Topic started by Akash! (@ 212.67.111.88) on Wed Oct 31 18:33:22 EST 2001.
All times in EST +10:30 for IST.
I do not understand tamil but i love sp bala's voice! I specially like the romantic songs he sings to modern beats! My favourites are
En Veetu thotatil - Gentleman
Kadhalenum - Kadhalar Dinam
Anbe anbe - Kadhal Desam
Anjali Anjali - Duet
Roja...
Can anyone recommend me some more film songs and film names in which sp bala has rendered songs in this style...please not old films but new films with good semi classical and fast music!...I am sure by now u have got the idea of what type of songs I mean! Many thanks to all the readers.
Responses:
- Old responses
- From: yaaraarO (@ 65.95.129.146)
on: Fri Jun 18 10:30:48 EDT 2004
MVKPalanichamy:
Thank you for the informative discussion about keys and kattais. I request you to post the same (both parts) in the " KJY carnatic film songs" thread (http://www.newtfmpage.com/forum/7601.11.43.29.html).
Thank you.
- From: yaaraarO (@ 65.95.129.146)
on: Fri Jun 18 10:32:47 EDT 2004
The correct link is:
http://www.newtfmpage.com/forum/7601.11.43.29.html
- From: MVKPalanichamy (@ 61.1.196.179)
on: Sat Jun 19 08:14:41 EDT 2004
Ok, Mister yaaaraarO,
.
Thanks for the appreciation. Can I also post it (both parts) in the other thread "SPB the Greatest singer in the world"? Will they drown me in the Kauvery sand?
.
MVKPalaniamy
.
PS Music knows no bounds!!
- From: S.Balasubramanian (@ 203.197.216.67)
on: Sat Jun 26 01:43:47 EDT 2004
Hello I Found Someone Posted That SPB has "Artificial Stylish", Who is That. Dont Say Like That, Here There R Lot of SPB Fans and Craze, I Love His Voice, Nobody Can Touch His Class of Singing. Do U Think, All His Songs R Repeted The Same Style, Just Listen "Payangha Mudivathilai", He Sung 7 Songs in That Film, All R Different Style, Pls Dont Repet UR Style of Saying SPB has "Artificial Style".
- From: Raghu (@ 193.129.245.198)
on: Mon Jun 28 05:19:59 EDT 2004
S.Balasubramanian (@ 203.197.216.67),
ppl with little music sense talk crap like that, better ignore this kind of crap.
we all know KJY is great & better than SPB in carnatic, but when it comes to play back singing SPB is the don & the ultimate, KJY is several miles away from SPB!
and oh yeah SPB's voice far better than KJY's voice any day :)
- From: S.Balasubramanian (@ 203.197.216.67)
on: Tue Jun 29 04:51:48 EDT 2004
Raghu R U Supporting Me, or Other Person, Whatever It May Be, E'one Love SPB's Voice. He Can only Give Such a class in Duet Songs. Thats all.
- From: Raghu (@ 193.129.245.198)
on: Tue Jun 29 05:09:27 EDT 2004
S.Balasubramanian (@ 203.197.216.67),
dude I am hard core SPB fan, ask any one :))
- From: S.Balasubramanian (@ 203.197.216.67)
on: Thu Jul 1 02:17:01 EDT 2004
To Raghu
I Know U R Hard Core SPB Fan,
All of U Love Music So Like SPB
But I Love SPB, So I Like Music
- From: Raghu (@ 193.129.245.198)
on: Thu Jul 1 05:19:10 EDT 2004
S.Balasubramanian,
pls post your views here
http://www.newtfmpage.com/forum/26785.11.25.59.html
it is all about my new film :)
- From: Maverick (@ 195.212.29.67)
on: Thu Jul 1 06:42:35 EDT 2004
Feel-good aa? Aiyyo..naan varala intha aatathukku.
- From: Kannan (@ 61.2.236.74)
on: Tue Jul 6 09:15:30 EDT 2004
Raghu (@ 193.),
I cannot agree that part about "voice". When you talk about Voice, there is none to beat our great KJY.
