<b>Rating Of Singers</b>

Home Forum Wiki Notes Register FAQ Sitemap About Us Contact Us

<b>Rating Of Singers</b> Rating Of Singers

Topic started by Rajesh Kumar (@ 198.151.230.253) on Thu Mar 1 03:33:16 EST 2001.
All times in EST +10:30 for IST.

We can Rate The Singers According to the Following Categories..

Singing:10 points

Pronounciation 10 points

Variation :10 points

Modulation : 10 Points

Versatality : 10 Points

Total should be 50....

Responses:

From: Rajesh Kumar (@ 198.151.230.253) on: Thu Mar 1 03:38:04 EST 2001

I start with P.susheela

Singing: 9 points

Pronounciation : 10 points

Variation : 8 points

Modulation : 9 Points

Versatality : 9 Points

totally She Scores 45/50
From: Peter Pan (@ 203.199.87.3) on: Thu Mar 1 04:45:01 EST 2001

My pick is Suresh Peters:

Singing: 2 points

Pronounciation : -10 points

Variation : what's that?

Modulation : -5

Versatality : -9

Total: -22 points

And he used to be one of my favorite composer's favorite singers. Looks like he isn't anymore. Thank the good Lord for that. Now he threatens to make his own music and sing too!!!
From: Peter Pan (@ 203.199.87.3) on: Thu Mar 1 04:46:39 EST 2001

Rajesh Kumar,
By the way, your experiment with HTML is quite an eye-sore. Please fix it.
From: NagaS (@ 202.169.129.72) on: Thu Mar 1 07:59:07 EST 2001

Peter Pan,

Thideernnu 'He is no more'nnu sonnaa eppadi ? Bayanthee poitteen :-)

I heard that Suresh Peters is doing music for some Malayalam Movies these days,

BTW, I am also happy that Suresh Peters is not singing Tamil(??!!) thesedays :-)

NagaS
From: Balaji (@ 199.67.140.20) on: Thu Mar 1 08:23:22 EST 2001

Hariharan:
Singing: 8 points
Pronounciation : 2 points
Variation : 5 points
Modulation : 7 Points
Versatality : 6 Points
Total: 24/50

Balaji
From: rjay (@ 206.150.228.62) on: Thu Mar 1 09:14:28 EST 2001

This is the thread that has come out with flying
colors!

;)
From: peeps (@ 64.133.24.5) on: Thu Mar 1 09:45:57 EST 2001

ha ha..good one rjay...:-) :-) let me also join in this colorful thread
From: peeps (@ 64.133.24.5) on: Thu Mar 1 09:47:38 EST 2001

varu'may'(ink) in niram sivappu?????
From: GM (@ 172.131.169.191) on: Thu Mar 1 10:33:34 EST 2001

hey ennappa rating udit narayan'kku pannalaya?
yaar pannalum pronounciation marakkama zero podunga
From: peeps (@ 64.133.24.5) on: Thu Mar 1 10:49:37 EST 2001

can we present a tongue cleaner to udit narayan...(just for thamash)
From: peeps (@ 64.133.24.5) on: Thu Mar 1 10:54:34 EST 2001

Rajesh Kumar,
Neenga Ramarajan fan-a?????
From: VASEEGARAN (@ 203.199.237.5) on: Thu Mar 1 12:07:20 EST 2001

Udit Narayan.
SING.....10
VARIATION...9
PRONOUNCIATION...10
mODULATION............8
Versatality.....9
TOTAL SCORE IN HINDI 46....IN TAMIL...23
V
From: Rajesh Kumar (@ 198.151.230.253) on: Thu Mar 1 23:00:19 EST 2001

peeps Ramarajan Fanellam illa..

Rating Colorfula irukattumenu than...

Yenna peeps thread'ku vanthuttu rating pannama poiteengale

Romba varuthama irukku
From: raj (@ 203.199.228.224) on: Fri Mar 2 08:23:52 EST 2001

Smt P Susheela socres 10 in each of the categories. Total 50.
From: raj (@ 203.199.228.224) on: Fri Mar 2 08:24:17 EST 2001

Smt P Susheela scores 10 in each of the categories. Total 50.
From: TNS (@ 203.199.228.148) on: Fri Mar 2 11:45:59 EST 2001

SCORE RATING la Voice kku 10 marks provide Panniyirukkanum.Hariharan,S.J,Kavitha Krishnamurthy ellam Nalla Padaranga..But no melody in their voice.
Voice nnu vandhal,P.S. and P.Jayachandran score 10 out of 10. TNS
From: rajesh (@ 198.151.230.253) on: Fri Mar 2 22:58:19 EST 2001

i go by Tns& Raj
From: Rajesh Kumar (@ 198.151.230.253) on: Thu Mar 8 02:26:46 EST 2001

the next singer is K.J.Yesudoss

Singing: 9 points

Pronounciation : 8 points

Variation : 9 points

Modulation : 9 Points

Versatality : 8 Points

totally She Scores 43/50
From: Rajesh Kumar (@ 198.151.230.253) on: Thu Mar 8 02:26:54 EST 2001

the next singer is K.J.Yesudoss

Singing: 9 points

Pronounciation : 8 points

Variation : 9 points

Modulation : 9 Points

Versatality : 8 Points

totally he Scores 43/50
From: Rajesh Kumar (@ 198.151.230.253) on: Thu Mar 8 02:30:10 EST 2001

the next singer is S.P.B

Singing: 9 points

Pronounciation : 9 points

Variation : 9 points

Modulation : 9 Points

Versatality : 9 Points

totally he Scores 45/50
From: Kupps (@ 156.153.255.250) on: Thu Mar 8 08:59:34 EST 2001

my pick this time is only female singers...
immediately comes four names PS, SJ, UR, KSC

im not going to rate PS. Many have given their and i follow them.

