Topic started by Pras (@ 65.92.101.68) on Mon Feb 11 16:56:07 EST 2002.
All times in EST +10:30 for IST.
I have heard the songs of Samurai! Theres 5 songs in total!
Responses:
- Old responses
- From: cosmician (@ 194.170.127.161)
on: Sat Mar 9 09:03:00 EST 2002
NagaS...
I liked Nithyashree's number too..her voice gave the song its character...good work by HJ too but he has to fine tune and bring out his style..otherwise he's too ARRish...
- From: Suresh (@ 195.93.48.178)
on: Thu Mar 14 05:38:08 EST 2002
Samurai sucks big time.
- From: Jeeva (@ 64.12.101.183)
on: Thu Mar 14 22:59:53 EST 2002
I heard for the first time, after you guys setting big expectations....
I doubt if these were written by film producer himself trying self propaganda.
Man, None of the song is Impressive.
I will try to listen another time, but I doubt,
this album will make it.
- From: Premkumar (@ 202.188.40.106)
on: Sun Mar 17 05:15:03 EST 2002
Juz wanna say something to those of u who r trying to compare between Samurai songs & Kannathil Mutthammittal songs. First of all, before doing any comparison, u should consider wat type are both movies about. For KM, it isnt much of a commercial movie if compared to Samurai which may appear to be another teen love movie. Therefore, u cant expect both songs composed for both movies to be the same or better. In KM, the songs r mostly used as BGM rather being picturized as if it was sung by the hero in the movie. In Samurai, the songs r most probably used for the hero & heroine. So, plz think before coming with "silly" comparisons !
- From: Common Friend (@ 203.197.141.186)
on: Mon Mar 18 06:31:47 EST 2002
>>> plz think before coming with "silly" comparisons
Statement worth a gold.
- From: RAM (@ )
on: Mon Apr 1 23:07:07 EST 2002
HJ copy the ARR music......but
Some of the blind fans are still support HJ is good then ARR.I have the strong evidence to say like this
Venmathi(minnale)-similar as -Yevano Oruvan
(alaipayuthe)
Gulmuhar malare(majnu)-similar as-Pachai nirame
(alaipayuthe)
Oru punnagai poove(12B)-similar as-kikku eruthe
(padayappa)
Aagaya sooriyan(samurai)-similar as-anbe anbe
(jeans)
dingu dong(samurai)some music from enna solla pogirai(kandukonden.k)
I'm also heard one song in minnale similar as thom karuvil irinthom(star),which song is realease earlier than minnale.the song is too short.
HJ always do this mistake in every album.HJ modify the ARR tunes and make it better than
ARR.AS a result,some stupid fans loves HJ music.
NO MUSIC IF NO ARR.He alway give us variety of new music.
<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
GOOD BYE!!!!!!!
- From: RAM (@ ) on: Mon Apr 1 23:08:38 EST 2002
HJ copy the ARR music......but
Some of the blind fans are still support HJ is good then ARR.I have the strong evidence to say like this
Venmathi(minnale)-similar as -Yevano Oruvan
(alaipayuthe)
Gulmuhar malare(majnu)-similar as-Pachai nirame
(alaipayuthe)
Oru punnagai poove(12B)-similar as-kikku eruthe
(padayappa)
Aagaya sooriyan(samurai)-similar as-anbe anbe
(jeans)
dingu dong(samurai)some music from enna solla pogirai(kandukonden.k)
I'm also heard one song in minnale similar as thom karuvil irinthom(star),which song is realease earlier than minnale.the song is too short.
HJ always do this mistake in every album.HJ modify the ARR tunes and make it better than
ARR.AS a result,some stupid fans loves HJ music.
NO MUSIC IF NO ARR.He alway give us variety of new music.
<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
GOOD BYE!!!!!!!
- From: Ganesh (@ 172.183.179.201) on: Tue Apr 2 01:30:54 EST 2002
HJ has even copied Deva. In 12B teh song Poove VAi Pesum Podhu is based on Pulveli Pulveli from Aasai.
- From: Common Friend (@ 203.197.141.186) on: Tue Apr 2 11:44:06 EST 2002
Infact Poove VAi Pesum Podhu is highly inspired from "Thoda thoda malarndhadenna" and charanam of Swasame.
