Topic started by Priya (@ 202.156.2.243) on Fri Dec 22 03:11:42 EST 2000.
All times in EST +10:30 for IST.
HI! Lets have a vote. Lets see who wins in this votes. It might be a male singer or a female. Just tell me your favourite male and female singer. And I will be counting from the beggining of this thread. When I'm getting no responses from you all, then I will anounce the results. One male and one female singer. OK. First i'll tell mine.
Male singer: SBP
Female singer: Janaki
What about the others?
Responses:
- Old responses
- From: kalaimamani (@ 203.199.213.4)
on: Fri Nov 29 10:13:51 EST 2002
PJ is alll time best singer of south india
- From: priya (@ 202.9.180.213)
on: Sat Nov 30 06:16:50 EST 2002
pj may be good....ONLY OF THE SOUTHHH......but yesudoss is like 'king of kings'....no comparison.....spb n jp r themselves fans of kjy
- From: Dr.KJY (@ 195.92.67.66)
on: Sat Nov 30 07:00:56 EST 2002
pj may be good....ONLY OF THE SOUTHHH......but DR.SPB is The 'king of kings'....no comparison.....kjy n jp r themselves fans of Dr.SPB!
- From: Dr.KJY (@ 195.92.67.66)
on: Sat Nov 30 07:27:00 EST 2002
Listen to SPB
in his new albums
1) April mathathile
2) Mounam Pesiyadhae
- From: Die-hard fan (@ 61.11.79.121)
on: Sat Nov 30 08:27:20 EST 2002
To all analysts os singers out there,
i would like like to point out on one thing...
i dunno how u can assess "versatility" of a singer like how u did... first let me come to ur own pt. abt. the qualities of a singer....
1. melody
2. range
3. speed
4. vibrations & oscillations
5. depth
6. softness
7. versatality
u say these r the qualities of a "really good" singer...fine, but u had a damn bad shot at who really has all these qualities.
if a man can render over 35000 songs and is still goin strong it simply means that he can render any kinda song with equal aplomb and thts exactly why he has been the most sought after singer over the last two decades in the whole of south india...
yeah... i'm talkin abt the "one 'n' only" SPB who has simply ruled the roost as far as playback singing goes...
can any voice in india range from songs like "dhorakuna"(classic shankarabaranam) to "namma singaari sarakku" and frm hi-pitched "raathiri nerathil"(anjali) to low ones like"malare mounamaa"...fast beats such as "ey.. unnai thaane" to lilting melodies as "nilaave vaa" all i've talked abt is a part of the unbelievable range of numbers rendered by the man.
lemme now give u an example each for the above mentioned qualities(there can be thousands given but tiz neither necessary nor practicable)..
1.melody-loadcartz of 'em...('neway) mandram vandha
2.range"alias"SPB-adimai penn to april maadhathil(to put it in a nutshell)
3.speed-kaala kaalamaaga(punnagai mannan),vela vela (avvai shanmugi) and lots more
4.vibrations and oscillations-shankara nadhasarirapara(shankarabharanam) etc.
5.depth-ketten (amarkalam), one among many..
6.softness-enna satham indha neram(especially in the charanams),one of his hundreds of " soft" melodies...
7.versatility-first lemme correct ur defn. of versatility...
>>7 versatality (ability to shine in film music, classical, devotional, semi -classical light music, festive music etc..) >>
versatility for a singer refers to his capability
to effectively render all kindsa songs really well... alternatively one can define versatility as "S.P.Balasubrahmaniyam"...
even if ur defn. holds good SPB is second to none dho hez not trained in carnatic music...
PJ is a good singer alrite , hez sung some soul-stirring numbers for IR and ARR in tamil and lotz like 'em in malayalam... but he is nowhere when compared to SPB...
PJ's voice is some what similar to KJY's but many feel that KJY had the "gandharvam" and depth in his voice that won him preference over PJ's (somewhat)feminine timbre...(and not "luck")
so plz make a sensible analysis hereafter...(especially to "Analyzer")
regards,
a hard-core TFM fan
- From: Hariharan & Co (@ 195.92.67.76)
on: Sun Dec 1 09:30:15 EST 2002
: Die-hard fan (@ 61.11.79.121) ;
well said!, this so called analyser is a load of mental fanatic of PJ, who knows nothing about music, he/she posts under different names to fool ppl, hence every one knows he is fool & no one bothers to reply to this Idiot, so pls don't waste to your time on this looser!
