Topic started by draj (@ 210.195.144.100) on Tue Dec 24 07:11:08 EST 2002.
All times in EST +10:30 for IST.
okok..i didnt mean to hurt yuvanS fan out there..but..itz a clear cut u see..till date yuvan has a lot of superb songs.. but if u take it accordingly..ok lets see,.. if anyone heard a copy of ARR kadhal virus 'BAILAMORE' and YUVANS 'z bala''z bailamore'... WHICH ONE IS BETTER.. of course is kadhal virus..so wat u need some more.. padmashree is always the best.
Responses:
- Old responses
- From: vs (@ 61.11.43.97)
on: Thu Dec 26 09:15:13 EST 2002
kadhal virus is one of the worst albums of this year.arr is composing too badly nowadays.useless
crap yetagain by kadhir.
- From: dev (@ 63.206.198.26)
on: Thu Dec 26 20:22:04 EST 2002
both the bailamores suck.
why don't you guys compare two good songs?
- From: Paran (@ 210.193.13.119)
on: Thu Dec 26 21:14:09 EST 2002
WHO ARE YOU GUYS DARE TO DOWNGRADE YSR...
He is better than Mozart okie...even Mozart admitted that in The Hindus.....yesterday..check page 32....
YSR is out of this world....totally..out...may be..somewhere near Pluto.....freezed in galaxy...and still tryign to churn out music....which he hopes to travel through vacuum space...
and yet..YSR fans...could hear it...loud and clear (eventhough it is not acceptable at all..i mean..soudn thorugh vacuum)....
YSR rocks.....he is teh best MD in PLUTO.....as there is no other Homo Saphiens there..heheheh
kidding.......
- From: draj (@ 210.195.144.1)
on: Fri Dec 27 00:55:19 EST 2002
yeah yeah....yuvan is juz the the bet md in pluto where no human being'z are living to hear his ???songz.....?plzler........yuvan is very talented and a good composer but...never try to compare him wif our padmashriler....itz like insulting him...
- From: Paran (@ 210.193.13.69)
on: Fri Dec 27 01:19:05 EST 2002
draj.....i am not underestimating YSR...i do believe...adn accept that he is talented...but teh idea of comapring him with ARR...and as teh matter of fact...any other MD with ARR really pisses me off....
even IR is a very good MD indeed...but when we are talkign abt successfull MD...it got to be ARR...do u guys agree...
ARR is smart in marekting himself...well IR failed on that matter...thats' all...
ARR chooses the best Directors to work with..IR...works with anyone...
so..IR doesn't get enough recignition like ARR...that's all
- From: Paran (@ 210.193.13.69)
on: Fri Dec 27 01:19:42 EST 2002
and same goes with YSR..
- From: draj (@ 210.195.144.30)
on: Fri Dec 27 04:37:45 EST 2002
yeahhhhh,,..u r rite paran..i agree wiff u.paran..
- From: Dinesh (@ 210.186.42.99)
on: Fri Dec 27 09:06:43 EST 2002
Dun 4get the most useless MD of TFM = Harris Jeyaraj.....nothing but a copy cat of Rahman,he will compose untill there is rahman songs!!i wonder what songs will HJ copy from rahman for Saami & Kaake Kaake!!
- From: Dorai (@ 165.89.84.249)
on: Thu Jan 2 15:28:40 EST 2003
YSR's latest from Mounam Pessiyadhe is a very good album.
I like the song "EnAnbe EnAnbe", nicely tuned and composed. I like the African style percussion interludes... He has come of his age finally...(I hope so...)
- From: 'Kadhal Mannan' AJITH (@ 195.93.73.7)
on: Wed Jan 8 13:48:07 EST 2003
this year a.r has waste his time with 'kadal virus' but ysr give lot of beatiful songs like:
in kadhal samrajyam "iru kangal" & others
in april madhatil "poi sollae" & others
in mownam pesyadae "en anbae" & others
about me, a.r can stay in london . ANGAYE STING TUNE TIRUDATAM LIKE "VAN NILA" FROM KV
- From: C~P (@ 202.9.149.65)
on: Thu Jan 9 02:16:29 EST 2003
'Kadhal Mannan' AJITH ,
u managed 4.5 lines w/o Caps!! :D
- From: Pam (@ 202.51.148.233)
on: Thu Jan 9 05:54:54 EST 2003
YSR's Punnagai Poove was very nice, and PopCarn too... ( especially Kaadhalaagi by SPB) .
