apdi enna special reason vechirukeenga? There is only one reason behind the posts from each side - the urge to defend one's idol. Apdi thaane neenga aarambicheenga?
Printable View
RK, i have already clearly posted my stand. And ennaathu?! naan aarambichenaa?!? Go man, read back the thread!
Sakala,
The way you post implies that you are the only one posting intelligently with a lot of insights and simply dismissing others' posts. Intha maathiri attitude-oda post panna naanga vera epdi sensible-a reply panrathu?
Mudiyala to the Core, Repeattu :(
I am a simple man, RK :)
director vikraman about arr n his melody song
watch rom 08:36
http://www.tubetamil.com/watch-cinem...-vikraman.html
No No, engaaluthaan prachanaiya start pannuthu, othukuren. But, neenga IR-a defend panra nokkathodathaane intha threadla post panna aarambicheenga? Atha thavira vera enna special reason vechirukeenga?
Look at the following post of yours.
This very post clearly shows your intentions - that is you are posting here to only belittle ARR. Ithu therinjathuku appuramum how else do you expect us to consider your posts here?
It is fine if you can't digest someone comparing ARR with IR. It is also fine to express the way you feel. But, why do you want to force your opinion on Ajay.
Ok, prachanainu aaiduchu. adithadi la erangiyaachu. unga pangukku neengalum sandaiku contribute panniyaachu. Aana athuku appuramum neenga mattum rombo sensible-a bayangara reasoning-oda post panra maathiri ungalaye neenga defend pannittu mathavangaloda posts-a ellaam dismiss panreengley?
RK, eppadi neenga oru stand edukkureengaLo appadi enakkum oru stand irukku. Athula entha problem um illainnu neengaLe sollitteenga.
So, leave out that comparison part. Even without that, the guy who question, he says why not you too for Oscars. Oru MD Oscar vaangittaaru, ivar vaangalai, athukkaaga ippadi ivar kitta kekkalaamaa?? Isn't that a blunderous mistake? Also see the tone. NeengaLum. So matha MDs enna panraangaLO athaiye Raja vum follow pannanum nnu ennamo Raja nethu vantha MD maathiri illa kekkuraaru?!? You can even replace MSV in Raja's Place. Alread an Indian MD that too from Chennai got 2 Oscars, Neenga MGR kaalathula irunthu irukkeenga, neengaLum yen try panna koodaathu nnu kettaa avarukku kovam/varutham varumaa varaathaa?!?
And coming back to that comparison part, i took that becos the question was asked keeping Rahman in mind, as he is the only one so foar who won Oscar. Now, even though i insisted my stand, that Raja is uncomparable with any,any MD, i never explained how or why. Discussion vera engayo pochu. I never explained or breiefed that. But just expressed my stand.
Eventhough I repeatedly said there was nothing insulting about Rahman, in Raja's answers, and if you look deep, its only on Raja that you can laugh, appuramum avar ennamo insult pannitta maathiriye pesittu irunthaanga, thatswhy i reacted. I also highlighted the irritation passed on Raja, in each question. Athai ellaam yaarum consider e pannalai. For each, his own stand.Quote:
Aana athuku appuramum neenga mattum rombo sensible-a bayangara reasoning-oda post panra maathiri ungalaye neenga defend pannittu mathavangaloda posts-a ellaam dismiss panreengley?
At max, Raja's reply to that Oscar question sounds only generic. He says there could be films that was not entered to Oscars which may be better than those in competition. Ithula enna thappu? Hollywood laye ippadi oru opinion sollappaduthu thaane?! Also, naan ethukku ivanga kitta poi nikkanum,nnu solrathula enna insult?? As if Rahman is the only Osar winner in the world maathiri illa kekkureenga?!? Oru veLai appadiye insult irunthaalum kooda that actually will apply tho all of the MDs who got Oscars, no?!
Recall, even on that Oscar Function, Raja highlighted how some hollywood composers had huge gap btw two oscars while Rahman got 2 at 1st attempt itself. He has no issues in accepting whatever talent Rahman has. Media & dumb fans, unnecessary provocation pannaama irunthaale pothum.
