Topic started by siva (@ 161.142.78.82) on Wed Nov 8 01:19:34 EST 2000.
All times in EST +10:30 for IST.
http://www.musicurry.com/tamil/cook0032_jeni.html
is it true???
Responses:
- From: yaaro (@ 195.92.67.217)
on: Wed Nov 8 08:34:34 EST 2000
so what?even if the queen of england dances to his tunes,we will never be impressed-we have heard better music.
- From: UV (@ 134.113.203.137)
on: Wed Nov 8 10:32:27 EST 2000
Yaaro
En Sir sandai and sindu mudivathe neer virumbum thozilo ? It is true or not why not be proud as Indian and tamilian getting some recognization.
Shame on you,ur fanatism is blinding u from appreciating good stuff.
- From: expecting a good fight (@ 202.54.13.6)
on: Wed Nov 8 10:42:17 EST 2000
he an only make peoples legs and hands moving but not their soul moving..only maestro IR can do it..he touches every ones heart with his music
- From: some fuel to fight (@ 216.190.255.35)
on: Wed Nov 8 12:38:34 EST 2000
We will be impressed only
if arr does not work with MR, SHANKER and other leading directors,
if he starts composing super hits song like "thirunalveli" ...(folksy tamil sand smelling song).
if arr sells his studio and starts a poti kadai in his back yard.
if arr does not relase his "bombay dreams".
if arr does not accept to work with MJ.
finally,
if arr gives away all his oppurtunities.
- From: ARR_fan (@ 63.101.96.1)
on: Wed Nov 8 12:57:36 EST 2000
sftl,
one more - if ARR accepts he is not a composer but only a sound engineer:-)
- From: jobless@arr.com (@ 216.190.255.35)
on: Wed Nov 8 13:19:55 EST 2000
an interview with arr that ir fans like!..
Q: People tell you copy? , Why do you copy music?
A: Who does not copy, how many fans of super start dress like him or have mannerisms like him, similarly I am a fan of many musicians, so I try to be like others composers I know.
Q:It seems you repeat the same tunes in all the movies, why?
A: Oh! (Laughs) for the past 2 years I have a lucky keyboard in which few keys dont work, so I am forced to use the same working keys for “composing” songs,
(With a commanding tone) this will be all right as soon as it is fixed.
Q: People tell you are sound engineer why?
A: From my birth I wanted to become an engineer, but due to family and other reasons I could not achieve it but now by gods grace I have achieved it, I take is as a compliment.
Q: Why do you work with MR, Shanker like directors only?
A:, Why do want an interview from me? (Laughs) I work with them because they are famous.
Q: What is the new keyboard you have?
A: Microsofts wireless keyboard., you know it drains lot of battery.
Q: Do you write score?
A: It is been long since I saw cricket.
(to be continued)
- From: gt (@ 63.108.172.129)
on: Wed Nov 8 13:28:53 EST 2000
ARR's songs are definitely catchy
Can we imagine Jennifer Lopez dancing for a great song like "Vizhiyil" from "Alaigal Oivathillai"?
We definitely need ARR's kind of tunes for people like Jennifer
- From: pacca american (@ 198.4.92.5)
on: Wed Nov 8 13:47:10 EST 2000
jennifer lopez with a third world musician.
Interesting!.
- From: Trend (@ 216.68.113.227)
on: Wed Nov 8 14:20:56 EST 2000
jobless@arr.com,
Your Q&A were good.I will just add a few more to try to entertain IR fans.
Q.Neenga MD aagarathukku munnala enna pannittu irundhingha?
A.I was running a small shop which makes xerox copies of anything you give.I was in this business for nearly 5 years when I became so successful I thought of changing careers.
Q.Why music field?
A.In principle both the careers are very similar to me.
Q.What is your favourite key on the keyboard?
A.Ctrl-C and Ctrl-V.If I don't use these keys for one day I can't sleep peacefully.
Trend
- From: Logic King (@ 208.237.135.21)
on: Wed Nov 8 16:10:40 EST 2000
Rahman And Jennifer Lopez???
What will Puff Daddy do??
