Topic started by greatest_spb_fan (@ 212.2.14.241) on Thu Aug 2 04:57:19 EDT 2001.
All times in EST +10:30 for IST.
why don't anybody start a thread like 'SPB the greatest singer that India had ever produced', pls
Responses:
- Old responses
- From: Kaumudi (@ 136.142.153.250)
on: Thu Dec 19 11:38:02 EST 2002
Can someone please drive some sense into the heads of the authors of the above two posts? They need to understand that no one can come up with ONE and ONLY ONE singer called the greatest that India has ever produced. I am kind of sick of these stupid superlatives!
Raghu
Adding to what av says, you remind me of the saying "The pot calling the kettle black". God help your curiosity.
- From: a.v. (@ 132.216.68.184)
on: Thu Dec 19 11:47:58 EST 2002
Raghu - Realise that you and the PJC fan are respectively doing the greatest disservice to SPB and PJC, by acting like pathetic fanatics and posting the same rubbish everyday on so many threads. SPB would hate to have a fan like you, and PJC will find the above PJC-fan (krishnadas and his numerous different avatars) extremely despiccable. Can't the admin start blocking IP addresses of posters who keep writing nonsense, so as to maintain the bare minimum standard of this forum?
- From: Jana (@ 212.217.67.10)
on: Thu Dec 19 23:34:28 EST 2002
Raghu
Like many people say its probablmy not correct to say one singer as the best india has produced. For every talented guy like SPB or Karthik(i think he is very good among the newer ones) there might be 1000 better ones who never got a chance.
Just for your info my personal favourite is Mohd. Rafi :)
- From: Lord LabakuDas (@ 12.162.224.5)
on: Fri Dec 20 11:07:11 EST 2002
Intha thread ennaikku archive's pogutho annaikku naan car'ley vandhu pazhani muraganukku mottai podratha vendi irukken...
- From: Lord LabakuDas (@ 12.162.224.5)
on: Fri Dec 20 11:17:36 EST 2002
" From: Lord Labakudas (@ 203.106.224.21) on: Thu Dec 19 02:13:03 EST 2002
Both Raghu and this Jayachandran fan are idiots of the highest order.
Is it of surprise that both of them are fans of ilayaraja as well? "
Makkals, Ennoda perlayum ippo duplicate vara arambichiruchu..ennoda ip'ya nalla pathukonga..Naan Avan Illay..
- From: Yaaro (@ 195.92.67.71)
on: Tue Dec 24 10:50:03 EST 2002
LLD;
>>Intha thread ennaikku archive's pogutho annaikku naan car'ley vandhu pazhani muraganukku mottai podratha vendi irukken...
<<
neengha muthala athai seiyungappa :))
I do think that SPB is best singer in india now, but about the past, I have not got much knowledge about rafi, kk, etc, but currently amongs the playback singers of India, SPB is at the top of the list, closely followed by KJY
- From: Detective (@ 195.92.67.67)
on: Sun Dec 29 07:02:20 EST 2002
SPB rulZZZZ
- From: Hariharan & Co (@ 195.92.67.66)
on: Thu Jan 2 04:31:48 EST 2003
SPB is the best singer in india tday, no doubt
- From: suja (@ 203.199.213.3)
on: Fri Jan 3 05:18:47 EST 2003
Please understand,try to understand what was the condition of Sri JAYACHANDRAN in childhood.I am not among those people who makes heroes poor when they were in childhood.
Sri JAYACHANDRAN was searching for a job after somehow completing Bsc in chemistry from Christ college Irinjalakkuta.I will tell you the story,please listen what happened then.Listen carefully.
Even for getting the money for bus fare,he has to do the same job.The people who degrade him here were not there for helping him in those occassions.He was belonging to a royal family...hence doing job like ordinary people will make all to turn against him.But he worked day and night...with his inborn talent.Now also i can't agree reservation based on caste.It must be based on income.
His elder brother Sri sudhakaran was both a classical singer and mrudungum artist left his home and stayed at chennai.But.his effort was not sufficient for his family to live like all..jayachandran has to struggle.