SuPerB = get it , :)
Means SPB simply rulzzzz
what is Gandharvam?
thanks
- From: Chembarathi (@ 203.199.213.3)
on: Tue Dec 3 05:41:23 EST 2002
Hariharan & Co (@ 195.92.67.76
You r raghu or hariharan?
Idiot stupid scoundrel you've no work here?
P JAYACHANDRAN is god man god,not a dirty worm like you!!!!!!!!
Spb is good,but not even comparablr to PJ!
You are an irritating mental insane,go to a mental hospital.
- From: saran (@ 65.95.116.111)
on: Tue Dec 3 22:41:30 EST 2002
SPB,unnikrishnan & harini are best singet that india never had before
- From: praveen kumar (@ 203.199.213.3)
on: Tue Dec 3 22:48:59 EST 2002
P JAYACHANDRAN,P JAYACHANDRAN AND P JAYACHANDRAN ALWAYS THE BEST
- From: meenu_09 (@ 161.142.112.5)
on: Wed Dec 4 04:07:22 EST 2002
Hello hello hello,
Why argues this and that all the singer have their own plus point. Dont' compare!
Nobody perfect in this world!!understand?????
- From: manju_tnb.com (@ 161.142.112.5)
on: Wed Dec 4 04:10:24 EST 2002
Please talk about the topic people@@@@@@
- From: u (@ 203.199.213.4)
on: Wed Dec 4 04:58:00 EST 2002
Good manju my fav singer PJ
- From: ?who who (@ 202.190.94.2)
on: Wed Dec 4 22:24:36 EST 2002
From U,203.199.213.4
STOP IT THERE!!!!
- From: praveen kumar (@ 203.199.213.3)
on: Thu Dec 5 01:33:47 EST 2002
I like P jayachandran the most
- From: Sudhanshu (@ 203.199.213.5)
on: Thu Dec 5 03:51:48 EST 2002
Yes,P JAYACHANDRAN is best in males.In females Smt susheeladevbi
- From: pjfan (@ 203.199.213.3)
on: Thu Dec 5 08:12:07 EST 2002
Well said sudhanshu,in males nobody born to beat Sree jayachandran
- From: Vijay (@ 203.200.33.65)
on: Fri Dec 6 02:04:59 EST 2002
kalaimamani, pjfan, Sudhanshu, praveen kumar, u, Chembarathi ... : I know you are the same person, posting with the same IP. Who the hell are you ?
- From: parvathi (@ 207.35.188.14)
on: Fri Dec 6 10:54:53 EST 2002
ma opinion
Unnikrishnan & harini-Chitra s r best and ma favourite singers
- From: kk (@ 203.199.213.3)
on: Sat Dec 7 03:54:16 EST 2002
PJ simply the best
- From: UK.COM (@ 202.190.94.2)
on: Tue Dec 10 03:50:17 EST 2002
SPB is the best!
- From: KunKun (@ 161.142.112.5)
on: Tue Dec 10 03:53:36 EST 2002
DONT FIGHT FIGHT BE COLLLLLLLLL!
- From: musicfanatic (@ 202.9.180.36)
on: Tue Dec 10 08:17:48 EST 2002
whoever it is posting for PJ....pls give other pj fans to post too!!! dude....we know very well that its the same peson posting with diff names.....chill now.its sad to see that pj actually very few fans
- From: KunKun (@ 202.190.94.2)
on: Tue Dec 10 19:55:26 EST 2002
You are right Musicfanatic . .its sad to see that pj actually very few fans.
- From: fan (@ 138.88.159.147)
on: Tue Dec 10 22:04:47 EST 2002
hariharan and swarnalatha makes the best combo..and they deserve the national award this year..
- From: krishnadas (@ 203.199.213.5)
on: Wed Dec 11 03:00:13 EST 2002
jayachandran is always best
east or west jayachandran is best
- From: palani (@ 203.199.213.4)
on: Wed Dec 11 03:07:31 EST 2002
Jyaachandran best
- From: agreed (@ 138.88.159.161)
on: Wed Dec 11 09:30:52 EST 2002
hariharan and swarnalatha makes the best combo..and they deserve the national award this year
I agree with u fan !!!
