Topic started by Thathuvavaathi (@ 203.199.220.81) on Sun Oct 21 06:30:29 EDT 2001.
All times in EST +10:30 for IST.
The much awaited "NANDHAA" film songs (Music : Yuvan Shankar Raja, Direction : Bala) are being released today (21-10-2001). Kamal Hasan is releasing the first audio cassette and Bharathiraja is receiving it, at Hotel Connemara, Chennai.
The songs are totally fresh & different, and not the usual Yuvan's latino-type music. This album can easily be compared to some of the best of Ilayaraja when he was at his best.
Hear the songs and enjoy.
(The sample audio songs will be posted here tomorrow - 22nd Oct, 2001)
Responses:
- Old responses
- From: madhav (@ 195.93.34.186)
on: Wed Oct 24 04:47:32 EDT 2001
Yuvan's website is also accessible at
www.busychennai.com/yuvan
- From: Punithan (@ 203.106.151.32)
on: Wed Oct 24 07:42:28 EDT 2001
Prabhu
I remember reading in newtfmpage about a beautiful song by Janaki in Parthaale Paravasam. Music is by ARR
- From: Raguvaran (@ 212.2.14.241)
on: Wed Oct 24 10:55:57 EDT 2001
: Punithan (@ 203.106.151.32) ;
Is there any SPB song in Parthaale Paravasam????
thanks
- From: uv2 (@ 63.225.17.34)
on: Wed Oct 24 11:10:28 EDT 2001
This thread is for Nandhaa songs..:))
- From: Venki (@ 216.115.36.65)
on: Wed Oct 24 11:26:39 EDT 2001
well.... , someone is looking for people in other
threads to hear songs from Parthaale Paravasam. :)
- From: kiru (@ 192.138.149.4)
on: Wed Oct 24 11:43:37 EDT 2001
First the positives - the album boasts very good recording and mixing. YSR has consistently given good mixes. He has avoided western influences in this album, like madhav and others have pointed out. IR has given two strong melodies just with his singing. Yuvan has also tried to write some bass lines like IR and not resort to the easy electronic drone in the background ambience thing, all the time.
The negatives, that I would like to point out, are - in a desire to sound 'pleasant' or to please the audience I think Yuvan is giving the music low priority !!!. You know what I mean ?, the tune is predictable. Somehow mun paniyaa sounded like snEhithanE from ARR ..the two IR songs seem to be modelled after the two songs in sEthu. (compare ammaa song with varthai thavari vittai in sEthu ) In the engengo sellum song, I find IR's voice overshadowed by the instruments, however melodious they sound. YSR should concentrate on creating 'totally' new melodies. (Ofcourse, he is better than so many other MDs). I think he also should concentrate on making sure the lyrics really fit his notes. I find in mun paniyaa there is some rushed singing.
Overall this is a good effort. Yuvan has been giving different albums all the time and so I think he will progress into a strong musician in the future. I want Yuvan to prove that to create new sound you dont have to literally change the sound. It is how you use the same traditional instruments in a novel way.
(thaths ..thanks for the high-quality clips and your respect for copyrights).
- From: Kannan (@ 194.201.128.5)
on: Wed Oct 24 12:46:45 EDT 2001
real audio version of the (complete) tracks are available at raaga.com... for more listening pleasure!
~:-))
- From: callaspadeaspade (@ 161.114.88.73)
on: Wed Oct 24 13:39:50 EDT 2001
IR's voice sucks on Nanda. his voice on the higher octaves make me want to cringe. when is he going to stop singing. boy !countless songs despoiled.
To call IR's voice 'beautiful' is a travesty of great singers.
when are u going to stop this fawning
- From: ravi (@ 129.42.208.142)
on: Wed Oct 24 13:44:58 EDT 2001
dai mayiru ...callaspadeaspade
dont talk sutpid...
none one can ever bring life into a song like IR does.............
no one can make u feel ....as closely related to a song than IR...
stop ur stupid criticism...and ...getlost
- From: MusicMouse (@ 61.1.212.151)
on: Wed Oct 24 13:50:48 EDT 2001
After many listenings
I melted by
Engengo Kalgal Sellum Pathaiyil Poginrai
Ethethou Nalai Enra Asaiyil Valginrai
- From: callaspadeaspade (@ 161.114.88.73)
on: Wed Oct 24 14:12:44 EDT 2001
Mr Ravi .
With due respect . this is a forum for voicing opinions . please do not indulge in personal attacks viz ., "mairu" etc.