In school days,he got first in youth festival where yeshudas was also a competitor.But Sri JAYACHANDRAN was the first.Yeshudas was first in classicals,and Sri JAYACHANDRAN was first in mrudungum.He used to sing kathakali sangeetham and read chenda,ashtapadhi,chakyar kooth,keli,all musical instruments with impressive performance in light music.But after this performance, since music was not that popular as today,there was severe money problem at home.He has to leave for chennai.
He met his elder brother,who was planning to come back to native since there was little chance for his music.But before leaving.he introduced Sri JAYACHANDRAN to yeshudas who was most famous (best too) in malayalam.Yeshudas used to go for classical concerts during those days.
Sri JAYACHANDRAN used to meet yeshudas regularly.But yeshudas used to tell fun,his ideologies about music,big big things.But Sri JAYACHANDRAN wanted just some chances atleast in mrudungum for getting his bread.But yeshudas,since knew Sri JAYACHANDRAN sung better than him in youth festival,made him to wander.
Sri JAYACHANDRAN made a habit to see yeshudas and come back for getting a chance as per his respected brother's precious advice.Meanwhile,his pennies with him reduced day by day.He informed his brother after 2 months his poor condition.He wanted a chance...but never wanted to cheat his "dasettan" as he used to call him.6 months passed without any use.He has to do work like an ordinary man at chennai in those days,he informed yeshudas his condition,but didn't helped him in any way.He was in big trouble.
One day Sri JAYACHANDRAN was sitting in front of yeshudas's house(not kjy's own,under rent) and was fully depressed at his condition.Yeshudas was inside eating food.One karnataka music director came there.He made yeshudas to sing in 7 films and wanted to make yeshudas sing for the eighth film.
Sri JAYACHANDRAN told him,yeshudas will come after eating food.The karnataka music director asked Sri JAYACHANDRAN why he was sitting there.He answered politely that he was waiting for a chance to read mrudungum in any classical concerts.He was impressed by the young man,understood his condition(Sri JAYACHANDRAN's condition) and promised to give a chance in his friend's classical concert.But he replied he must get the permission from yeshudas.When yeshudas came,he saw both talking.When Sri JAYACHANDRAN presented this in front of yeshudas,he was angry telling,"I'll give you chance,why to go with him?".But by the blessings of GOD,Sri JAYACHANDRAN did mrudungum well and the karnataka music director understood his performance in light music.Hence,in the eighth film in which he did music direction,there were only Sri JAYACHANDRAN's songs.There was no even a single song by yeshudas!!!!!He was understanding,yeshudas sings,but not even comparable to Sri JAYACHANDRAN's talent.You can guess how happy Sri JAYACHANDRAN would be while getting his first penny in music...But in malayalam everyone was going behind yeshudas.
In a stage programme at chennai,in which many sung (it was a local programme), accidentally one director vincent and music director Sri CHIDAMBARANATH heard Sri JAYACHANDRAN singing in stage.They requested famous music director Sri DEVARAJAN to try out this singer,who sung so well.
Devarajan initially didn't agree but later made Sri JAYACHANDRAN to sing.It was a chnage in trend of MALAYALAM FILM MUSIC...The great MANJALAYIL MUNGITHORTHI....came into existance.It was differnt from yeshudas's boring songs pavadaprayathil...,Jan ninne premikkunnu...,ni madhu pakaru,omalae kandoo jan etc.It gave some importance to our playback singing too ( MALAYALAM).
After that,Sri JAYACHANDRAN never had to look back,many many awards.He was the best playback singer in malayalam,obviously was a headache for yeshudas somebody singing better than him.He was planning to do something at this stage.
But..he has to wait...wait upto 1987.(I know,what hwppened,but can't make that secret public).Unfortunately Sri JAYACHANDRAN has to leave from our playback singing and was getting awards in TAMIL.That also was too much for yeshudas.Sri JAYACHANDRAN also sung in all languages iN india.In 1992,i remember he inaugaratted a function at calcutta after singing for 2 days and recording for a bengali film.But he is the ONLY singer who sung in most Indian REGIOANL languages.