But still ARR RULZ!!!!!!!!!!
- From: BT (@ 207.46.228.14)
on: Thu Jan 9 13:52:00 EST 2003
Another one of those sleeping threads...
draj! Except for the words "bailamos/bailamore" (pronounced differently in each song), there's nothing common in those songs... Why compare two unrelated songs??
I wonder what the policy of TFM page forum is... Keep all music related (even vaguely) threads, however insane the subject may be??
- From: Jay (@ 203.124.234.166)
on: Fri Jan 10 00:32:07 EST 2003
Yuvan Shankar is a clear copycat of A R Rahman. Listen to his Bala song, that Yen Kannai... It clearly sounds like Satrangi re.. or its Tamil version, Yen uyirae.., from the Mani Ratnam movie Dil se.. or Tamil Uyirae. All of you will agree with me.
- From: Are Yaar (@ 203.115.31.67)
on: Fri Jan 10 05:34:09 EST 2003
Jay:
I agree and I have mentioned this too.
- From: Kalai (@ 61.11.77.139)
on: Fri Jan 10 06:15:17 EST 2003
Jay, Are Yar,
Can you mention which portion of En Kannai(BALA) resembles En Uyire(UYIRE). What is that, that is common in these songs? tune or beat or anything else?
Please justify if you think your statement in not senseless.
- From: JYOTHI, U.K (@ 213.2.111.98)
on: Fri Jan 10 08:36:04 EST 2003
Okay, so YSR has composed some excellent nimbers this year, whereas ARR has did quite nice numbers but not great. However when ARR comes good it is out of this world,,,Lets just wait patiently this year.
- From: BT (@ 207.46.228.14)
on: Sat Jan 11 02:46:36 EST 2003
(The conversation is turning healthy. This is good to see)
I have no idea about the copying. In my opinion, Yuvan is a great talent, but lately he's been churning away a ton of movies. I hope he restricts himself and gives even better scores.
It's a great achievement for Yuvan, for being even compared to ARR. Competition is always welcome... it's us who benefit from that.
- From: Are Yaar (@ 203.115.31.67)
on: Sat Jan 11 03:06:03 EST 2003
Kalai:
If you sing both songs or play them in your system simnultateously then you will hardly find difference in majority of the tune.
But YSR is intelligent. Its like remixing that he has done. I am not a person who condemns that. YSR is learning and he can learn only from his masters. But if he continues these things regularly the he will be only another HJ or VS. I don't want him to be like that.
- From: Kalai (@ 61.11.76.199)
on: Sat Jan 11 04:08:05 EST 2003
Are Yar,
Read and please reply you opinion
I don't find any similarity betrween the two songs when I hear back to back.
Try to do this...
Sing the En Kannai Pidingikkol Pennae lyrics in En Uyirae tune.
I tried to do this, but i wasn't able to.
If you can do the above, you are someone great and no point in us arguing and ignore the following.
If you can't that is reallity. En Kannai is ORIGINAL.
Copying songs sin. Giving flase alarm that a song has been copied is a bigger sin. Don't do this.
- From: C~P (@ 202.9.147.96)
on: Sat Jan 11 08:30:44 EST 2003
kkk....high time.....
Kannai Pidingi Kol i thot resembles Moondru ezhuthu Ketta Vaarthai
can some1 clarify??? .... unfort. i don have Satrangi Re on my sys :(
- From: Are Yaar (@ 203.115.31.67)
on: Sat Jan 11 09:36:21 EST 2003
KKK:
That's why I said YSR did a sort or remix into it. And I praised him doing that...There are many instances where YSR composed in the lines of ARR....Well if you don't want to believe then its upto you.
CP:
Some of my coleagues also said so when the film songs released...But for me it striked with Satrangi re song...
Well Moonrezhuththu is also ARR's....
But I am saying is why should people not try to take things that are pretty obvious.