Ending the argument with my fav ARR Song!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qp95c6nqO24
Sakala,
That was a totally unnecessary question from the interviewer. Avangalukku therinjathu avalothaan. The main objective of people like that is to create controversies Maybe, he didn't feel that IR is incomparable.
But, at the same time, Raja's answers looked suspicious to me. Ajay and others confirmed that it was targeted at ARR. Ungalukku appadi onnum thonala so you are defending. Ellaame fine. Enna, neenga solrathu engalukku convincing-a padala. Ipdi thaane Srinivas sonnathayum vechu unga side-la avara thittuneenga? Infact, IR's statement is more close to being explicit than that of Srinivas. Anyway, one can't be 100% sure about the intentions of what one says to the media. Everything is open to interpretations.
I think we have to agree that we all have different perspectives on this issue and move on. Itha naan samaathaana pura reason kaaga sollala. I am saying this because of the pointlessness of the whole argument.
sorry just one question to mr.sakala
if kamal is in rahaman's position and rajini responds like raja what will be your take?
My answers to Rahman Ji's questions:
I have not made a video but have tried to answer the questions anyway!
What is the first step in removing borders?
Everyone is born human, only later do they come across, race, culture and religion, hence the first step is to avoid to picking up differences. Music is the way forward in breaking barriers!
What makes you believe in Karma?
Life experiences have put a concrete belief over Karma for me! Although in reality, I believe for e.g. if you give happiness, don’t expect it in return and if someone causes you distress, then shower more love towards them. God will dish out Karma, so don’t think it’s in your hands otherwise you might just end up being a victim!
What is good music to you?
Music is music, there is no such thing as good music or bad music, however if you see everything in a positive light then all types of music can be appreciated for their real worth.
My definition of “good” music – The bottom line is you should be loyal to the listener inside you and not be biased towards any artist as some times underground compositions by one-off artists can be more evergreen then the whole discography of a mainstream artist. It all depends on how much the listener broadens their taste.
The top spot belongs to “Celtic Music” in my most favourite musical genre list. Times have changed and recently I have been hooked on to a lot of “Dubstep”, who knows what I’ll be favouring next?
What does it take to be human?
Compassion, live and let live and forgive and forget. Don’t let ego get in the way if you value a relationship.
What fuels your moral code? Culture, Faith or Law?
Faith! Firstly, have faith in the divine, then humanity and importantly yourself.
ஆஸ்கருக்கான விருது தேர்வுகளுக்கு முன்பான பணிகள் எவ்வாறு நிகழ்கிறது? நாமினேஷனில் இருக்கும் சினிமாவின் ஒவ்வொரு துறையினையும் யார் ஆஸ்கருக்கு அனுப்புகிறார்கள்? சம்பந்தப்பட்ட கலைஞரே விண்ணப்பிப்பாரா இல்லை ஆஸ்கர்/படத்தின் தயாரிப்பாளார் பார்த்துக்கொள்ளுவார்களா? தெளிவுபடுத்துங்கள்.
Venkki,
The academy consists of around 6000 members. These members may be artistes,technical guys, directors, composers. They will be asked to nominate their picks. And they can do this only for their respective departments. For example, ARR is a member of the academy and he can make his nominations only in the music category. Once the nominations from these 6k members are received, they are audited by an auditing firm. And top 5 ranked nominations are announced for each category. For best film category, the top 10 are considered.
The final voting is more or less the same like nomination process. Ballot papers are sent to these 6k and they have to vote based on preferential rating system. Again the results are audited by the same firm. This time, there will be only one or two from the firm who do the counting. And these two remain the only people who know the results before it is announced officially in the Kodak theatre.
There are few rules too. The film should have released in the previous calendar year, it should have had a theatrical release, etc.
