Topic started by k_vanan (@ 210.186.138.85) on Tue May 25 06:37:57 EDT 2004.
All times in EST +10:30 for IST.
*Madhavan
Director: susi ganesan (five star, virumbikiren)
Sources: dinakaran.com
Responses:
- From: NagaS (@ 219.120.136.211)
on: Tue May 25 06:47:54 EDT 2004
I liked susi ganesan's first two movies - could be a nice oppurtunity for Karthik Raja to make another 'dummdummdumm'ish album :)
NagaS
- From: Kalai (@ 203.124.133.42)
on: Tue May 25 07:41:45 EDT 2004
Good to see a nice heart wishing Good Luck for Karthik Raaja, which happens very rarely. I too am one of the rare persons who believe that KR is not being recognized/utilized properly by TFM.
Susi Ganaesan is a Good Director. We can expect a Very Good Project from this team.
- Kalai
- From: Srivatsan (@ 136.182.2.222)
on: Tue May 25 09:51:17 EDT 2004
Kalai: Add me to your list. I love KR Dum Dum Dum, great songs and good BGM tooo. KR is defintely one of the most underrated MDs - hope he gets a good break soon!
- From: Yesakki (@ 63.73.213.5)
on: Tue May 25 11:44:47 EDT 2004
After Album he has given nonsense music.- 3 roses and singara chennai.
If he cannot capitalise on opportunities he can be written off.
- From: R-E-5-P-E-C-T (@ 203.106.8.137)
on: Tue May 25 12:40:43 EDT 2004
Who is The Producer is it MADRAS TALKIES...?
- From: Kum_Laden (@ 149.99.188.70)
on: Tue May 25 13:04:22 EDT 2004
The movie name is Karuppan?
is Vijayakanth the hero???!
- From: NagaS (@ 219.120.136.211)
on: Tue May 25 20:28:37 EDT 2004
Yesakki,
Do you seriously believe any 'decent' muzik can be given to a movie like 'singaara chennai' ? :)
He should have used his oppurtunity on 'Ragasiyamaay' ... It had some nice songs, But nothing great ...
NagaS
- From: CM (@ 166.121.36.7)
on: Tue May 25 21:42:39 EDT 2004
When you assess a person's musical talents we will have to look at all his contributions. KR has consistently given some fantastic songs in most of the movies he worked in. Unfortunately most of the movies flopped big time and as ever tamil sentimentality pushed him to be rated even below dupes like Baratwaj and S A Rajkumar. Wait and see when one super hit movie comes from Karthik Raja, all fools will be queing for his dates soooon.
- From: OISG (@ 195.229.241.183)
on: Wed May 26 00:16:55 EDT 2004
NagaS
It should atleast equal Dum3,yes.... thats the only Karthik Raja movie that sank WITH A TRACE.KR with such poor imagination in terms of tunes will never be able to hold a movie together and make it for his personal triumph.
KR can never hope to match the imagination and genius of his father & the spark his younger brother has.YSR despite not showing any classical tastes has managed a name for himself by offering the directors what they want and seems to be fully aware of his limitations.
KR, i feel, talked too much,bad mouthed other MDs, before his music actually took off....and now after 10 years, it looks its never due for one.
- From: OISG (@ 213.42.2.11)
on: Wed May 26 00:29:47 EDT 2004
CM,
"all fools will be queing for his dates soooon"
that was a good one:))
- From: Cinefan (@ 61.95.200.248)
on: Wed May 26 00:50:09 EDT 2004
I am also one of those who believes that KR has not been given his due.He is definitely better than YSR,S.A.Rajkumar,Deva etc.His strong point is melody&he is very good at it.He just needs a movie which will hit bigtime at the box office.If this news is true,maybe this is that movie.
- From: 1 (@ 61.1.220.238)
on: Wed May 26 01:15:52 EDT 2004
yes i do like him a lot
he has delivered some great songs in ullasam, dumdum, album, naam iruvar namaku iruvar etc.,
expecting a lot from this album
smile
suresh
- From: Kalai (@ 203.124.133.42)
on: Wed May 26 01:29:00 EDT 2004
>> After Album he has given nonsense music.- 3 roses and singara chennai.
>> If he cannot capitalise on opportunities he can be written off
After Album, the movies that were released are 3 Roses, Ragasiyamai and Singaara Chennai.
I accept that Singaara Chennai is a let down. But none of the three movies is an oppurtonity. All crpas. Though 3 Roses and Ragasiyamai are not Very Good Albums, they are still Good Album. "Oduthae Oduthae" from Ragasiyamai is much more than enough for that movie.
Even the movie Album was not an opportunity. The movie got much much better Music than what it deserved. The movie at the best would get an average rating. No surprise that it flopped. But the Album Music was real beauty. One of the All Time Best.
The only real opportunity that KR got was DDD. Every one knows how he had used that opportunity. He did justice to the Big Banner ABCL in Ullaasam. The next opportunity is in the pipeline - "Karuppan". Wait till then.
>> KR can never hope to match the imagination and genius of his father & the spark his younger brother has
Ofcourse KR cant match his father. For the matter, no one else can match to the GENIUS either. His brother is an Young Enthusiastic tallent, who is a hit in the industry. But KR is defnitely better than YSR.
- Kalai
- From: vijay (@ 68.51.215.28)
on: Wed May 26 01:35:13 EDT 2004
YSR hasnt done better recently. Both him and KR have stunk it up lately. Its Bhavatharini as a MD, who is going to be the surprise package ;-))
- From: Normal Man (@ 203.61.89.73)
on: Wed May 26 03:01:44 EDT 2004
Hopefully he does not use Bhavatharini in any of the songs. She is a living example of how to spoil a song and irritate the listeners.