Now he is old..but is now also best in malayalam.He came back with prayam nammil...getting state award.Again headache for yeshudas.But Sri JAYACHANDRAN being a good,generous,kind,self-respecting,not caring adverse experiences now also respects yeshudas by telling him as "DASETTAN" like that young man requested to him of age 23...for just entering into music!!!!!He forgot all that,he love music..he now also loves yeshudas.ITself shows how patient,good he is!
Last year during april,there was a programme (Light music concert) by Sri JAYACHANDRAN and his son,but he made yeshudas also to come for the programme after requesting the club members.
Sri JAYACHANDRAN's life resembles the story of a boy who became great after getting a dead rat thrown by one merchant,and finally returned bach a rat made in gold!!!Heard the story?
Ranjith,did you like the story of the king of music?I posted it for you ONLY BECAUSE THERE ARE MANY INCLUDING PUBLIC NEWSPAPERS WHICH PRAISES YESHUDAS, BUT PRETENDS AS IF THEY DON'T KNOW WHO IS JAYACHANDRAN....
- From: suja (@ 203.199.213.3)
on: Fri Jan 3 05:19:54 EST 2003
Please understand,try to understand what was the condition of Sri JAYACHANDRAN in childhood.I am not among those people who makes heroes poor when they were in childhood.
Sri JAYACHANDRAN was searching for a job after somehow completing Bsc in chemistry from Christ college Irinjalakkuta.I will tell you the story,please listen what happened then.Listen carefully.
Even for getting the money for bus fare,he has to do the same job.The people who degrade him here were not there for helping him in those occassions.He was belonging to a royal family...hence doing job like ordinary people will make all to turn against him.But he worked day and night...with his inborn talent.Now also i can't agree reservation based on caste.It must be based on income.
His elder brother Sri sudhakaran was both a classical singer and mrudungum artist left his home and stayed at chennai.But.his effort was not sufficient for his family to live like all..jayachandran has to struggle.
In school days,he got first in youth festival where yeshudas was also a competitor.But Sri JAYACHANDRAN was the first.Yeshudas was first in classicals,and Sri JAYACHANDRAN was first in mrudungum.He used to sing kathakali sangeetham and read chenda,ashtapadhi,chakyar kooth,keli,all musical instruments with impressive performance in light music.But after this performance, since music was not that popular as today,there was severe money problem at home.He has to leave for chennai.
He met his elder brother,who was planning to come back to native since there was little chance for his music.But before leaving.he introduced Sri JAYACHANDRAN to yeshudas who was most famous (best too) in malayalam.Yeshudas used to go for classical concerts during those days.
Sri JAYACHANDRAN used to meet yeshudas regularly.But yeshudas used to tell fun,his ideologies about music,big big things.But Sri JAYACHANDRAN wanted just some chances atleast in mrudungum for getting his bread.But yeshudas,since knew Sri JAYACHANDRAN sung better than him in youth festival,made him to wander.
Sri JAYACHANDRAN made a habit to see yeshudas and come back for getting a chance as per his respected brother's precious advice.Meanwhile,his pennies with him reduced day by day.He informed his brother after 2 months his poor condition.He wanted a chance...but never wanted to cheat his "dasettan" as he used to call him.6 months passed without any use.He has to do work like an ordinary man at chennai in those days,he informed yeshudas his condition,but didn't helped him in any way.He was in big trouble.
One day Sri JAYACHANDRAN was sitting in front of yeshudas's house(not kjy's own,under rent) and was fully depressed at his condition.Yeshudas was inside eating food.One karnataka music director came there.He made yeshudas to sing in 7 films and wanted to make yeshudas sing for the eighth film.
Sri JAYACHANDRAN told him,yeshudas will come after eating food.The karnataka music director asked Sri JAYACHANDRAN why he was sitting there.He answered politely that he was waiting for a chance to read mrudungum in any classical concerts.He was impressed by the young man,understood his condition(Sri JAYACHANDRAN's condition) and promised to give a chance in his friend's classical concert.But he replied he must get the permission from yeshudas.When yeshudas came,he saw both talking.When Sri JAYACHANDRAN presented this in front of yeshudas,he was angry telling,"I'll give you chance,why to go with him?".But by the blessings of GOD,Sri JAYACHANDRAN did mrudungum well and the karnataka music director understood his performance in light music.Hence,in the eighth film in which he did music direction,there were only Sri JAYACHANDRAN's songs.There was no even a single song by yeshudas!!!!!He was understanding,yeshudas sings,but not even comparable to Sri JAYACHANDRAN's talent.You can guess how happy Sri JAYACHANDRAN would be while getting his first penny in music...But in malayalam everyone was going behind yeshudas.