SJ:
---
Singing        : 9 points(if it means voice then 8)

Pronounciation : 9 points

Variation       : 9 points

Modulation      : 10 Points

Versatality     : 10 Points
From: Kupps (@ 156.153.255.250) on: Thu Mar 8 09:02:06 EST 2001

UR:
---
Singing           : 10 points

Pronounciation : 10 points

Variation         : 9 points

Modulation      : 9 Points

Versatality       : 9 Points
From: Kupps (@ 156.153.255.250) on: Thu Mar 8 09:03:36 EST 2001

KSC:
----
Singing            : 9 points

Pronounciation : 9 points

Variation         : 9 points

Modulation      : 9 Points

Versatality       : 9 Points
From: Rajesh Kumar (@ 198.151.230.253) on: Fri Mar 9 02:13:53 EST 2001

my next pick in the list is
Unnikrishnan

Singing : 10 points

Pronounciation : 9 points

Variation : 9 points

Modulation : 9 Points

Versatality : 8 Points

Totally he scores 45/50
From: vengayam (@ 202.54.94.54) on: Fri Mar 9 06:49:39 EST 2001

people seem to be very liberal out here.ksc & unnikrishnan getting 45/50 means we are happy with okay stuff. unnikrishnan 8 out of 10 for versatality... how come. how about this for mano
singing 8
pronounciation 7
variation 7
modulation 9
versatality 8
Total 39/50
udit narayan
singing 9
p'ation 2
variation 6
modulation 7
versatality 6
total 30/50
sadhana sargam
singing 6
p'ation 3
variation 5
modulation 6
versatality 5
total 25/50
ir
singing 5
p'ation 6
variation 2
modulation 5
versatality 4
total 22/50
From: Kupps (@ 156.153.255.250) on: Fri Mar 9 11:16:36 EST 2001

Vengayam,

i beg to differ in one aspect of your rating for IR i.e pronounciation. IMHO it is 9 or 10. When his pronounciation is judged forget about other attributes of singing. I think his pronounciation is better than Mano's. Please note that IR takes care in pronouncing even non-tamizh words esp. sanskrit words. his devotion towards it(pronounciation) is much higher and is one of the best in TFM, imho.

above all i know that what you have rated is based on your opinion. so if you feel that i should not have contested it then please pardon me and forget my posting.
From: karthi (@ 63.21.181.160) on: Sat Mar 10 01:40:47 EST 2001

OK, now it's my turn. (For a change I start NOT with PS!). Aamaa, variation-kum modulation-kum enna vithiyaasam? So, I am combining them! But adding two more things - miga mukkiyam - Voice & Bhaavam!

Janaki:
Singing: 10
Pronounciation: 7
V/M: 6
Versatality : 10
Bhaavam: 9
Voice: 7
----
49/60
----

Suseela:
Singing: 8
Pronounciation: 10
V/M: 10
Versatality : 6
Bhaavam: 8
Voice: 10
----
52/60
----

Vani Jayaram:
Singing: 7
Pronounciation: 9
V/M: 5
Versatality : 5
Bhaavam: 8
Voice: 9
----
43/60
----
Chitra:
Singing: 7
Pronounciation: 8
V/M: 5
Versatality : 8
Bhaavam: 9
Voice: 9
----
46/60
----

Marks for male singers? Adhu adutha vaaram!
From: neelkanta iyer (@ 203.197.146.70) on: Sat Mar 10 04:41:18 EST 2001

this is not a wel thought topic.
the most importent aspect of a singer is feel, which is not even identified in the topic.
very bad show guys.karthi stands out here .he/she
is mentioning about bhaavam in the rating.
some releif
From: neelkanta iyer (@ 203.197.146.70) on: Sat Mar 10 04:42:33 EST 2001

this is not a well thought topic.
the most importent aspect of a singer is feel, which is not even identified in this topic.
very bad show guys.karthi stands out here .he/she
is mentioning about bhaavam in the rating.
some releif
From: m ramamurthy (@ 203.197.82.92) on: Mon Mar 12 09:38:48 EST 2001

Dear readers,
Lata is my favourite.
Singing 10/10 ( maybe even 100 /10)
Pronouciation 10/10
Singing: 10/10
Bhaavam 10/10
Voice 10/10
From: Indian music fan (@ 204.50.249.133) on: Wed Mar 14 15:12:37 EST 2001

Mohammed Rafi is the best EVER !!

Singing - 10
Pronounciation- 10
Variation- 10
Versatality- 10 (unmatchable)
Voice- 10 (also unmatchable)
Style- 10

Total is perfect !!!

No one can match Rafi Sahab !!

List all pages of this thread

Post comments

Sections: Home - TFM Magazine - Forum - Wiki - POW - oPod - Lyrics - Pictures - Music Notes -
Forums: Current Topics - Ilayaraja Albums - A.R. Rahman Albums - TFM Oldies - Fun & Games
Ilaiyaraja: Releases - News - Share Music - AR Rahman: Releases - News - AOTW - Tweets -
Discussions: MSV - YSR - GVP - Song Requests - Song stats - Raga of songs - Copying - Tweets
Database: Main - Singers - Music Director's - Lyricists Fun: PP - EKB - Relay - Satires - Quiz