Topic started by Surya (@ 213.122.244.153) on Fri Dec 1 15:22:56 EST 2000.
All times in EST +10:30 for IST.
YSR's Dheena starring Ajit should be coming out soon. Has anyone any info about it?Also what are his other upcoming projects?
Responses:
- Old responses
- From: a Sad Old timer (@ 63.225.174.176)
on: Sun Feb 11 03:01:28 EST 2001
It is high time to shut down this site for a short period of time...something like a vacation.(2 months)
Too much trash talk is going on.....and
things are going crazy.....
at this rate what ever good name this site earned in the past will be wiped out. :(
- From: check it out (@ 202.188.196.83)
on: Sun Feb 11 09:00:06 EST 2001
i personally think that dheena has horrible music. a severe let down after poovellaam kettupaar
- From: Vijay Venkatram J (@ 202.54.33.161)
on: Sun Feb 11 13:32:36 EST 2001
check it out:
I strongly object! I believe Dheena is an improvisation after Poovellam Kettuppaar from Yuvan! In fact, there are no interlude repetitions and dryness compared to PK! All songs in Dheena are both catchy + situational simultaneously maintaining the flow!
In fact Music has saved the fil Dheena, that is what the Press and Audience Say!
Maestro Ilaiyaraaja's Fans Come To:
http://clubs.yahoo.com/clubs/maestroilaiyaraajafansclub
- From: a Sad New Timer (@ 4.54.212.102)
on: Sun Feb 11 15:32:14 EST 2001
If this site is shut down for vacation, Hawai is a beautiful place for vacation
- From: trying to close bold (@ 156.153.255.195) on: Mon Feb 12 00:17:42 EST 2001
- From: failed to close "bold" (@ 156.153.255.195) on: Mon Feb 12 00:18:30 EST 2001
sad new timer you have to do it :-(
- From: yvs mani (@ 164.100.191.194) on: Mon Feb 12 06:43:30 EST 2001
Initially, I felt Dheena's music is not upto that point. After 2 or 3 hearings, I wish to hear it again and again. especially, sollammal thottu, nee illai endraal.
- From: madhav (@ 213.122.197.83) on: Mon Feb 12 10:38:28 EST 2001
We have again strayed from the topic. It is not whether we want TFM to close down for a two week vacation in Hawai:-)
Dheena, has now gained its rightful place at the top of the tfm charts and I hope Yuvan will get his deserved credit for his wonderful music. Keep it up Yuvan
- From: closing bold (@ 172.135.81.50) on: Mon Feb 12 11:35:03 EST 2001
- From: trying to close bold (@ 156.153.255.195) on: Mon Feb 12 00:17:42 EST 2001
- From: Fliflo (@ 146.186.113.254)
on: Mon Feb 12 11:58:48 EST 2001
Hit of today:
http://www.sysindia.com/tamil/cine/box/feb112k1.htm
Dheena pushes friends and tops the list!
- From: Travis (@ 194.85.200.36)
on: Mon Feb 12 16:18:07 EST 2001
If dheena's music is no.1 and it is what Tamil Public like, by Gods, where has TFM come to?
If one judges the quality of music by box-office records, then from the link (from IP 146.186.113.254), no doubt Thenali's medicore(?) music is a far 5th compared to the enchanting music of Dheena, inspiring music of Friends, mind-blowing Vanchinathan(by KR!) and of all people SAR's Priyamanavale...
AR Rahman has too many enemies and they seem to haunt him everywhere from message forums to box office records...
- From: Travis (@ 194.85.200.36)
on: Mon Feb 12 16:24:17 EST 2001
If dheena's music is no.1 and it is what Tamil Public like, by Gods, where has TFM come to?
If one judges the quality of music by box-office records, then from the link (from IP 146.186.113.254), no doubt Thenali's medicore(?) music is a far 5th compared to the enchanting music of Dheena, inspiring music of Friends, mind-blowing Vanchinathan(by KR!) and of all people SAR's Priyamanavale...
AR Rahman has too many enemies and they seem to haunt him everywhere from message forums to box office records...