In a stage programme at chennai,in which many sung (it was a local programme), accidentally one director vincent and music director Sri CHIDAMBARANATH heard Sri JAYACHANDRAN singing in stage.They requested famous music director Sri DEVARAJAN to try out this singer,who sung so well.
Devarajan initially didn't agree but later made Sri JAYACHANDRAN to sing.It was a chnage in trend of MALAYALAM FILM MUSIC...The great MANJALAYIL MUNGITHORTHI....came into existance.It was differnt from yeshudas's boring songs pavadaprayathil...,Jan ninne premikkunnu...,ni madhu pakaru,omalae kandoo jan etc.It gave some importance to our playback singing too ( MALAYALAM).
After that,Sri JAYACHANDRAN never had to look back,many many awards.He was the best playback singer in malayalam,obviously was a headache for yeshudas somebody singing better than him.He was planning to do something at this stage.
But..he has to wait...wait upto 1987.(I know,what hwppened,but can't make that secret public).Unfortunately Sri JAYACHANDRAN has to leave from our playback singing and was getting awards in TAMIL.That also was too much for yeshudas.Sri JAYACHANDRAN also sung in all languages iN india.In 1992,i remember he inaugaratted a function at calcutta after singing for 2 days and recording for a bengali film.But he is the ONLY singer who sung in most Indian REGIOANL languages.
Now he is old..but is now also best in malayalam.He came back with prayam nammil...getting state award.Again headache for yeshudas.But Sri JAYACHANDRAN being a good,generous,kind,self-respecting,not caring adverse experiences now also respects yeshudas by telling him as "DASETTAN" like that young man requested to him of age 23...for just entering into music!!!!!He forgot all that,he love music..he now also loves yeshudas.ITself shows how patient,good he is!
Last year during april,there was a programme (Light music concert) by Sri JAYACHANDRAN and his son,but he made yeshudas also to come for the programme after requesting the club members.
Sri JAYACHANDRAN's life resembles the story of a boy who became great after getting a dead rat thrown by one merchant,and finally returned bach a rat made in gold!!!Heard the story?
Ranjith,did you like the story of the king of music?I posted it for you ONLY BECAUSE THERE ARE MANY INCLUDING PUBLIC NEWSPAPERS WHICH PRAISES YESHUDAS, BUT PRETENDS AS IF THEY DON'T KNOW WHO IS JAYACHANDRAN....
- From: Hariharan & Co (@ 195.92.67.74)
on: Fri Jan 3 12:33:40 EST 2003
(@ 203.199.213.3) & the rest of PJ fanatics;
PJ is a very good singer, but only idiots will compare PJ with the Genius SPB, ask PJ, he him self will say SPB is the greatest singer that India had ever produced!
List all pages of this thread
Post comments
Sections:
Home -
TFM Magazine -
Forum -
Wiki -
POW -
oPod -
Lyrics -
Pictures -
Music Notes -
Forums: Current Topics - Ilayaraja Albums - A.R. Rahman Albums - TFM Oldies - Fun & Games
Ilaiyaraja: Releases - News - Share Music - AR Rahman: Releases - News - AOTW - Tweets -
Discussions: MSV - YSR - GVP - Song Requests - Song stats - Raga of songs - Copying - Tweets
Database: Main - Singers - Music Director's - Lyricists Fun: PP - EKB - Relay - Satires - Quiz
Forums: Current Topics - Ilayaraja Albums - A.R. Rahman Albums - TFM Oldies - Fun & Games
Ilaiyaraja: Releases - News - Share Music - AR Rahman: Releases - News - AOTW - Tweets -
Discussions: MSV - YSR - GVP - Song Requests - Song stats - Raga of songs - Copying - Tweets
Database: Main - Singers - Music Director's - Lyricists Fun: PP - EKB - Relay - Satires - Quiz