நன்றி அஜய். நீங்கள் சொல்வதைப் பார்க்கும் போது இசை என்ற துறையிலேயே தனது விருப்பமான ஒன்றைத் தேர்ந்தெடுக்க கணிசமான அளவு மெம்பர்கள் இருப்பார்கள் எனத் தோன்றுகிறது. அதுவும் உலகத்தின் ஒவ்வொரு நாடுகளிலும் வந்து (அமெரிக்காவில் இசை பயின்று) ஹாலிவுட் இசைப் பணிகளில் ஈடுபட்டுக்கொண்டிருக்கும் பல மனிதர்கள்.. ஆறாயிரம் மெம்பர்களில் இசைக்கென நூறு நூற்றைம்பது மனிதர்கள் இருக்கிறார்கள் என வைத்துக் கொண்டாலும் இவர்கள் இசை தெரிந்தவர்கள். உலக இசை வடிவங்களை ரசிக்கத் தேர்ந்தவர்கள். ஒவ்வொரு வருடத்திலும் அதிக எண்ணிக்கையினால் தேர்வு செய்யப்படும் நாமிநேஷன்கள், விருதுகள் ஓரளவிற்கு தரமானதாக இருப்பதால் தான், ஆஸ்கர் என்ற தரம் இன்றும் விழாமல் பதக்கப் பட்டியலில் முன்னிலையில் இருக்கிறது என நினைக்கிறேன்.
hello - cudnt help but notice you equating Srinivas with ARR and IR, in terms of giving credibility to his words
Srinivas yenna oru 30,000 songs paadiruppaaraa ?
yenna from 'sa' to 'sa' yezhu swarangalla Dr. M. Balamuralikrishna avargala vuda, sangeethathhula gyanam ulla maha vidhwan aa ?
summa pozhudhu pogaama facebook profile la vandhu dubakoor comment adikkara vettippaya - avvalavu thaan - he does not even qualify to be a decent chorus singer - andha rangela oru meritorious background vechhukittu ivaru, yedakku mudakku comment adichhaa, romba nalla edhirkaalam irukkara madhiri therla.
sari adhu avaroda thalai ezhuthu - yevan maathha mudiyum ?
idhey srinivas, naalaikku veru oru MD popular aanaal, appa popularlity pona MDs ai idhey polathhaan pesuvaaru - yenga oorla vaikkaporla oru praani paduthhu kidakkum - andha prani thaan gyabagam varudhu!
IRIR, Why you show this much hatred on Srinivas? He is a hard code Rahman fan. He is into cine music because of Rahman. He knew Rahman very well than any other celebrity in Kodambakkam. Throughout his career so far, he encourages and involves melody part of music and he stands for it anytime. Just because he brought some controversial words, we do not need to bring down him to ground level.
Srinivas, in his FB page, posted a short review about NEPV, during its release. He said that Ennodu Vaa Vaa is a drishti parigaaram inthat album, and praised other songs. I commented him asking if he has guts to mention which songs are drishti parigaarams in ARR albums.
He replied me saying that he has the liberty of saying his comments directly to ARR.
I replied, intha dagaalti ellaam veNaam, can you publicly declare which song of ARR is drishti parigaaram, he deleted both his and my comment!
Meanwhile he said one song of NEPV has resemblance with ABBA ABBA. He deleted that too :lol:
Recently during IR's birthday, a mega size Cake was made with his pictures and placed in a Mall, some one invited Srinivas for that launch event and he came. Again some moron asked to sing a song on stage, and he sang an ARR song in an event meant for IR!
Even without all this, agree with irir123 that he is just a sumaar singer!
Sakala,
While replying to Srinivas, why did you ask him to mention the 'dhrishti parigarams' of ARR when the comment was about NEPV songs? From where did ARR come into the discussion? Either you should have proved that his opinion was wrong or substantiated your claim,right? Sometime back you said that IR cannot be with ARR or any current MD. In this case, you have intentionally or unintentionally done exactly that.
If you say that you brought ARR because Srinivas is an ARR fan, then it's even worse. A typical 'Engaalu cycle'la light illamathaan varraaru, ungaalu cycle'eh illama varraaru' type of fan boyish reply.
Srini is not even being considered an above average singer by you. Then why even bother to follow him?