- From: Sam P (@ 62.7.130.179) on: Tue Apr 2 13:53:12 EST 2002
This is useless.........the songs from Samurai ARE good. HJ is a good md...ok, many songs sound similar...but who's complaining...they sound good. as soon as you get ARR, or anything that sounds like AAR (HJ) then everyone hates them and condems their music.
- From: Aswathama (@ 207.18.199.151) on: Tue Apr 2 16:20:37 EST 2002
Samurai is one of the better effort from Harris Jeyaraj after Minnalae. I really enjoyed all the songs in the movie. I can clearly see a future where HJ, Eman, Yuvan, Barani ruling the TFM.
ARR should retire from TFM. I feel he can do a better sound engineer job for Andrew Lloyd Weber.
- From: ~n~ (@ 203.115.208.90) on: Wed Apr 3 02:59:13 EST 2002
Samurai isn't that bad....it's very mediocure...but i do like "Oru nadhi..oru pournami"...themusic is qiute different...and the way the singres have sung it is really great....it's vey upbeat...suitable for dancing...
- From: jose (@ 202.88.224.44) on: Thu Apr 4 14:04:46 EST 2002
samurai and vaasu are rubbish albums by harris trying to imitate arr and faltering pathetically in that effort.
now confirmed that he is yet another one film wonder.
- From: NCR (@ 206.30.30.2) on: Thu Apr 4 15:57:10 EST 2002
HJ Copy cat of ARR, then ARR is a copy cat of mutiple souces, Deva too. Why blame HJ. Everybody is doing the same job. Dont just blame HJ.
Go to http://www.mail-bag.com/copycat.shtml
- From: Bharath (@ 156.153.255.134) on: Thu Apr 4 16:32:14 EST 2002
who wrote lyrics of samurai.. its a pity that people r discussing the personality and character instead of the music and its contents..
whats the world coming to..
who is the lyricist of samurai..
- From: True fan (@ 210.187.144.249) on: Thu Apr 4 22:29:55 EST 2002
Hey stupid NCR if HJ wants to copy english song i not a big problem but why he copied ARR tunes.
NCR mind your words before said anything...
why HJ not copying Deva,Ilayaraja,MSV.U can see where is the music power.I also don't know why HJ get award for minnale & 12B.I think they don't know that HJ is copied ARR tunes & english songs.
I proud of Yuvan's music because he is not copycat like HJ.He come in his own way but HJ is
come in ARR way by copycat the ARR tunes.
i'm storngly want say that....
Next ARR is must be YUVAN not HJ....
Remember that...man
HJ alway come with oh..oh..oh humble....in his song.
in samurai album i can heard some music souces from (sanggamam,kadhal Desam,kandukonden.k,jeans & more)
Some beats of (oru nadhi,samurai) song is copied by (Laila collage laila,Kalluri Vasal )
For the details please see up (RAM)
he said the truth of the music
- From: Jeeva (@ 172.167.59.215) on: Thu Apr 4 22:53:20 EST 2002
Moongil Kadugale is just beautiful.
Vocal performance is marvelous!
- From: Suresh (@ 172.182.159.96) on: Fri Apr 5 01:37:49 EST 2002
HJ will never amount to anything. The only true upcoming talent in TFM is Yuvan for his catchy beats and fast numbers. He doesn't have to steal from ARR in order to be compared with ARR. His music says it all.!
- From: Sam P (@ 213.120.56.41) on: Fri Apr 5 08:42:39 EST 2002
The ppl on this forum are becoming more and more digressive- for gods sake- listen to the music!! everyone is stereotypin md's. for gods sake, just listen to their bloody music. appriciate the qualities, and point the faults- but dont just dismiss it. i dont understand, how one fan sayin Yuvan is brilliant, can also say HJ is useless.its amazing- wen ARR's Parthale Paravaasam came out, most ppl hated it- but it was one of his best- musically, it was fantastic- no one has done stuff like that- i can understand why ppl didnt like it, but you cant say that ARR is going downhill. with HJ, Samurai is a nice albulm. its not one that hits u on first hearing, but after repeated hearing, you appreciate the music, and begin to realise how nice the songs are.
its just somethin to consider.
thanx
- From: Common Friend (@ 203.197.141.186) on: Sat Apr 6 07:28:57 EST 2002
Yesterday, I listened to Samurai thru Raagaa. I could see the similarity that I came to know from this forum about that Aagaya Surian and anbe anbe song. I was not very much impressed by whole of the album. Again, he tried to imitate ARR here and there, but that Oru nadhi song was really amazing. Nithya shri was in her best. Even today morning, I was humming that song. I am really impressed with this song alone, but my deep brain says that there is one song which is very similar to Oru nadhi. I am not getting it, but my RAM/ROM/Harddisk is fully engaged searching for any evidence of its trace.