- From: **** (@ 203.145.133.130)
on: Tue Feb 13 00:22:07 EST 2001
fuk u a$$ travis,
oruthan olunga malai vandhaa ungalukelam peidkadhey.
a$$
- From: Kupps (@ 156.153.255.195)
on: Tue Feb 13 02:02:00 EST 2001
travis we need not have to give this much comment for the top albums listed by that site. i think the list is prepared based on audio sales, at present, that too based on some shops(imho).
remember thenali's audio came long back and it is not considered as one of the bests of ARR. even audio sale of one of the bests of ARR are outsted by another release of ARR, so can we claim that to be bad? tell me, at present, cassettes of indian or thenali which one is moving fast? thenali..is the answer, right? do u think thenali is better than indian?
imho minnalae is a better album than dheena. but it has got position 2 which is ok for me because there might not be much difference in number 1's count and number 2's count and especially for albums like these. had minnalae been pushed beyond thenali then we can claim that there is something fishy.
but i feel that there is fishy about position of priyamanavalae :-))
- From: Travis (@ 194.85.200.36)
on: Tue Feb 13 04:29:19 EST 2001
Dear Kupps,
Thank You. At least, you got me right. I dont believe in these box office records... But with some people bragging that dheena is in top of list and associated ireelevancies, I just wanted to point out a simple fact except for minnale and thenali there isnt one movie which has escaped the mediocrity of today's TF music and I included the chart becoz it just suffices to my view that quality is not there if an album is no.1 in the charts.
Does anyone of u think in 2 months time you can actually distinguish music from dheena and friends or priyamanavale?
Dear **** (@ 203.145.133.130),
I am not against YSR coming up in life. If i met up with him personally, I am sure I cant match half his wits. But is that the point? What I wanted to emphasize was that dheena music is less inspiring, in my opinion, that poovellam kettupar. Though the latter didnt itself set any standards is irrelevant, At least he made a sincere attempt. I am frustrated that just bcoz of just YSR (I dont know what u guys think, but I believe most) are expecting to see a rejuvenated raja in him. Well, let YSR just come up with some quality stuff that lets u sit up and ask who is this guy(in a good sense!), forget about rahman, like his father. Of course its true that he is young and all. Fine and so is Bharadwaj, who in my view, did a wonderful job parthen rasithen. and same goes to Harris Jeyaraj. Didnt these people came out of obscurity ONLY bcoz of the quality they delivered? Doesnt YSR, coming from a musical-genii family, ought to have got this right? For all the glitter that surrounds his family, he should be the best musician in these(, of course second only to his bro! ) times.
- From: Kupps (@ 156.153.255.195) on: Tue Feb 13 04:56:47 EST 2001
Travis i beg to differ from you with respect to Friends and Thenali. IMHO Friends is slightly better than Thenali ofcourse, i have a soft-corner to IR's music. but i sincerly wanted to compare these two with respect to my music taste (not with respect to their(albums') stuff, because im zero in classical knowledge). as per my comparison Friends is better than thenali.
IMHO both are not-so-good-stuff from either of the MDs, that is apart.
- From: appa indha bold tholla thanga mudiyalai (@ 156.153.255.195) on: Tue Feb 13 04:58:47 EST 2001
- From: (@ 156.153.255.195) on: Tue Feb 13 04:59:30 EST 2001
- From: (@ 156.153.255.195) on: Tue Feb 13 05:00:41 EST 2001
Travis you should have closed the bold
- From: Kupps (@ 156.153.255.195) on: Tue Feb 13 04:56:47 EST 2001
- From: Travis (@ 194.85.200.36)
on: Tue Feb 13 05:15:35 EST 2001
Dear Kupps,
I agree I was hasty and wrong in including friends to mediocrity. I am sorry, me being a arr fan, expected. Lets forget about thenali and friends since you cant convince me that thenali isnot as good as friends and the same way I cant do the vice-versa.
Returning to the topic, what do u think of dheena's music? You said Minnale is your fav... lets see what others have to say.
- From: Gangai Amaran (@ 194.127.2.7)
on: Tue Feb 13 05:49:44 EST 2001
Dheena is the worst album i heard recently. YSR tried to copy ARR but in vain. Soon YSR will sit along with his father IR and chase flies in his house in Pannapuram.
