Topic started by musicurry (@ 129.24.244.222) on Wed Sep 19 02:48:30 EDT 2001.
All times in EST +10:30 for IST.
hi guys,
let us discuss about harris jayaraj's new releases
Responses:
- Old responses
- From: Gentle Maghan (@ 210.214.243.180)
on: Sun Sep 30 21:36:09 EDT 2001
Rehna hai Tamil Nadu mein
http://music.indya.com/reviews/film/rhtdm.html
Our Rating
Your Rating *
Uh oh, wrong number! The otherwise-astute producer Vashu Bhagnani has made a big, big mistake this time. Like Shankar's Hindi debut Nayak, this one contains tunes that are straightaway lifted from the Tamil original Minnale. That is like courting disaster in capitals. The seven tracks are derailed without a second's pause.
I don't doubt for a moment that Harris Jeyaraj is a very gifted composer. His track record in the South is proof enough of his pudding. But the recipe for sambar and soup are different. Jeyaraj lands himself in soup for a no fault of his.
The title song, with its zig-zaggy motions of love devotions, is hardly going to make young hearts waltz in delight. The ecstacy whipped up by the profusion of orchestral embellishments adds nothing to our knowledge of puppy love as propagated in today's teen flicks.
But don't be hasty in dismissing the album. Worse disappointments await us, as Shaan goes Bolo bolo in the wonky lovespeak of that title. Sonu Nigam does a street smart Mumbaiya track Oh mama mama, where Sameer gets to talk about the Tehelka scandal and match fixing.
What about song-fixing? Isn't that what arbitrary linguistic transpositions of soundtracks amount to? Listen to someone called Bombay Jayshree (was she called Chennai Jayshree in the original track?) doing Zara zara. The seduction in the song is so scattered, it puts us to sleep. As for Roop Kumar Rathod in Dil ko, it must be the worst instance of aural miscasting since Hema Malini huffing through Peene waalon ko with Kishore Kumar in Haath Ki Safai.
There is something patently strange and strained in the music score of Rehnaa Hai Terre Dil Mein, as though the music strayed from the North pole to the South. Adding to the weirdness is the presence of an extra cassette with the album, which gives us a tape full of rejected songs from the film by KK, Sunidhi Chauhan and the like.
First, Bhagnani gives us rejected footage at the end of Mujhe Kucch Kehna Hai, now rejected songs. Rejection is becoming an epidemic and contagious now. Perhaps it is our turn to do so.
Subhash K Jha
- From: Venmathi (@ )
on: Thu Oct 11 20:05:35 EDT 2001
http://www.planetbollywood.com/Music/RehnaaHaiTerreDilMein/index.html
- From: MS (@ 129.252.25.204)
on: Thu Oct 11 20:50:47 EDT 2001
Seems like Hindi will never get over the inspid combo of Kumar Sanu - dholak - unimaginative tabla beat - trite tune. They need to listen to it in all possible recycled ways.
- From: IceKutti (@ 66.43.8.161)
on: Sat Oct 13 14:13:12 EDT 2001
I am listening to ... "Rehna Hai Tere Dil Mein"... The song by Roopkumar Rathod "Dilko", I dont know the whole meaning of the song... But the whole song.. and the beat is soooo nice...
- From: hari (@ 61.11.81.110)
on: Sat Oct 13 15:07:44 EDT 2001
superb album with 2 good additional tracks.
- From: rajakumar.s (@ )
on: Mon Nov 12 09:38:37 EST 2001
Why HJR is not able to score a good song like "vaseegara" in his following movies? Is he a flop or a " onetime magic"?
- From: rajakumar.s (@ )
on: Mon Nov 12 09:38:59 EST 2001
Why HJR is not able to score a good song like "vaseegara" in his following movies? Is he a flop or a " onetime magic"?
- From: RAMAN (@ 61.1.203.218)
on: Mon Nov 12 09:42:21 EST 2001
mr.rajakumar, you are correct it seems!Also notice that most of his songs are having the tunes of ARR
- From: paandee (@ 129.252.25.84)
on: Wed Nov 14 15:02:48 EST 2001
where can I get MP3z of RHTDM?
can anyone tell me please....