God save Indian music
- From: siva (@ 161.142.78.82)
on: Wed Nov 8 19:53:54 EST 2000
Well, i did not expect a fight when i started this thread... was just curios of the authencity of the source...
well, if its true, then i am definitely eagerly waiting for the song and the MTV video (if there is one)...
btw, i am a fan of both the maestro and arr
- From: (^!^) (@ 208.24.179.211)
on: Wed Nov 8 20:12:18 EST 2000
siva: aren't you a fan of Jennifer Lopez?:-)
- From: Bore (@ 216.34.244.106)
on: Wed Nov 8 20:12:58 EST 2000
Trend, - you lack a sense of humor. Big Bore!
- From: Bore (@ 216.34.244.19)
on: Wed Nov 8 20:13:54 EST 2000
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Trend, - you lack a sense of humor. Big Bore!
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
- From: G. Kuppusamy (@ 156.153.255.250)
on: Wed Nov 8 23:39:12 EST 2000
digression
jobless@arr.com i liked ur interview with ARR. But i need a clarification from "YOUR ARR". In the first question he justifies his copying by quoting super star's fans. but jobless@arr.com's ARR sir, they dont get paid for such copying but u r :-)
end digression
siva, in preliminary state of this rumour, i can just state that it can happen. he is working with sir lloyds et al. why can't with jeniffer? he is a great MD. if this concert has to attract a lot of indian market then ARR will be used by jeniffer or sir lloyd or know personality, for its success.
- From: peeps (@ 202.54.13.6)
on: Thu Nov 9 00:21:44 EST 2000
A compatively very small mail from kupps..
ennachu kupps????why soo small mail???
illa adutha maila continue pannuveengala??
- From: G. Kuppusamy (@ 156.153.255.250)
on: Thu Nov 9 03:10:28 EST 2000
:-)
- From: Trend (@ 216.68.113.227)
on: Thu Nov 9 08:44:13 EST 2000
Bore,
Thanks for your compliment.I will try to be a bigger bore in the future.-)
Trend
- From: Billa (@ 129.253.193.7)
on: Thu Nov 9 12:46:39 EST 2000
From: expecting a good fight (@ 202.54.13.6) on: Wed Nov 8 10:42:17 EST 2000
he an only make peoples legs and hands moving but not their soul moving..only maestro IR can do it..he touches every ones heart with his music
Hi, Now I understand why they do not broadcast IR's songs in operation theatre. How the hell can they conduct surgery if the heart and soul keeps moving all the time?? BTW, indirectly do you mean ARR fans are heartless?? and also from your post I infer that for some people, IR's music moves the head also from its original location to somewhere below the waist!!
- From: Logic King (@ 208.237.135.12)
on: Thu Nov 9 13:18:29 EST 2000
Grow up guys ............
- From: yaaro (@ 213.123.29.70)
on: Thu Nov 9 16:51:28 EST 2000
very funny billa!
i am running out to buy some vayithu vali maathirai..
more jokes like this please!
- From: KRM (@ 205.227.60.67)
on: Thu Nov 9 21:00:08 EST 2000
The fact of the matter is rahman has the talent and his popularity reaches far and wide. Rahman is calm and gives everbody from the people who sing harmony to the sound engineer credit for the success of his music. He does not stop with SPB, chitra, and a few prefered voices but is always introducing new talent. The fact that when rahman introduces novel ideas it instantly becomes the norm for popular music, copied by every other MD for his next movie, is proof enough for his creative talent. If the masses do not recognize other MD's , because of rahamn's music, that should not undermine rahman's talent. People said that rahman is a 1 time wonder after roja and gentlemen...the fact that he is still going from strength to stregth with his fans following always increasing is reason enough to acknowledge his enormous talent.
- From: expecting a good fight (@ 202.54.13.6)
on: Thu Nov 9 23:47:25 EST 2000
Billa,
Yes...IR's music makes the head to move below waist..that is because we bend our head below our waist before HIS music(humbleness)..
