more
days!!
For an article on AMR which discusses his meeting
with Sridhar, see:
http://www.cadcam.nus.sg/~mpessk/ppp/amraja.html
- From: Ramki (@ pm138-11.dialip.mich.net)
on: Tue Dec 23 21:35:52 EST 1997
pagalavan another good song in Mohana punnagai'kalyaanam kutcheriyaam ponnunjalaam poomaalaiyaam jo jo jongricho kalyaaniyil aaradhanai kanneeril aalapanai'.One of the worst film of Sridhars. There were 3 heroines Jayabharathi,anuradha(yes adhae anuradha dhan)and one more(could be sripriya).
'Kaatrinile varum geetham 'was pathetic too.Include 'soundaryamae varuga varuga'too:)
- From: Aravind (@ 202.42.152.9)
on: Tue Dec 23 22:21:22 EST 1997
Another Sridhar movie with IR was 'nAnum oru thozilALi'. *ing Kamal & Ambika. It was a horrible masAlA garnished with around 10 lovely songs. But because of the miserable failure of the movie, songs went unnoticed.
1) Angel aasai angel - Melodious solo - PS??
2) manthaveLi manjak kiLi - Fast Bhangda type song - SPB
3) Ayiraththil nI oruththan - OK solo - SJ
4) pattup pUvE - Fast beautiful song - SPB with 100% enthu
5) semparuththip pUvE - OK duet - SJ, SPB
6) nAn pUveduththu - 'mukkal' duet - SJ, SPB (who else)
7) oru nilavu nadanthu - Very fast duet - SJ, SPB
I may have missed a few songs. Not much melody in any of the songs. But very enthusiastic ones.
Was 'oru Odai nathiyAgirathu' also by Sridhar? It had at least 2 GREAT songs - 'thalaiyaik kuniyum thAmaraiyE' and 'thenRal ennai muththamittathu'.
- From: vijay (@ 129.252.29.214)
on: Wed Dec 24 01:00:00 EST 1997
all of u have forgotten thendrale ennai thodu,one of the greatest musicasl hits of raaja.the songs especially 'thendrale ennai thodu" set in raaga hamsanaadham are very pleasent to hear and retain their freshness even after a decade.
vijay
- From: Pagalavan (@ waterboy.cisco.com)
on: Wed Dec 24 01:04:15 EST 1997
Ramki
kaatRinilE varum geetham was not by Sridhar. Its by SPM, I think.
- From: Ravi (@ greed.cs.umass.edu)
on: Wed Dec 24 01:04:45 EST 1997
SSK: Navarathnam was directed by APN.
- From: pg (@ gate02.merck-medco.com)
on: Wed Dec 24 08:42:52 EST 1997
Sridhar imported Anand Shankar for one of his late films. Does anyone remember the movie ? There was also another Sridhar movie - Sir I Love You *ing Sivakumar, Ranjani. Who was the MD for this ? Anand Shankar ?
- From: Ramki (@ ucc202.lab.cc.wmich.edu)
on: Wed Dec 24 11:37:05 EST 1997
Pagalavan 'kaatrininile varum geetham 'was by Sridhar(This was kavithas second film with him-he introduced her in oh manju)
PG-'sir I love u'was directed by Rangaraj and ilaiyaraja was the MD
We have missed out one more film of Sridhar that had good songs-thudikkum karangal-Music SPB
- From: pg (@ gate02.merck-medco.com)
on: Wed Dec 24 13:18:29 EST 1997
Ramki :
How about yArO ezhudhiya kavidhai ? I think it was by Sridhar and had music by Anand Shankar.
- From: RV (@ nat-20.avanticorp.com)
on: Wed Dec 24 15:10:13 EST 1997
Wasnt Kalaik Kovil by Sridhar ? "Thanga Radham Vandhadhu Veedhiyile". I wonder why Balamurali is not used that much in TFM.
- From: Ramki (@ pm138-06.dialip.mich.net)
on: Wed Dec 24 15:54:17 EST 1997
pg Im not sure abt 'yaaro ezhudiya kavidhai'but the MD is Anand Sagar. I guess its not by Sridhar but i can be wrong
- From: Gokul (@ p1.echostar.com)
on: Wed Dec 24 17:16:45 EST 1997
What about the classic songs from Ennai Thandu
Vitten? Muthamma Muthamma was a very nice song which highlighted Arun Mozhi's Voice.
The movie was a total flop.
Oo Poomalai from Iniya Ooravi Poothathu..
Also the unforgettable song
"Thalayai Kuniyum Thamaraiye!" from
Oru Oodai Nadiyagirathu.
Has sridhar given up making movies?
He had a great rapport with IR.