- From: Are Yaar (@ 203.115.31.67)
on: Sat Jan 11 09:43:34 EST 2003
Sorry Kalai:
Got caried away by CP...so no KKK...its kalai..ok
- From: JAY (@ 203.124.234.166)
on: Sat Jan 11 09:57:04 EST 2003
YEN KANNAI.. FROM BALA IS A COPY CAT SONG
LISTEN TO UYIRAE SONG,
YEN AAR UYIRAE LINE IN UYIRAE AND ..UNNALAE IN BALA,
YUVAN UR A COPYCAT
THSI YEAR WONT FARE WELL.
A R RAHMAN IS BACK THIS YEAR
- From: MUSIC LOVER (@ 195.226.230.37)
on: Wed Jan 15 15:50:57 EST 2003
PARAN AND ARE YAAR IM HERE SO KEEP OUT BEFORE I GET IN TO MY SLAMMING OF U GUYS AND ARR,HAHAHAHA,THEY WILL DISAPPEAR NOW
- From: Bala (@ 4.37.102.100)
on: Wed Jan 15 17:16:15 EST 2003
some guy is talking out here about ARR marketing himself very well.. but not ilayaraaja.. its really funny.FYI.. ilayaraja ruled the south indian cinema for more than 20 years.. still he is busy working with big banners and young directors..But think about A.R.R he lost his good will towards his favourite companies.Rajini's first choice was always A.R.R but now... same thing with Balachander and Barathiraaja. Kathir is also reconsidering his decision of making movies with A.R.R. Another big name is A.M Ratnam.. who kicked off A.R.R from his unit.Vidyasagar took his place and he is far better in doing the job.U guys can easily imagine how bad the Ratnam movies like RUN and Dhool if those have been orchestrated by ARR.He is best in doing some video albums for sony.But not for movies.Every other director want him on the movies to get an attraction to their movie.But now that also has gone after his poor show all over the year.On the whole did he ever try anything new.. he is s good sound engineer thats all.Think about Yuvan .. if u guys listen to the Kaathalagi kaninthu in popcorn and munpaniyaa in nandha..what a musical value they have.I just quote some..if u want i can give as much u want .. if u guys could quote something like this from ARR music then i will accept him as a great music director..
- From: Lollu Party (@ 61.6.38.132)
on: Wed Jan 15 19:46:01 EST 2003
OK, YOU don't have to accept him as a great music director.
Satisfied?
- From: Paran (@ 210.193.13.206)
on: Wed Jan 15 20:36:14 EST 2003
Aiyoo ML...we are so scared of u man...
i'm even "pissing" in my pant...just because i read ur posting......i'm a "musicloverophobia"..
ade podanggo.......y u like to create ur own stories......u have a great imagination man..i heard Disney is looking for a creative person...wanna join them?
by that..at least ur creativity will be paid off..
- From: Dinesh (@ 210.186.42.203)
on: Thu Jan 16 09:09:24 EST 2003
AM RATNAM KICK ARR?u mus be dreaming..then who is the producer for Unnake 18 Ennaku 20 & BOyz??ur father is it??
& PLZZ..ARR IS THE BEST EVEN IN THIS SHORT 10 years!he have archived more then illai in 20 years!
List all pages of this thread
Post comments
Sections:
Home -
TFM Magazine -
Forum -
Wiki -
POW -
oPod -
Lyrics -
Pictures -
Music Notes -
Forums: Current Topics - Ilayaraja Albums - A.R. Rahman Albums - TFM Oldies - Fun & Games
Ilaiyaraja: Releases - News - Share Music - AR Rahman: Releases - News - AOTW - Tweets -
Discussions: MSV - YSR - GVP - Song Requests - Song stats - Raga of songs - Copying - Tweets
Database: Main - Singers - Music Director's - Lyricists Fun: PP - EKB - Relay - Satires - Quiz
Forums: Current Topics - Ilayaraja Albums - A.R. Rahman Albums - TFM Oldies - Fun & Games
Ilaiyaraja: Releases - News - Share Music - AR Rahman: Releases - News - AOTW - Tweets -
Discussions: MSV - YSR - GVP - Song Requests - Song stats - Raga of songs - Copying - Tweets
Database: Main - Singers - Music Director's - Lyricists Fun: PP - EKB - Relay - Satires - Quiz