- From: prasanth (@ )
on: Sat Jan 5 14:21:21 EST 2002
ALL HIS SONG ARE MADE FROM OTHER SONGS
EXAMPLES MAJNU:GULMUGAR IS PURE COPY OF PACHINIRAM FROM ALAIPAYUTHE
2 :MAJNU:THADA THADA IS PURE COPY OF UPPUKARVADU
IN MUDHLAVAN
HE IS HELL I WILL NEVER LISETEN TO HIS MUSIC
- From: pandivasu (@ 210.214.241.241)
on: Sat Jan 5 14:26:05 EST 2002
HARRIS JAYARAJ HAD RAPED A GIRL 2 YERES AGO
THE JUDJEMENT IS NOT YET MADE
HE HAS ALSO BEEN ARRESTED FOR ABUSING CHILDREN
INFORMATION ON MUTHAMITTAL.COM
- From: fgfd (@ 203.196.144.134)
on: Sun Jan 6 07:07:09 EST 2002
http://www.harrisjeyraj.com
- From: some1 (@ 203.199.248.2)
on: Sun Jan 6 09:00:48 EST 2002
whats with the caps fellas?
- From: ulp!! (@ 203.199.248.2)
on: Sun Jan 6 09:03:30 EST 2002
hey ppl
opinions differ....
But i feel HJR just picks up tune that arr discarded when he was arr's asst.
- From: RAAJA MUSIC UNIVERSAL MEMBER (@ 168.187.168.42)
on: Sun Jan 6 10:35:29 EST 2002
HARRIS JEYARAJ IS A ONE TIME MAGIC COMPOSER LIKE ARR - ARR IS GETTIN UNPOPULAR NOW BCOS HES RUNNING OUT OF TUNES IN JUS 20 MOVIES OR SO AND HES HIGHLY RATED IN INDIA BCOS HINDI FILMS HAVE NEVER HEARD ANY MUSIC WHICH IS NEW - SOUNDS OF RAHMAN ARE NEW FOR THEM -BUT NOT FOR US
- From: fghfdh (@ 202.9.167.86)
on: Wed Jan 9 12:34:00 EST 2002
rapist hj you have to ne hanked to death
- From: Prateek Maheshwari (@ )
on: Mon Mar 18 00:57:56 EST 2002
Its nice to hear the music of RHTDM as the music is very nice but we should not forget that Harris Jairaj is former secretary of Great Mr.Ar Rahman who is the king of new Generation music so according to me the songs are inspired by the music of Arrahman but good trialby Harris.....
If any comments mail me at Prateek_m@www.com
- From: a (@ 206.217.209.194)
on: Mon Mar 18 01:48:44 EST 2002
it's utter nonsense to compare one composer with another one.
- From: Ramki (@ 161.150.2.250)
on: Fri Mar 22 13:52:00 EST 2002
His telugu debut 'Vasu'(venkatesh *er) has a beautiful melody(paadanaa theeyaga) superbly rendered by SPB.
- From: vijay (@ 61.11.76.186)
on: Fri Mar 22 17:45:20 EST 2002
hj latest album VAASU (telugu) is fantastic.hats off HJ.
- From: vijay (@ 61.11.76.186)
on: Fri Mar 22 17:45:43 EST 2002
hj latest album VAASU (telugu) is fantastic.hats off HJ.
- From: ajay (@ )
on: Wed Apr 3 05:50:11 EST 2002
hai, actually vaseegara was rahman's tune and arr has filed a case against harris jeyraj
- From: ajay (@ 61.11.82.39)
on: Wed Apr 3 05:52:07 EST 2002
hai, vaseegara was a.r.rahman's tune and ar has filed a case against him
- From: Karthikh.J (@ )
on: Fri Aug 15 06:30:33 EDT 2003
Hey Guyz
He z the best music director at present..
even though he copyies his copied songs has
better background music than the original
His use off electric ,Base guitars even arr
has not used them that beautifully
- From: Karthikh.J (@ 203.145.184.180)
on: Fri Aug 15 06:34:58 EDT 2003
Hi every one
I know all copies till the latest Ullam ketkumae..
