Topic started by Karthik S (@ 164.164.82.29) on Thu Aug 9 03:46:19 EDT 2001.
All times in EST +10:30 for IST.
When's 12B releasing? Any official info?
The only info I gotto hear was that Harris was off to Manhattan, US for mixing the songs for 12B for 15 days, recently. The promos are also out on TV and do look interesting, but as always its way too early to say anything at this point.
After Majnu, I do look forward to 12B. Is it true that the audio is slated to be out on August 15th? One of the rumours I heard!
Responses:
- Old responses
- From: xxxxxxxx (@ )
on: Sat Sep 29 00:28:52 EDT 2001
any1 knowing abt harish ragavendhra pls inform here
- From: soorya (@ 161.142.100.85)
on: Sat Sep 29 01:55:16 EDT 2001
hi karthik
actually i want to gave 100%....
but i am afraid if no one will support me...
now i am so happy when u are giving me the support...
actually i really love the songs(all the songs) in 12B......
expecially...poove vai pesum pothu...my dream is in it........
- From: Kumar (@ 130.213.201.248)
on: Mon Oct 1 19:27:46 EDT 2001
Guys,
I saw this movie last week here in the bay area..
movie was good... I was hoping the director
would handle this different plot well... and looks
like he has... ofcourse with zillions of songs..
HJ has done a good job for the BGM... he has
really taken the cocenpt of having BGM songs to
the next level... I think I heard atleast 3 songs
being used... one was in english mostly.. and
some nice pieces here and there.. it felt good.
But watching this and watching minnale before
that, the question which came to my mind... does
this guy have range.. he is good for city and
youth subjects... but what about others ? guess
time might answer that... until then IR still
rules the BGM world...
:-)
- From: Kumar (@ 130.213.201.248)
on: Mon Oct 1 19:30:13 EDT 2001
BTW has anyone seen both the movies... ie
12B and sliding doors ??? how do they compare ?
has jeeva (12b director) innovated a lot or has
he blindly copied ideas ? I only saw 12b.. waiting
to get my hands on sliding doors to do the
comparision...
:-)
- From: NagaS (@ 202.169.129.72)
on: Tue Oct 2 06:02:16 EDT 2001
Kumar,
I watched the movie in Bangalore.,
Yes, He has composed couple of songs as BGM, But other than that - HJ has used ONLY songs as him BGM., For example, whenever simran comes, he plays ' Poovee vaay pesumpothu' in BGM, When Jyothika comes with shaam, its either 'love paNNu' or 'Muththam Muththam' song's music, If she comes with Suhil Shetty - 'Jyothi Nirainjava' music comes .... In Minnalee also, he used 'Ennai Eeethoo seythuvittaaL' bit in BGM a bit too much.,
Do you think he can be compared with IR's BGM for this ???? I very much disagree !
NagaS
- From: saket ram (@ 161.139.37.65)
on: Tue Oct 2 06:09:24 EDT 2001
very good one ...
nice to hear ...
excellent job ..
harris jeyaraj certainly in 2nd place
aft a r rahman now !!
- From: Naaga Sudha (@ 203.199.242.22)
on: Tue Oct 2 06:23:57 EDT 2001
Hero Shaam is from a small town Tirupattur near Karaikudi and he is far better than Vijay,Ajit,Prasanth TRIO.
But the movie slips in screenplay.Shaam if he catches 12B bus in time he becomes Bank officer and become Simran's lover.If he misses the bus he becomes mechanic and loves Jyothika...But in three scenes in the film both the Shaam,Bank officer as well as Mechanic are present which is major flaw...But Harris and Hero Shaam are too good...
- From: Kumar (@ 130.213.201.248)
on: Tue Oct 2 18:50:26 EDT 2001
Hi Nagas,
I certainly am not equating him to IR. Ofcourse
I cant do that... IR will haunt me in my dreams
then.. :) just kidding... but am saying when
compared to SAR (who repeats the same song in
the BGM) or with deva or others who keep repeating
a single theme music thro ought, he atleast tried
something different to have different songs in
the BGM.. we have to agree even IR did not try
that.. having so many bgm songs...