- From: Raghu (@ 217.158.120.226)
on: Wed Dec 11 10:13:33 EST 2002
>>hariharan and swarnalatha makes the best combo..and they deserve the national award this year
I agree with u fan !!!<<
of course, as both of you are the same idiot, look at your IP addresses
here u go (@ 138.88.159.161) & (@ 138.88.159.147)
note only the last 3 didgits are different, because that changes from time to time, day to day.
if (@ 203.199.213.5) is PJ lunatic
u r hariharan lunatic, both of u get a life & get lost from this website :((
- From: Paneerselvam (@ 202.141.24.2)
on: Wed Dec 11 23:15:47 EST 2002
This site s not ur father's
- From: musicfanatic (@ 202.9.180.169)
on: Fri Dec 13 03:32:17 EST 2002
ur ABSOLUTELY RIGHT raghu.....its gettin a little too irritating....summa tying to act smart
- From: Manoj nair (@ 203.199.213.3)
on: Fri Dec 13 08:11:37 EST 2002
My favourite singer is the master of songs Jayachandran.
SPB is a very good singer,but not good as Jayachandran
- From: musicfanatic (@ 202.9.181.208)
on: Fri Dec 13 10:55:50 EST 2002
OHH GODDDD.....Y DOES THIS FREAKY GUY NOT REALISE THAT WE R NOT DUMB TO FIND OUT THAT ITS THE SAME IDIOT WHO'S POSTING WITH DIFFERENT NAMES????!!!!
NOW.....IF HE'S GOING TO CONTINUE DOING THE SAME......IS THERE ANYWAY TO BLOCK SUCH POSTINGS???????
FREAKKSSSS
- From: vanmathi (@ 64.228.69.128)
on: Fri Dec 13 15:05:54 EST 2002
Unnikrishnan & SPB s great singers
- From: KRISHNARAJ (@ 203.199.213.3)
on: Fri Dec 13 23:26:48 EST 2002
JAYACHANDRAN IS THE GREATEst SINGER IUN INDIA
upasana upasana ithu dhanyamamorupasana
unaratte ushassupolunaratte
oru yugachethana unaratte
upasana upasana
sathyam mayakkumarunninte chirakil
swargathu parakkumi nattil illatha
swargathu parakkumi naattil
swapnam marikkumi nattil
sargaswaroopiyam shasthram nirmikkum
agnikundangalkkullil
manushya-a-a-aa-
he manushya-a-a-a-aa-a-aa-
valicheriyoo ninte mukhammooti
kalam sharashayya theerthu mayangumi
kanatha kurukshethrabhoovil kaliyugam
kanatha kurukshethra bhoovil
socratisumar dhyanichirikkumi
swarnasamanathinnarukil
manushya-a-a-a--aa
he manushya-a-a-aaa-aaa
valicheriyoo ninte vishapathram
This is the song i like most.There is a request to all jayachandranfans.Please follow this--
unaratte ushassupolunaratte
oru yugachethana unaratte
come on wake up come along with us/
- From: PJ fanatic (@ 195.92.198.75)
on: Sat Dec 14 06:22:59 EST 2002
SPB is the lord, the rest are his student!
List all pages of this thread
Post comments
Sections:
Home -
TFM Magazine -
Forum -
Wiki -
POW -
oPod -
Lyrics -
Pictures -
Music Notes -
Forums: Current Topics - Ilayaraja Albums - A.R. Rahman Albums - TFM Oldies - Fun & Games
Ilaiyaraja: Releases - News - Share Music - AR Rahman: Releases - News - AOTW - Tweets -
Discussions: MSV - YSR - GVP - Song Requests - Song stats - Raga of songs - Copying - Tweets
Database: Main - Singers - Music Director's - Lyricists Fun: PP - EKB - Relay - Satires - Quiz
Forums: Current Topics - Ilayaraja Albums - A.R. Rahman Albums - TFM Oldies - Fun & Games
Ilaiyaraja: Releases - News - Share Music - AR Rahman: Releases - News - AOTW - Tweets -
Discussions: MSV - YSR - GVP - Song Requests - Song stats - Raga of songs - Copying - Tweets
Database: Main - Singers - Music Director's - Lyricists Fun: PP - EKB - Relay - Satires - Quiz