Just shows the level of puerility on your part. Well, alright, IR's voice is mellifluous.
"No one can ever bring life into a song like IR does". If eructations and cacophony are the norm of good singing ;yep IR's voice does bring life in the form of braying. as a matter of fact , it personifies braying.
awaiting your profanity,expletives etc.
- From: Venki (@ 216.115.36.65)
on: Wed Oct 24 14:24:35 EDT 2001
callaspadeaspade you have your own taste.. nothing to complain about it.
- From: sats (@ 139.177.224.100)
on: Wed Oct 24 14:41:33 EDT 2001
The song "amma" reminds me of the bharathi song "ninnai saran" and the chorus in the munpaniya song is sounds same as that of "vellimalare vellimalare" from jodi
- From: Fliflo (@ 146.186.113.254)
on: Wed Oct 24 14:42:22 EDT 2001
If you go acoording to rules and norms, I am sure you would agree that majority of singers have to be ignored. Physics of sound no matters for ears. Physics does not have any sense about "expression of feelings". IR's voice definitely get a pass here..If my ear can not sense that...stop listening...
- From: PASSION (@ 165.91.166.96)
on: Wed Oct 24 15:30:22 EDT 2001
just listeneed to the songs..preety good...atleast YSR ia makinf giant strides forward...spb song was a spellbinder....so was IR'S renditions..i cannot say the same about rest of the album...its was pretty ordinary stuff..."ayiram " cud have been better ..."andal poem " is a mess..... overall its an album which shows ysr has moved away from his fusion funky stuffs....
one more thing i dont get why IR is getting repetitive in singing these type of songs...we heard it in sethu and then in kutty and then in bharathi and now in nandhaa...if u ask people abot IR ...they are gonna say the guy who sings the sad songs in tamil movies...whats happening to his singing abilities ...i have no doubt that he can emote ..but for the guy who sang"sorkagamme endralum "..."enthu oruthara patham".." thendral vanthu".." das das".." poomalaiye tholsera"..."veetuku veetuku "...list goes on...it isnt fair on his part to churn out only sad melodies...he can do better..in fact IR is more versatile in such type of songs..i get the feeling that whenever u listen to sad songs by IR ..it all seems the same.. could we ever get renditions like "kathakelu kathakelu "from MMKR..those were the days!!!!
about nandhaa....could have been better ,,,but surely SPB'S SONG IS A WINNER ALL THE WAY ...
- From: whynot (@ 165.91.166.96)
on: Wed Oct 24 15:33:17 EDT 2001
YEAH I AGREE PASSION IR IS CURRENTLY IN THE MELANCHOLIC TREND. MAYBE ITS A WAY OF EXPRESSING HIS DISPLEASURE AT BEING INGNORED BY THE PRESENT MUSIC FANS.
- From: CBI (@ 165.91.166.96)
on: Wed Oct 24 15:35:58 EDT 2001
did u guys notice that towarda the end of the pallavi int he "mun paniya song"....there is a resemblemnce of "LYRIL AD"....
WHAT SAY YOU???
- From: Fliflo (@ 146.186.113.254)
on: Wed Oct 24 15:43:57 EDT 2001
IR IS CURRENTLY IN THE MELANCHOLIC TREND. MAYBE ITS A WAY OF EXPRESSING HIS DISPLEASURE AT BEING INGNORED BY THE PRESENT MUSIC FANS.
"Romba butthisaaliya pesittatha ninaippo..."
- From: ravi (@ 129.42.208.147)
on: Wed Oct 24 16:30:05 EDT 2001
heloo callaspadeaspade,
u know whats braying ...ever heard that ...
anyway sorry for being a bit mischief " mayiru"
well tell me which singer brings life into a song
waiting for ur reply
- From: ash (@ 12.5.196.138)
on: Wed Oct 24 16:47:47 EDT 2001
callaspadeaspade is somewhat right. IRs voice is so terrible these days. His voice was real good a few years ago and it was good only for singing certain type of songs like folk, pathos etc. Only good thing about IR singing is, that his pronounciation is very good.
- From: sabesan (@ 172.135.249.195)
on: Wed Oct 24 16:56:01 EDT 2001
CallASpadeASpade - not sure who u r..... but this time i agree with u..... yes, IRs voice is not good in the "amma" song in most of the places.... it suits at the beginning of the song very much.... but inside the para's - well, i really wish someone should have sung that part alone.... i really enjoyed the start of the song..... it really brings a lot of sorrow at the beginning, but half way thro, hmmm i don't want to say.... his voice was very very very good in SETHU songs, and in KUTTI song....... not in this..... well, all IMHO :-)....