- From: Kupps (@ 156.153.255.195)
on: Tue Feb 13 05:56:40 EST 2001
Travis
First of all thanks for closing the bold :-)
I know there is a hidden-smily after your statement I was hasty and wrong in including friends to mediocrity. Its ok man. As you said we cannot(and don't have to) convince either of the other as long as we could appreciate the goodie in our not-so-favourite MD's products.
As far as Dheena is concerned, I like one song that is vathhikucchi song. I liked it in the first time when i heard it in the theatre. I think it is some mexico-calypso musical stuff. But definitely a very good trial. Others did not impress me much.
Minnalae is similar to Dheena as far as my liking goes. I mean, Vaseegara is a very good song and others fade under its power. But IMHO other songs of Minnalae are slightly better than other songs of Dheena and Vaseegara is better than vathhikucchi. These two MDs are budding. Hence altogether their work is good. Lets wait and see how they are performing in future.
- From: Question (@ 209.187.151.146)
on: Tue Feb 13 09:05:15 EST 2001
I just wanted to point out a simple fact except for minnale and thenali there isnt one movie which has escaped the mediocrity of today's TF music
This shows that you are an ARR fan. And FYI, Thenali is a perfect example of the mediocrity of today's TF music. But where were you when it was at no.1?
- From: Travis (@ 194.85.200.36)
on: Tue Feb 13 09:23:42 EST 2001
Thats it.. My cover is blown... indeed am a fan of rahman and I am proud to be so.. rather than listen to silly stuff just for the sake of being the 'different' kind....Mediocrity (as u call it) of Rahman , my dear, is still dizzying heights that the other music directors day-dream to achieve...
and thenali is in way medicore by any standards.... vaasame and porkalam are just examples.
- From: DigestTheFact (@ 209.187.151.146)
on: Tue Feb 13 10:11:57 EST 2001
Travis:
Enjoying Music is purely subjective. There is no end debting any particular album is mediocre or not. The one sounds bad to you might be good to me. There is no common ground for that. To IR fans, ARR is a mediocre MD. And obviously for ARR fans, whoever comes next going to be mediocre. It is just a cycle and simple truth. If you are proud about ARR, so be it. I am proud of whom I like and what I like. If you think today's TFM is mediocre, I would say ARR is the reason for bringing TFM to this level. If you can't digest others' albums topping the chart, don't listen and don't cry about mediocrity.
Mediocrity (as u call it) of Rahman , my dear, is still dizzying heights that the other music directors day-dream to achieve...
Dude, wait for some more time. He is going to be on the ground with others.
- From: Travis (@ 194.85.200.36)
on: Tue Feb 13 11:03:39 EST 2001
Yes, if that day comes when arr is grounded by ysr, kr, deva and the rest, i will be a fan of anu malik.
and please, the statement that arr brought mediocrity to tfm is atrocious...Is it the fault of arr that so many useless mds tried to follow his footsteps in vain, jumped into the bandwagon with cheap so-called camouflaged versions of arr and have created this stale phase of tfm. No way! Its shame on you to say such a baseless thing on the prodigy of 90's.
List all pages of this thread
Post comments
Sections:
Home -
TFM Magazine -
Forum -
Wiki -
POW -
oPod -
Lyrics -
Pictures -
Music Notes -
Forums: Current Topics - Ilayaraja Albums - A.R. Rahman Albums - TFM Oldies - Fun & Games
Ilaiyaraja: Releases - News - Share Music - AR Rahman: Releases - News - AOTW - Tweets -
Discussions: MSV - YSR - GVP - Song Requests - Song stats - Raga of songs - Copying - Tweets
Database: Main - Singers - Music Director's - Lyricists Fun: PP - EKB - Relay - Satires - Quiz
Forums: Current Topics - Ilayaraja Albums - A.R. Rahman Albums - TFM Oldies - Fun & Games
Ilaiyaraja: Releases - News - Share Music - AR Rahman: Releases - News - AOTW - Tweets -
Discussions: MSV - YSR - GVP - Song Requests - Song stats - Raga of songs - Copying - Tweets
Database: Main - Singers - Music Director's - Lyricists Fun: PP - EKB - Relay - Satires - Quiz