The other points, i do not want to enter into a discussion, because we all know your the greatest fan of SPB:)
- From: Raghu (@ 193.129.245.198)
on: Tue Jul 6 11:28:00 EDT 2004
Kannan (@ 61.)
I cannot agree that part about "voice". When you talk about Voice, there is none to beat our great KJY.
The other points, i do not want to enter into a discussion, because we all know your the greatest fan of KJY :))
- From: S.Balasubramanian (@ 203.197.216.67)
on: Wed Jul 7 10:19:34 EDT 2004
Mr Kannan
Nengha Thamizh Aaludhanu Ninakiren, Paatu Naa Enna THeriuma, Pamaranini Paaratu Enbhadhan Suruakam. KJJ Paadina Rasikalam, But En THalai SPB Nammium Kooda Paada Vaipan, SPB ku Equal SPB dhan, Vocal Power na Athu SPB dhan, Ippadinu Naan Sollala, Namma Singer Hariharan Solli irrukar. OK...
- From: Kannan (@ 61.2.236.14)
on: Thu Jul 8 02:34:37 EDT 2004
...voice-kku KJY-na KJY dhan, KJY-kku equal KJY dhan, "..I am in awe of his voice (KJY's)"-nu, idhu Nann sollala, namma great SPB-ye solli irrukkar:)
.
Kannan
- From: Raghu (@ 193.129.245.198)
on: Thu Jul 8 05:01:03 EDT 2004
Kannan,
>>namma great SPB-ye solli irrukkar:)
<<
avar KJY voice patri matum sollale, ulagam poora ulla singer's patri nalla than solvaru, avar kunam appadi :)
KJY has a nasal voice at hight pitches, when he sings kalaivaniye at high pitch, it sounds very thin & nasal, else at mid -lower octaves he is very good, but KJY lost his voiec 10 years ago, at the age og 52, but at 58 SPB still sounds like 25 year old youth,!
- From: Raghu (@ 193.129.245.198)
on: Thu Jul 8 05:02:06 EDT 2004
Kannan (@ 61.)
I cannot agree that part about "voice". When you talk about Voice, there is none to beat our greatest DR.KJY.
- From: hari (@ 155.69.5.234)
on: Fri Jul 9 06:28:51 EDT 2004
Raghu,
"KJY lost his voiec 10 years ago, at the age of 52"
Have you heard of any KJY mallu song after 1992?
just curious...
- From: Raghu (@ 193.129.245.198)
on: Fri Jul 9 07:38:10 EDT 2004
Kannan (@ 61.)
I cannot agree that part about "voice". When you talk about Voice, there is none to beat our greatest DR.SPB.
Hari,
hello, mallu or tamil does not matter, but his songs after 1996 in tamil sounds bad, his voice became to sqeeky!
- From: Kannan (@ 61.2.236.193)
on: Sat Jul 10 00:48:44 EDT 2004
Raghu,
I agree with your statement about KJY's voice after 1996 (even 1994). But in 1996 KJY was 57 and not 52 (as you stated earlier. But, if we take KJY's voice before 1994 (I am restricting myself to TFM), when you talk about "Voice", there is none to beat our greatest DR.KJY.
.
About KJY's voice sounding "thin & nasal" at high pithes I have this to say: When KJY sings at the highest pitches that the other singers can sing, we do not realise KJY is singing at high pitch, because he does it so naturally, effortlessly (E.g., "Kanavu kanum vazhgai yaavum"). So, unjustly, no credit is given to his (KJY's)singing at these pitches by a casual listener.
The pitches at which we find KJY strained (nasal, thin etc..) are the pitches at which other singer (including SPB)would not even be able to sing.