But, Oru nadhi is one exceptional song. Good work.
- From: chanakyan (@ 61.11.82.143) on: Sun Apr 7 18:38:40 EDT 2002
superb album.definetly hj will take next year's film fare award also with this movie.
- From: Mathi (@ 172.156.100.197) on: Sun Apr 7 22:13:07 EDT 2002
Well, from reading the comments, people do not seem to appreciate the music of Harris Jeyaraj. In fact, I am a big fan of H. Jeyaraj and A.R. Rehman. Personally, I think they both have their own styles. Sometimes, the thoughts and styles of MDs just happen to be coincidental. Harris's all albums have captured my interst. Also, the fact, Harris was in ARR's group and that may have certain influences on Harris's music. Therefore, it does not mean that Harris duplicates or modifies ARR's music. Harris has introduced new styles in his music. Especially, the song "VASEEGARA" was a big success. If it was a copy of ARR, people would not have liked it. SO, please do not just make comments with closed mindedness. Thanks
Mathi from Toronto, Canada
- From: Jeeva (@ 152.163.207.189) on: Mon Apr 8 20:37:15 EDT 2002
A great combination of good lyrics, awsome guitar and sweet voice.
Moongil kaadugale - Vandoo
Munagum padalgale...
Thoora Chigarangalil
Thanneer Thuvaikkum Aruvigale...
Iyarkkai thayin madiyil piranthu
Ippadi vazha Ithayam tholainthu
Salithu ponean manithanai Irunthu
Parakka vendum paravaiyai thirinthu
Thirinthu...paranthu...paranthu....
(Moongil...)
Setru thaneeril malarum
Sivappu thamarayil
Serum manapadillai
Poovin jeevan manakirathe
Vearai Aruthalum manangal
veruppai vumizhvathillai
Arutha nathiyinmel - Marangal
Aanantha poochoriyum...
Thamarai poovai maareano..
Jenma sabamum yennil kaaneano..
Maramai nanum maareano...
Manitha piraviyil Uyyeano..
Mealum...Mealum yennai
parugum vannam
pani thuliyai maareno..
(Moongil...)
Uppu kadalodu megam
Urpathi aannalum
Uppu thaneerai megam
Oru podum sinthaathu
Malayil vizhunthaulum sooriyan
Marithu povathillai
Nilavukku olliyooti thannai
Neetithu kolgirathe...
Megamai nanum mareano...athan
menmai gunangal kanbeano...
Sooriyan poleave mareano...yean
jothiyil Ulagai Aalveano...
Jananam, maranam Ariyavannam..nanum
Mazhaithuliyai aaveano...
(Moongil...)
- From: Man (@ 210.187.144.35) on: Wed Apr 10 02:30:34 EDT 2002
Samurai is rubbish album!!!!!!!!!!!
most of the music are already compose by ARR
Remind that........
- From: RAM (@ ) on: Mon Apr 1 23:08:38 EST 2002
List all pages of this thread
Post comments
Sections:
Home -
TFM Magazine -
Forum -
Wiki -
POW -
oPod -
Lyrics -
Pictures -
Music Notes -
Forums: Current Topics - Ilayaraja Albums - A.R. Rahman Albums - TFM Oldies - Fun & Games
Ilaiyaraja: Releases - News - Share Music - AR Rahman: Releases - News - AOTW - Tweets -
Discussions: MSV - YSR - GVP - Song Requests - Song stats - Raga of songs - Copying - Tweets
Database: Main - Singers - Music Director's - Lyricists Fun: PP - EKB - Relay - Satires - Quiz
Forums: Current Topics - Ilayaraja Albums - A.R. Rahman Albums - TFM Oldies - Fun & Games
Ilaiyaraja: Releases - News - Share Music - AR Rahman: Releases - News - AOTW - Tweets -
Discussions: MSV - YSR - GVP - Song Requests - Song stats - Raga of songs - Copying - Tweets
Database: Main - Singers - Music Director's - Lyricists Fun: PP - EKB - Relay - Satires - Quiz