U know one thing they are giving anacin and vicks along with THENALI casette..go and get it and enjoy..:-)..:-)
- From: STS (@ 38.29.70.134)
on: Fri Nov 10 00:15:42 EST 2000
KRM,
ARR uses each and everyone because he can't do it alone. When you don't have your own ideas you depend on others. Giving credit does not make one great musician. When you say ARR is calm, how about others? Deva is very very calm. Talents introduced by IR is countless. (Names are listed in some of the threads). I don't think Udit, Saadhana are talents. Samway I don't accept Lata or Aasha in Tamil (when IR let them sing few songs). Please understand that introducing talents is to hide the similarity of the same tunes being used and reused.
fact that when rahman introduces novel ideas it instantly becomes the norm for popular music... Can you pls let us know the novel ideas introduced by ARR? Copying?? Well, well. I am fed of this topic.
Looks like he peaked early enough and his recent albums like Alai Paayudhe, Rhythm, Thenaali are mediocre which are comparable only to SAR (not even to Deva).
ARR is replaced by YSR/KR. Believe it or not
- From: thayaaaaaaaaaaaaaa (@ 4.4.74.119)
on: Fri Nov 10 00:22:25 EST 2000
hey STS man ...
u sure are one hell of a hypocrite ... in some thread, someone asked u, why do u criticize arr .. u said, u dont and that u respect him ... now, if u ahve to support ir, why not do it iwthout comparison ? ob'ly u r a hcirf .. but man, dont change your colors so often ....give us some time .. :)))) to digest your dynamic brain..
- From: expecting a good fight (@ 202.54.13.6)
on: Fri Nov 10 00:39:35 EST 2000
well done STS
- From: G. Kuppusamy (@ 156.153.255.250)
on: Fri Nov 10 09:03:53 EST 2000
(Rahman And Jennifer Lopez) -> IR v/s ARR
(IR and Paul mauriat) -> IR v/s ARR
(Paatu and Music) -> IR v/s ARR
(andha kaalathu paatu) -> IR v/s ARR
every thread threats to change to only one colour ie. IR v/s ARR.
:-(( :-(( :=(( very sad guys...
swamiji yengae poneenga...unga jalra sathhamae kaanomae... ivargalukku geethopadaesamo gnanasnaanamo panna koodadho...
- From: Trend (@ 216.68.113.227)
on: Fri Nov 10 09:57:46 EST 2000
STS,
You are not making any points.I can just see a plain irritation on ARR you have.KRM was merely stating what he was thinking as ARR's characteristics and talents.
He didn't use IR anywhere in his statement.I don't know why unnecessarily you are getting yourself provoked and trying to bring up another mindless fight.I just think most of your statements are ridiculous.
"ARR uses each and everyone because he can't do it alone. When you don't have your own ideas you depend on others".
Any MD would agree that he needs the support of his troupe for his creation.I don't see anything wrong in giving credit to others so that they wahtever recognition they can get.
Personally,anyday I wouldn't trade in for anyone with Asha to sing "Shenbagame Shenbagame".Sadhana has sung some good songs too and has good voice(I agree she is merciless sometimes with pronounciation).
ARR introduces novel ideas.Some of them click others don't.I think it's atrocious when you call ARR's novel idea is copying.IMO,he is yet to peak.
"ARR is replaced by YSR/KR."
Not yet.But if they give better songs which becomes bigger hits they surely can replace ARR.In fact they can become the best MDs TFM has ever produced if they do a wonderful job.
Please try to be reasonable in your comments.
Trend
List all pages of this thread
Post comments
Sections:
Home -
TFM Magazine -
Forum -
Wiki -
POW -
oPod -
Lyrics -
Pictures -
Music Notes -
Forums: Current Topics - Ilayaraja Albums - A.R. Rahman Albums - TFM Oldies - Fun & Games
Ilaiyaraja: Releases - News - Share Music - AR Rahman: Releases - News - AOTW - Tweets -
Discussions: MSV - YSR - GVP - Song Requests - Song stats - Raga of songs - Copying - Tweets
Database: Main - Singers - Music Director's - Lyricists Fun: PP - EKB - Relay - Satires - Quiz
Forums: Current Topics - Ilayaraja Albums - A.R. Rahman Albums - TFM Oldies - Fun & Games
Ilaiyaraja: Releases - News - Share Music - AR Rahman: Releases - News - AOTW - Tweets -
Discussions: MSV - YSR - GVP - Song Requests - Song stats - Raga of songs - Copying - Tweets
Database: Main - Singers - Music Director's - Lyricists Fun: PP - EKB - Relay - Satires - Quiz