Also hopefully he does not allow his string sounds to be very low and those stupid synth sounds tearing your ear drums.
- From: NagaS (@ 219.120.136.211)
on: Wed May 26 03:50:32 EDT 2004
Vijay,
Appuram eppadiba Yuvan-kku aduththaduththu movies vanthukittae irukku ?
Whenever a YSR album is released, Within next couple of days, he gets / starts to work on another project - did you notice ?
Somebody told me he is accepting only 'n' number of movies - only after finishing one, he will accept another - I believe it NOW - He must be 'one of' the first choice MDs of directors / producers in TFM !
Now don't tell me he is yet to score for mani rathnam or Bharathi raja :)
NagaS
- From: Nattamai (@ 195.92.67.78)
on: Wed May 26 04:19:19 EDT 2004
Must be rewritten as :
KArthik Raja is a KArupan :))
- From: Cinefan (@ 61.95.200.248)
on: Wed May 26 06:13:45 EDT 2004
Why the hell do people come up with offending personal remarks?
- From: Wondering (@ 208.24.179.27)
on: Wed May 26 10:33:24 EDT 2004
Here is another synonymous title:
"Mottai" by ARR
"Thundu" by ARR
"Abasvaram" by ARR
"Producer with no Kovanam" by ARR
- From: Nattamai (@ 67.15.42.16)
on: Wed May 26 10:40:17 EDT 2004
---- Nattamai (@ 195.92.67.78)
It was not me, some stupid using my nickname....
- From: vijay (@ 68.16.25.50)
on: Wed May 26 11:36:49 EDT 2004
"Appuram eppadiba Yuvan-kku aduththaduththu movies vanthukittae irukku ?
I was talking about YSR's quality of music. If you remember even Deva(who accepted all trash films and was willing to work for peanuts) had much higher number of movies in 96, 97 and 98 as compared to IR/ARR:-) With the top MDs accepting less and less movies these days the field is open for anyone. YSR isnt even as good as HJ right now IMO.
- From: NagaS (@ 219.120.136.211)
on: Wed May 26 20:22:23 EDT 2004
vijay,
YSR is not accepting every movie like deva - If you read what I posted earlier - he is accepting only certain number of movies, which he thinks is his limit - who are we to ask him to reduce or increase that limit ?
You are talking about Quality and then mention HJ's name ? Come-on yaar - That way, Even Deva's Copied melodies had Quality - Who can forget Aaasai and Nerukku Naer ?
HJ may be successful, But even a 3 year old in tamilnadu knows he is just a clone of ARR :) ... IMO YSR is the ONLY MD, who is not following IR or ARR, But trying to make a style of his own :)
NagaS
- From: kumar (@ 69.192.101.152)
on: Wed May 26 20:58:09 EDT 2004
I agree with you Naga.
YSR is trying to give some New Style.
Specially R & B.
He can copy " Dalendar Mehndi" and "Aqua"
- From: NagaS (@ 219.120.136.211)
on: Wed May 26 21:23:14 EDT 2004
kumar,
'R & B'nna ennaba ?
about copying from western sources, Im also very upset that he did that in some songs - He even copied / recycled an IR Song 100% in 'bala' ... very bad !
But you can't use it as an argument to say HJ is better than YSR .. hahaha :>
NagaS
- From: Nattamai (@ 67.15.42.16)
on: Fri May 28 02:02:35 EDT 2004
KR's another new movie "kudaikkul mazhai" *Parthiban.
- From: Sala (@ 81.86.97.15)
on: Fri May 28 07:42:10 EDT 2004
I too accept to Naga's...
Yuvan is the only MD in TFM who is giving different style of music at the present...
that's the only reason everyone likes to work with him...No wonder Selvaraghavan told that Yuvan is the hero of the movie 7G R C...and Simbu has praised Yuvan about his working style in his recent interview...
YUVAN is the best...
Anyway all the best to KARTHIK RAJA for his upcoming projects...hope he gets a good break now...can anyone give any other source of his upcoming movies...
cheers
- From: Mumbai Ramki (@ 203.199.48.200)
on: Fri May 28 08:21:39 EDT 2004
To say Yuvan is the best ,well i do not agree.But i do agree he ha s given good melodie sin Ullam ,Perazhagan and latest 7/G .But yuvan uses lot of loops and is narrowing himself as far as style is considered .especially 7/g and KK have very very similar style starting from use of instruments !!!
Sala ,
browser.to/karthikraja
List all pages of this thread
Post comments
Sections:
Home -
TFM Magazine -
Forum -
Wiki -
POW -
oPod -
Lyrics -
Pictures -
Music Notes -
Forums: Current Topics - Ilayaraja Albums - A.R. Rahman Albums - TFM Oldies - Fun & Games
Ilaiyaraja: Releases - News - Share Music - AR Rahman: Releases - News - AOTW - Tweets -
Discussions: MSV - YSR - GVP - Song Requests - Song stats - Raga of songs - Copying - Tweets
Database: Main - Singers - Music Director's - Lyricists Fun: PP - EKB - Relay - Satires - Quiz
Forums: Current Topics - Ilayaraja Albums - A.R. Rahman Albums - TFM Oldies - Fun & Games
Ilaiyaraja: Releases - News - Share Music - AR Rahman: Releases - News - AOTW - Tweets -
Discussions: MSV - YSR - GVP - Song Requests - Song stats - Raga of songs - Copying - Tweets
Database: Main - Singers - Music Director's - Lyricists Fun: PP - EKB - Relay - Satires - Quiz