I am saying he a welcome change when compared
to others... I also liked the small theme he
plays everytime when the hero tries to go after
jyothica or the whislting.. nice ones... dont
u agree to that..
:-)
- From: Kumar (@ 130.213.201.248)
on: Tue Oct 2 18:54:36 EDT 2001
I sure wonder how do KR and YSR compare in BGM.
I dont remember their BGMs much... I think KR
did a good job in the ullam kollai poguthe.. I
dont remember though.. guess this is a digression
from 12b.. sorry guys... just thinking out loud.:)
:-)
- From: NagaS (@ 202.169.129.72)
on: Wed Oct 3 01:44:34 EDT 2001
Kumar,
Now I got your point, I agree with you :-)
I remember KR did a good job for Ullasam (Don't talk about the movie tho'), YSR's BGM was good in PKP - I could very well remember his bit songs 'Poovellaam MaalaigaL aagum' and 'Pooththathu Pooththathu manathu', along with the violin piece he plays when vijayakumar and nasser split - They sure have the potential, Probably yet to get a movie which NEEDS real BGM ? Nandha is the answer I am hoping !
NagaS
- From: ******************************************** (@ 166.121.37.114)
on: Wed Oct 3 01:45:46 EDT 2001
12b ..was good
- From: RM (@ 202.156.2.134)
on: Thu Oct 4 00:54:17 EDT 2001
who the singers for each song in the movie? thanks a million
- From: prem (@ 61.11.76.228)
on: Thu Oct 4 02:38:54 EDT 2001
sariya thavara = samantha edward,febi,mathangi
punnagai poove = kay kay,prashanthi
poovey vai pesum = mahalakshmi iyer,harish ragavender
mutham mutham = kay kay,mahalakshmi
jodhi neranjava = sukhwinder singh
background score songs.
oru parvai paar = karthick
anandam = prem ji,tippu,karthick,timmy
nenje = sunitha rao.
- From: dashwinder kumar (@ 203.106.116.77)
on: Thu Oct 4 02:48:19 EDT 2001
realy good music acting of sham and simran realy superrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr
- From: Karthik S (@ 164.164.82.29)
on: Thu Oct 4 05:34:23 EDT 2001
http://cinemaa.indya.com/ips35/html/cinemaa/south/amma12b.html
"...Harris Jeyaraj's music is ordinary. Being a Rehman protégé he makes his singers sing with an accent that's not used anywhere in Tamil Nadu. His background score is interesting."
- From: sathish (@ 61.11.80.85)
on: Thu Oct 4 17:38:24 EDT 2001
superb musical film.another hit by hj
- From: Xavier (@ 210.214.17.168)
on: Fri Oct 5 10:30:36 EDT 2001
I saw 12 b recently. songs are good.
but can someone tell me why jyothika travels by bus when she has a car?
- From: bhoo (@ 203.199.227.102)
on: Fri Oct 5 23:11:18 EDT 2001
I saw 12B recently. songs are very nice, i love each n every songs. past 30 min iam searching for the 12b songs but i couldn't get it. In this movie shyam is very nice n role is interesting. any way all the best.
- From: HJ (@ 213.122.215.187)
on: Sat Oct 6 10:59:28 EDT 2001
Guys here is a posting I found in Forum hub
From: research
o mama mama(minnale) = columbus(jeans)
venmadhi ('""") = evano oruvan(alaipayuthey)
mudhal kanave(majnu) = sowkiyama(sangamam)
gulmohar malar(majnu)= pachai niram(alai)
mercury ragam(majnu) = hum rahi jab(pukar)
poopol poopol(minnale)= taal se taal(taal)
western
punnagai poove(12B) =Aayirathil naan(iruvar)
jodhi neranjava(12B) =ottagatha katti(gentman)
mutham mutham (12B)= muthamma(super police)
i had more copied versions of harris jeyaraj from rehmans previous tunes,which i'll be giving later.hope we have heard all this before and we don't need a harris jeyaraj to remake them again. there are others to do it. i hope we are not deaf anyway. it is sad to hear there is someone to say this fellow is starting to rule tamil film music.