Listen to the best high-pitch-songs sung by KJY/SPB, you would realise this (put it through a voice analyser,to convince oneself).
regards
- From: S.Balasubramanian (@ 203.197.216.67)
on: Mon Jul 12 03:00:22 EDT 2004
My Dear Kannan,
Just Listen SPB's "Mun Paniya" From Nandha(All The SPB's Songs Under the Baton of Yuvan), And Just Stop THis Topic, Bcoz I Accept UR Statement With Just an Include, "None Other THan My Great SPB to Beat KJJ". Just Listen THat "Mun Pania" Song, How SPB, the Great Decorates Even His Breath At The End of First Stanza. So Please Stop THis Topic, I Dont Want To Compare My SPB's Voice With The Any Other Singers in The World.
- From: Raghu (@ 193.129.245.198)
on: Mon Jul 12 04:39:52 EDT 2004
Kananan,
Hello, >>The pitches at which we find KJY strained (nasal, thin etc..) are the pitches at which other singer (including SPB)would not even be able to sing.
>When you talk about "Voice", there is none to beat our greatest DR.KJY.
<< No, I don't agree, dude, KJY has an excellent voice, but it is monotonous, he sounds the same all the time, his voice is best suited for sad songs, bhajan songs & Carnatic based songs (In which he excels), but SPB's voice is AWSOME, it is full of energy, full of RICHNESS, full of ROMANCE, full of DEPTH/BASS, plus the way he MODULATE his voice is unparallel, in comparable, he is in par with the great Rafi & well above KJY and all other singers in PLAY BACK SINGING, note, I am not talking about Carnatic singing!
- From: Raghu (@ 193.129.245.198)
on: Mon Jul 12 04:40:24 EDT 2004
Kananan,
Hello, >>The pitches at which we find KJY strained (nasal, thin etc..) are the pitches at which other singer (including SPB)would not even be able to sing.
<< This such an absurd statement, SPB is the ONLY male singer along with Great Rafi, who sings with ease at high pitches, NOT the great Dr.KJY, though an excellent Carnatic artists, KJY is not able to hit note 36, with EASE, of course he can, but not with ease as SPB / Rafi, this was analysed by the great Latha ji :),
- From: Raghu (@ 193.129.245.198)
on: Mon Jul 12 04:40:51 EDT 2004
Kannan,
>>When you talk about "Voice", there is none to beat our greatest DR.KJY.
<< No, I don't agree, dude, KJY has an excellent voice, but it is monotonous, he sounds the same all the time, his voice is best suited for sad songs, bhajan songs & Carnatic based songs (In which he excels), but SPB's voice is AWSOME, it is full of energy, full of RICHNESS, full of ROMANCE, full of DEPTH/BASS, plus the way he MODULATE his voice is unparallel, in comparable, he is in par with the great Rafi & well above KJY and all other singers in PLAY BACK SINGING, note, I am not talking about Carnatic singing!
- From: Kannan (@ 61.2.236.170)
on: Mon Jul 12 05:12:23 EDT 2004
All the same, finally,
But, if we take KJY's voice before 1994 (I am restricting myself to TFM), when you talk about "Voice", there is none to beat our greatest DR.KJY.
Regards,
List all pages of this thread
Post comments
Sections:
Home -
TFM Magazine -
Forum -
Wiki -
POW -
oPod -
Lyrics -
Pictures -
Music Notes -
Forums: Current Topics - Ilayaraja Albums - A.R. Rahman Albums - TFM Oldies - Fun & Games
Ilaiyaraja: Releases - News - Share Music - AR Rahman: Releases - News - AOTW - Tweets -
Discussions: MSV - YSR - GVP - Song Requests - Song stats - Raga of songs - Copying - Tweets
Database: Main - Singers - Music Director's - Lyricists Fun: PP - EKB - Relay - Satires - Quiz
Forums: Current Topics - Ilayaraja Albums - A.R. Rahman Albums - TFM Oldies - Fun & Games
Ilaiyaraja: Releases - News - Share Music - AR Rahman: Releases - News - AOTW - Tweets -
Discussions: MSV - YSR - GVP - Song Requests - Song stats - Raga of songs - Copying - Tweets
Database: Main - Singers - Music Director's - Lyricists Fun: PP - EKB - Relay - Satires - Quiz