MOHANLAL ON ARR SONG IRUVAR Kannai Katti Kollathe
https://www.facebook.com/photo.php?v=581915865171409
I was nervous to sing for ARR’NENJUKULLE' FAME SHAKTISREE GOPALAN
A few days ago, Nenjukulle..., a single from Mani Ratnam's Kadal, was premiered on television. And ever since, the voice behind the number, Shakthisree Gopalan's inbox has been flooded with congratulatory messages. "It still hasn't sunk in. The response to the song has been overwhelming, and I feel blessed to receive positive feedback from so many people," she smiles.
So, how did the song happen? "I've been singing backing vocals for A R Rahman for the past couple of years and have worked with him in films like Ghajini and Endhiran. A few months ago, I happened to be in his studio for some official work, and Rahman spotted me. Out of the blue, he asked me if I would like to sing for him. I always carry my demo CD with me, and I immediately thrust one in his hands. It contained some of my original compositions as well. He listened to them right away, and within a couple of hours, I found myself recording Nenjukulle...," she recalls.
Shakthi adds, "Even when I was singing the number, I thought it was just a scratch vocal. Usually, I practise before I go to record even the backing, but on that day, I had not even done the basic warm up. I was quite nervous when Rahman asked me to sing, and was surprised when he retained it!"
Tell her that her rendition have also been criticised for sounding westernised, and she says, "I've trained in Carnatic music for over 13 years, and I've also learnt western vocal for some months. I'm part of a rock band, and I also sing jazz. I've mixed influences, and that's probably reflecting in the way the song sounds."
Nenjukulle... is not the first filmi number that this architect-singer has sung. "My last hit was Makalaya... from Naan. I've also sung for G V Prakash and a few other musicians."
http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/e...w/17169673.cms
I never follow him! But somehow his account was tied up to Raja Fans group. And its he who brought in ARR in his post! He said so "No one else here(in exception with ARR, who does it totally different) cud have done this!"
While no one one earth is waiting for Srinivas's review, i was irked that he brings ARR in to discussion. Thats why i too asked to list publicly, after that he brought in that abba abba comparision too. Thiruppi pesa enga kitta vishayamaa illai?! :) But he started deleting comments and so i left
My comments to some of your responses-ARR
http://www.facebook.com/notes/ar-rah...34537259942652
requesting thalaivar fans to put this issue to rest...
anand,
fantastic share, that vikraman interview..
and his song choice, minnalae... really oonai urukkum stuff!!
never knew this guy is also a ARR fan..
venkkiram - avaru solra thoni sarilla - avlo thaan - oru 100 -200 paattu paadinaa, udaney yenna venumnaa pesirradhaa ?!
he maybe a hardcore fan of anyone - idhaiyey, naalaikku, oru IR fan, IR musicla naalu pattu paadittu, mattha MDs patthi indha madhiri pesinaa adhivum thappu thaan!
singers dont create - the creator is the composer - who himself his maintaining a dignified silence ! right ?
LM, I kindly request you to take necessary action and help sanity prevail in this thread. And I request all AR fans to stop arguing as it does not take anyone anywhere. Every statement/posts here and elsewhere speak for itself and for the person who writes, and one does not have to be a rocket scientist to understand things. I do not see any point in arguing, therefore.
pls anyone upload arr interview in jayatv on deepavali day.thalaivara interview panna vera aale kedakalaya??meendum chinmayee-ya??
forgot to mention...
very good post irir... the one u posted on 9th!
Super interview with thalaivar in Jaya tv today, his ideologies, his wit and above all his modesty all classy. Of the 5 directors that came on the show, he seemed to genuinely like Kadhir's passion and style of making. There were some nice snippets regarding some of his songs with them too. Chinmayi said there were so many people who looked up to him as a role model and some of them listen to no music at all, that for me shows why he is so special :notworthy: Personally I've learnt so much from him by just being a fan and following him for the past 20 years, I am sure I'll get influenced even more in the days to come. God bless you sir :-)
i cant view the interview from europe. is gvm talking about his future films or about working with arr?
http://www.techsatish.net/2012/11/po...enon-udan.html
http://www.techsatish.net/2012/11/a-...n-jaya-tv.html
So his next hollywood project is "The Seventh Son"