this is not in support for any other music directors or because of any envy on harris jeyaraj. this is true he has re-written the lyrics for the previous rehman tunes. if he would have been under anyone else,he might have surely reflected them as well.i want anyone to take this as a positive comment,and encourage him in giving really new good numbers.
we are always ready to welcome new sincere guys,like yuvan and karthickraja who are working hard to give better music.let jeyaraj learn from them first than to blindly compare himself unnecessarily with Rehman as papers say nowadays.
i thank Day By Day for starting this topic.
- From: RealDeal (@ 24.15.81.189)
on: Sat Oct 6 12:52:40 EDT 2001
Kumar, NagaS...was the movie good. Is it worth it to spend $8 or should I wait for the DVD?
Any thoughts on our TF directors creativity process? What do you guys think of taking the idea from hollywood and then doing it in Tamil. Kamal seems to be doing that for quite some time now. Alavandhan is based on "silenece of the lambs"??
Beat this...Anil Kappoor makes the hindi movie from whatever succeeds in tamil.
Is it safe to say Malayalam and Bengali industries are the best regional indian original movie makers.
- From: Common Friend (@ 203.197.141.187)
on: Sat Oct 6 13:09:02 EDT 2001
HJ:
Your list is pakka. The pukar and Super police are excellent examples. I thought that I had no takers for my findings. You made it in posting. I initially thought that HJ(harris) owned a xeros machine, but now I am sure that he is the xerox machine it self.
- From: a.a (@ 203.199.228.91)
on: Sun Oct 7 01:54:14 EDT 2001
Dai Podhu Nanba...
So what it is xerox copy...12B songs are rage today...Every count down it is number 1...On big screen in DTS sound they are great...Whole Chennai is singing Mutham mutham muthama....
Dai common friend nee vera thread kku poi...Karisalkattu Poove padathoda BGM ...pattri discuss pannu...Ali Ahamed
- From: swati_ramani (@ 210.214.242.28)
on: Sun Oct 7 03:14:51 EDT 2001
Song Love Pannu is copied from Kikku Yeruthae(Padayappa).
- From: swati_ramani (@ 210.214.242.28)
on: Sun Oct 7 03:15:37 EDT 2001
Song Love Pannu is copied from Kikku Yeruthae(Padayappa).
- From: swati_ramani (@ 210.214.242.28)
on: Sun Oct 7 03:15:53 EDT 2001
Song Love Pannu is copied from Kikku Yeruthae(Padayappa).
List all pages of this thread
Post comments
Sections:
Home -
TFM Magazine -
Forum -
Wiki -
POW -
oPod -
Lyrics -
Pictures -
Music Notes -
Forums: Current Topics - Ilayaraja Albums - A.R. Rahman Albums - TFM Oldies - Fun & Games
Ilaiyaraja: Releases - News - Share Music - AR Rahman: Releases - News - AOTW - Tweets -
Discussions: MSV - YSR - GVP - Song Requests - Song stats - Raga of songs - Copying - Tweets
Database: Main - Singers - Music Director's - Lyricists Fun: PP - EKB - Relay - Satires - Quiz
Forums: Current Topics - Ilayaraja Albums - A.R. Rahman Albums - TFM Oldies - Fun & Games
Ilaiyaraja: Releases - News - Share Music - AR Rahman: Releases - News - AOTW - Tweets -
Discussions: MSV - YSR - GVP - Song Requests - Song stats - Raga of songs - Copying - Tweets
Database: Main - Singers - Music Director's - Lyricists Fun: PP - EKB - Relay - Satires - Quiz