- From: yourstruly (@ 172.188.127.65)
on: Wed Oct 24 17:02:44 EDT 2001
Dear Mr Callaspadeaspade,
How does the phrase 'up your arse' feel like when you are at the receiving end? If you are displeased about a singer, you don't have to make an effort to display it. Just don't listen or shut your ****.
- From: doubt (@ 216.65.106.130)
on: Wed Oct 24 18:15:05 EDT 2001
Many portions of nanda songs resemble and reminded me of some old tunes. In the 'mun paniye' song, the chorus interludes is similar to the song 'velli malare velli malare' by rahman.
In the song 'Or 1000 yaanai', the 2-3 starting 'thaai vayithirl thalai keelaga…' resemble the lines 'vaan mazhai pol iravil varuvaan, in naan virumbum varaiyil..' in chandralekha song in thiruda thiruda.
- From: dsds (@ 24.178.147.172)
on: Wed Oct 24 18:45:11 EDT 2001
munpaniya mudharthuliya ---- song
same as
poongatrilae un swasathai --(uyirae)
- From: ram (@ 63.99.162.140)
on: Wed Oct 24 18:46:07 EDT 2001
i am new to this forum. heard Nandha's songs and should say that it was a different kind of effort from YSR. It seems that each song has a theme in this movie. "Mun Paniya" by SPB is superb. Other songs are also ok
- From: Rajini (@ 128.107.253.39)
on: Wed Oct 24 20:43:28 EDT 2001
Its ulta songs from ARR and IR...
- From: Callaspadeaspade (@ 207.18.199.140)
on: Wed Oct 24 23:34:30 EDT 2001
Mr ravi ,
apology accepted. Let me set the premise . I am an IR fan(atic) too but I draw the line when IR takes the mike. To define braying with respect to IR , i have to list a fusillade of songs that were just raped by him . But those would be my personal opinions and that could be biased . A few years ago, when "poonthottam" came out , it had a wonderful song "inia malarhal malarum". i think it was Anandha vikatan that actually came out with the criticism that IR should think twice before singing.
Sure , IR's voice has been compatible in certain situations. In "avadhaaram", I don't think any one else would have been a better fit.
As a music lover, don't tell me that it did not pain you to see IR sing "indha maan undhan sondha maan " from karagattakaran. the higher octaves were deplorable.
Had u noticed my dissent , i had said that IR was poor in higher octaves. Not every one can conquer the higher octaves.
My qualm is that IR gets carried away with himself and occassionally(more often nowadays) picks up a song and spoils it . The tune , unfortunately, turns out to be scintillating. And therein lies my frustration that IR does not recognize his limitations.
Of course , I'd rather listen to IR than listen to the Hindi coterie that ARR puts forth. But i do not listenn to ARR anyway.
- From: A.A (@ 203.197.135.88)
on: Thu Oct 25 01:40:06 EDT 2001
Nanda and Kasi have very similar themes...Kasi is Vikram starrer and remake of Malayalam hit.In KASI A HARIJAN GIRL LOVES THE COMPLEXED HANICAPED MAN and in Nandha a Srilankan tamil refujee loves complexed Soorya...Both the films have Panjam Patini and Soha...back ground the chances of both films Bombing at box office is very much there as both are Deepavali releases So do not hail the music of this film more than it really deserves.IMHO....below average....Nandha...Album.
List all pages of this thread
Post comments
Sections:
Home -
TFM Magazine -
Forum -
Wiki -
POW -
oPod -
Lyrics -
Pictures -
Music Notes -
Forums: Current Topics - Ilayaraja Albums - A.R. Rahman Albums - TFM Oldies - Fun & Games
Ilaiyaraja: Releases - News - Share Music - AR Rahman: Releases - News - AOTW - Tweets -
Discussions: MSV - YSR - GVP - Song Requests - Song stats - Raga of songs - Copying - Tweets
Database: Main - Singers - Music Director's - Lyricists Fun: PP - EKB - Relay - Satires - Quiz
Forums: Current Topics - Ilayaraja Albums - A.R. Rahman Albums - TFM Oldies - Fun & Games
Ilaiyaraja: Releases - News - Share Music - AR Rahman: Releases - News - AOTW - Tweets -
Discussions: MSV - YSR - GVP - Song Requests - Song stats - Raga of songs - Copying - Tweets
Database: Main - Singers - Music Director's - Lyricists Fun: PP - EKB - Relay - Satires - Quiz