Search:

That page is in total HCIRF control!! waste of time.

அப்புறம் ஏன்யா அவரோட இவரை compare பண்றீங்க?

P_R and groucho - From what I read in Wiki it does not look like Brando was professionally arrogant, but as a person. I do not know much about MB, so I have to refrain.

"Tough to work" does not necessarily mean arrogance. You are again cleverly diverting!! I am tired of this game.

Oh Oh, I am sorry V_S. I keep on forgetting this forum is a virtual temple for IR devotees only and there is no place for "non-believers" like me. My comments on IR are making this holy place dirty....

P_R,

I already bailed myself out. Just what I expected...my arguments are being manipulated to make them irrelevant or even worse wrong.

I brought in monetary comparison just to indicate...

app - I am not complaining about comparison - but how it is done. Yeah, you are right about bias. HCIRF fans get irritated whenever an unbiased opinion is expressed. That person get immediately...

What is very irritating to me is using specific attributes to place Raja higher in any comparison. These attributes are varied based on the person he is compared to. Just few of pages ago, MSV was...

It is an unfortunate comment I know, but I could not help it. Moreover, it is not a advice but it is a comment on your style of writing.

The second sentence in your reply is not always true. A...

Suresh - First of all please start treating others on par with you!! (I hope you understand what I mean)

-Deleted-

Mumbai Ramki - No entertainment for you!!

app,

While I agree that IR is the king of orchestration (meaning MSV can not be compared to him in that dept), I do not agree 70s Hindi song orchestration was far superior than MSV's - I think...

I hate to include you in the HCIRF category, you are too moderate.

So, IR can not be compared to MSV because of this and that. But much of the opposition (from HCIR fans of course) to BR's blog was centered around this one point. If I got the pulse correctly, many...

Suresh,

Just by laughing at me, you can not make my argument irrelevant. KVM did Sankarabharanam in 1980; I say IR's SRR is something like that. Even today, IR can not be challenged in his fort....

HCIRF: No, No, MSV can not be compared to IR... that's so wrong. By 1988, MSV was totally out of business. IR is still active.
Me: So are you saying by MSV was not good by 1988?
HCIRF: No, No, he...

Well, I think we came back to the original issue (whether IR is the new MSV) and I told why I consider that way. And you disagree, that's natural.

-Duplicate-

That's right V_S. MSV could have continued to work on "unimportant" Tamil movies and some Kannada / Malayalam movies, as IR chose to do. For some reason MSV did not. May be, after 25 years, the next...

V_S,

I did state IR dominance in a positive way only (dominated with his quality and speed). I was just citing IR's dominance as the reason for MSV's exit.

"Even coming to your point, by...

jaiganes,

I think BR's comparison is appropriate - If you say GVM is new Mani then IR is the new MSV. Yes, I understand IR is still active but MSV wasn't. But I do not think there was any one else...

Suresh - As a music lower I understand you hold MSV and KVM in high esteem. But most of the HCIR fans got offended because "IR HAS BEEN COMPARED TO MSV" - That's blasphemy to them. And they issued an...

Great work app_engine. I started visiting hub regularly only to read this thread. You kept it interesting from first song to the last one....

Many many thanks for taking us through these...

deleted.

The "opposite camp" does the same thing or even worse app_engine. Just because someone does not like all of IR's recent songs (even though they love his 70s/80s/most 90s), brand them as IR haters....