I found out copied songs in minnale,majunu,lesa lesa,sami,vetri the remake in tamil of vasu,nd
samurai nd now in ullam ketkumae..but the songs
are good thats all needed
- From: Ram (@ 217.44.99.206)
on: Fri Aug 15 07:40:57 EDT 2003
I think you will find that YSR is the best MD at present. He doesn't copy like HJ and he is the best according to the Hindu.
- From: hjfan (@ 61.11.81.57)
on: Sun Aug 17 16:11:01 EDT 2003
very very good album (ullam ketkeme).
- From: FAN (@ 209.148.140.158)
on: Sun Aug 17 20:09:05 EDT 2003
Hey Ppl>
I just think Harris J. composed beautiful music for the songs in the tamil movie 'Saamy'
The songs go well with the movie
- From: FAN (@ 209.148.140.158)
on: Sun Aug 17 20:09:13 EDT 2003
Hey Ppl>
I just think Harris J. composed beautiful music for the songs in the tamil movie 'Saamy'
The songs go well with the movie
- From: FAN (@ 209.148.140.158)
on: Sun Aug 17 20:09:18 EDT 2003
Hey Ppl>
I just think Harris J. composed beautiful music for the songs in the tamil movie 'Saamy'
The songs go well with the movie
- From: Jayaram (@ )
on: Thu Oct 16 06:10:46 EDT 2003
I Dont Think That Vidyasagar And Yuvan Have a Taste To Music As Harris Does It For His Every Project
- From: Naren (@ 219.65.112.214)
on: Wed Oct 22 20:01:07 EDT 2003
Rapist? who cares. I see him as an alternative to Rahman. I thoroughly enjoy his songs, the bass especially. Etho onru from Lesa lesa makes me dance. He is certainly talented.
- From: Piratheepan (@ 68.90.48.197)
on: Wed Oct 22 21:32:05 EDT 2003
I dont like harris that much he reuses his tunes and other all the time cept for maybe one song each album.
YSR is good at times. Think vidhyasagar is realli good when he works for an artist worth spending time on.
Right now I dont see any alternative to rahman.i thought pravin mani mighta been good but then he came out with otran. vidhyasagar n ysr arent steady.
i would like to say HJ would be but then id be lying cuz he hasnt proved his merit to me yet.cuz all his music is alike.
- From: kiran (@ )
on: Thu Sep 9 10:52:35 EDT 2004
The songs from Majnu is not copied from any songs Prasanth , the Rythms are same but music is entirely different..........
- From: kreddy (@ 61.3.219.16)
on: Thu Sep 9 10:58:22 EDT 2004
I am Keshav Vijaywada(AP)
The song Venus Venus penne is the ever best song.......After that song I started listening to Tamil music there is no such song in Telgu ..............Why can't Yuvan continue the same kind of music........
- From: Cinefan (@ 203.101.56.145)
on: Fri Sep 10 06:30:41 EDT 2004
http://sify.com/movies/tamil/review.php?id=13563830&ctid=5&cid=2429
Chellamay-Movie review(MD-harris Jayraj)
List all pages of this thread
Post comments
Sections:
Home -
TFM Magazine -
Forum -
Wiki -
POW -
oPod -
Lyrics -
Pictures -
Music Notes -
Forums: Current Topics - Ilayaraja Albums - A.R. Rahman Albums - TFM Oldies - Fun & Games
Ilaiyaraja: Releases - News - Share Music - AR Rahman: Releases - News - AOTW - Tweets -
Discussions: MSV - YSR - GVP - Song Requests - Song stats - Raga of songs - Copying - Tweets
Database: Main - Singers - Music Director's - Lyricists Fun: PP - EKB - Relay - Satires - Quiz
Forums: Current Topics - Ilayaraja Albums - A.R. Rahman Albums - TFM Oldies - Fun & Games
Ilaiyaraja: Releases - News - Share Music - AR Rahman: Releases - News - AOTW - Tweets -
Discussions: MSV - YSR - GVP - Song Requests - Song stats - Raga of songs - Copying - Tweets
Database: Main - Singers - Music Director's - Lyricists Fun: PP - EKB - Relay - Satires - Quiz