- From: Kanchana (@ ww-td03.proxy.aol.com)
on: Wed Dec 24 18:35:07 EST 1997
Ravy:
Since this was on your list of Sridhar movies to review (in the TMS thread), I'll go ahead and talk about it.
meeNda sorgam
Lyricists: Kannadhasan, Subbu Aarumugam, P.S.Gopalakrishnan.
Music: T.Chalapathi Rao
Storyline:
The main characters are Shekar (Gemini Ganesan), Nirmala (Padmini) and Kumarayya (S.V.Sahasranamam). Shekar takes an interest in the welfare of recently orphaned Nirmala, and introduces her to Bharata Natyam guru Kumarayya. She learns & excels in Bharata Natyam, but also falls in love with Shekar who thinks she should devote herself to the dance exclusively. He gets married to someone else, he is unhappy, the wife is unhappy and Nirmala is also unhappy. Finally, the wife commits suicide, and Shekar & Nirmala get together.
This is a movie which belongs to my parents' generation(50's) and I've heard them say great things about it. But when I watched it a few years back for the first time, I thought it was too slow and contrived. Also, Sridhar is not consistent: at one point Shekar says he is attracted to Nirmala but her talent should belong to the whole world and not just to him; at another point, Shekar says he is only in love with her talent and not her. ???!! And, somehow, the wife is painted in a bad light as an arrogant lady because she challenges her husband re his feelings for Nirmala. ??!! Anyhow, five out of the seven songs are great with good picturization.
aadum aruL jyothi
MLV/Seerkaazhi. Sung for S.V.Sahasranamam and the nattuvaangam lady, for a formal Bharata Natyam recital by Padmini. One of my favorite MLV movie songs.
thuyilaadha peNN ondru kaNdaen
AMR/PS. Sung for Gemini & Padmini, this is a dream by Nirmala.
kalaiyae en vaazhkayin dhisai maatrinaai
AMR/PS humming. Sung for Gemini. Shekar takes a casual walk around the gardens and Nirmala dances along with him.
kalaiyae en vaazhkayin (pathos)
PS. Sung for Padmini. Nirmala dances based on Kumarayya's request, to make a very ill Shekar feel better. Both Nirmala & Shekar recall the happier days when this song was sung.
mana naattiya maedayil aadinaen
PS/few lines by AMR. Sung for Padmini & Gemini. The extremely depressed Nirmala & Shekar ask themselves which direction their respective lives are headed.
***
I'm curious about Sridhar's Kodimalar, which has songs like mounamae paarvaiaal oru paattu paada vaeNdum. Anyone here seen it?
- From: Ramki (@ pm137-19.dialip.mich.net)
on: Wed Dec 24 23:06:20 EST 1997
Kanchana me:))
Another boring film from Sridhar.The story line is :
vijaykumari oru vaipesamudiyaadha penn.Andha kaaranathaal avarukku thiruman thadaipadum.Avaradhu thangai Pushpalatha.Pushpalathaavukkum AVMRajanum Lovers.
AVMraajanin anna Muthuraman.MVRajamma ivargal mother. Kalyaana tharagar Muthuraamanin familiyidam vijayakumari oomai enbadhai maraithu kalyaana aerpaadugal seidhuviduvaar.VKumari oomaiyendru therindhavudan Muthuraman thirumanathirkku marukka,Vkumari kinarril kudhikka
appuram Mraman othukolvaar.Aanal MVRajamma thadai poda appuram ore kuzhappam(directorkkum namakkum:))
I can recall only 2 good songs from this film
Malarae nee sollae oru mozhiyumillai - PSuseela
Mounamae parvaiyaal oru pattu paadavendum-PBS
- From: Kavinjan (@ )
on: Fri Jan 4 02:39:30 EST 2002
What about Sivandha Mann Songs
Oru Raja Raniyidam Vegu NaaLaaga asai
koNdaar..... (TMS & PS)
List all pages of this thread
Post comments
Sections:
Home -
TFM Magazine -
Forum -
Wiki -
POW -
oPod -
Lyrics -
Pictures -
Music Notes -
Forums: Current Topics - Ilayaraja Albums - A.R. Rahman Albums - TFM Oldies - Fun & Games
Ilaiyaraja: Releases - News - Share Music - AR Rahman: Releases - News - AOTW - Tweets -
Discussions: MSV - YSR - GVP - Song Requests - Song stats - Raga of songs - Copying - Tweets
Database: Main - Singers - Music Director's - Lyricists Fun: PP - EKB - Relay - Satires - Quiz
Forums: Current Topics - Ilayaraja Albums - A.R. Rahman Albums - TFM Oldies - Fun & Games
Ilaiyaraja: Releases - News - Share Music - AR Rahman: Releases - News - AOTW - Tweets -
Discussions: MSV - YSR - GVP - Song Requests - Song stats - Raga of songs - Copying - Tweets
Database: Main - Singers - Music Director's - Lyricists Fun: PP - EKB - Relay - Satires - Quiz