Topic started by musicfan (@ 62.199.220.2) on Wed Feb 5 09:01:13 EST 2003.
All times in EST +10:30 for IST.
Who is the top 5 musicdirectors in tamilnadu? eg. heres my list:
1. AR rahman
2. Ilayaraja
3. Deva
4. Vidyasagar
5. Harris Jeyaraj
Responses:
- Old responses
- From: Thiru (@ 210.214.132.9)
on: Sun Jan 25 16:36:57 EST 2004
ARR is the best
he can do variety of music.
He is not restricted to just Tamilnadu.
4 national awards.
Padmashree.
International projects.
Worked with Andrew webber and Micheal Jackson.
- From: subash (@ 67.123.74.160)
on: Sun Feb 1 12:48:14 EST 2004
i will go with:
5. adityan
4. murugavel
3. deva's brother
2. that kid who sings down my theru ("Kathirikkaay! Vendakkaay!" he sings)
1. me
just fyi, this is a joke. don't respond seriously.
(AND NOT JOKING -- how come no one ever mentions shankar mahadevan's group? shankar-ehsaan-loy?)
- From: Isaigani (@ 202.177.185.199)
on: Sun Feb 1 17:27:25 EST 2004
Tamil Nadu Top 5
--------------------
1. ARR (*)
2. A.M. Raja (Then Nilavu.. etc)
3. IR (Talapathi.. etc)
4. HJ (Minnale..etc)
5. YSR (Nandhaa..etc)
India Top 5
--------------------
1. ARR (Lagaan..etc)
2. R.D.Burman (1942 Lovestory.. etc)
3. Shankar-Essan-Loy (Dil Chaahat Hai .. etc)
4. Ismail Darbar (Devadas.. etc)
5. Rajesh Roshan (Paapa Kehtha Hian.. etc)
International Top 5
--------------------
1. ARR
(Ever high budget Musical Stage performance : Lord of the rings)
2. --(No Asian's in the list)
3. --
4. --
5. --
- From: Me (@ 217.44.92.37)
on: Mon Feb 2 01:44:51 EST 2004
Isai Gnani, you obviously don't really listen to a lot of intermational music, otherwise ARR would not be the top of any chart,let alone International.
What about greats like John WIlliams, Danny Elfman and Thomas Newman?
- From: jacky (@ 61.2.224.110)
on: Mon Feb 2 03:14:26 EST 2004
Isaigani,
I think KR did much better in Dum dum dum than YSR in Nandha.
- From: solo (@ 210.210.34.38)
on: Mon Feb 2 03:24:21 EST 2004
1. IR
For Varieties of Music from Folk to Western
For Mesmerizing BGM Scores
For making the Songs Longlasting
For immediate delivery
2. ARR
For instant Hits (For Some Period only)
For Best Sound Recording
For Westerinzed Rhythms / Dance Numbers
For multilingual projects
For Children attraction
3. HJ
For good fusion
For good voice
For innovations
4. Vidyasagar
For experimental numbers
For decent audio sales
5. Deva
For Front Benchers
For Nice Copied Tunes
For low budget prices
- From: anba (@ 219.95.211.148)
on: Mon Feb 2 05:07:55 EST 2004
A.R.Rahman...music man extraordinary...making India proud with every song composed...humble...god fearing...silent...soulful...sensitive... god fearing...silent...soulful...sensitive...extremely choosy about the projects he undertakes...the man is pure magic!
I still remember the first time I heard the music of Roja...in 1992. I heard a entirely new sound never before! A new seamless blend of Indian classical and western music thereby creating a entirely new aural experience.
For those who thought Roja was a fluke...Pudhiya Mugham came as a big surprise! It displayed Rahman's mastery over melody with the song azhagu topping the charts with its simple and imaginative composition coupled with some delightful lyrics! And then followed the chart busting Gentleman. It proved that Rahman was equally at ease composing ear friendly commercial music...chikku bukku railey...for instance!
A lot of Interesting movies like Kizhaku Cheemayile (Aathangara marame...), Duet (Naan paadum sandham...), Rangeela (Hai raama...), Kaadhalan (every song...!), Karuthamma (Thenmerku paruvakatru...), May Madham (Minnaley...), Bombay (Kannalane...), Kaadhal Desam (Mustafa...) later came Maniratnam's Dil se! Rahman attempted sufi music ably aided by Gulzar's classic lyrics. I rate Dil se as Rahman's career best though he is hell bent upon creating a even better song!
since roja until kangalal kaithe sei...he's superb...he's the man god gave 2 tamilans and indians all of the world....
- From: Isaigani (@ 202.177.189.199)
on: Mon Feb 2 09:31:50 EST 2004
Hi Me..
I know about John Williams the composer of Titanic and many good films.. but Rahman's music was sold more than him.. Also JOhn williams was not choosed for Lord of the rings musical's..
I would agree still Rahman is not upto No.1 position in International level.. but sure it will happen..
- From: Isaigani (@ 202.177.189.199)
on: Mon Feb 2 09:36:27 EST 2004
Hi Jacky,
Your are right KR did well in Dum Dum Dum its ofcourse better than Yuvan's Nandhaa.. but there is no consistency.. but Yuvan has lots of hits...
Even i would rate KR's Un peyrai sonaal podhum from Dum Dum Dum..
But Yuva's Poopoovai punagaikum ival (Bala) is great also Kaadhal Kondean, Mounam Pesiyathey.. and amny more.. thats the reason Yuvan better than KR
- From: vijay (@ 202.56.198.130)
on: Wed Feb 4 13:11:45 EST 2004
hi guys n gals,
i saw this site n i was really interested to get in even though i was a telugite,so coming to the ratings in my view are 1:the king of music ,the melodieous raja,king of rock n king of jazzz n the guy who i s none other that ILAYARAJA. 2:ARR=excellent music ,delicious to ears ,n ridiculous clarity.
3:DEVISRIPRASAD=every youth love him.
4:MMKERAVANI=sammaga untadhi.
5:SRI:vinasampuga untadhi.
- From: vijay (@ 202.56.198.130)
on: Wed Feb 4 13:12:59 EST 2004
hi guys n gals,
i saw this site n i was really interested to get in even though i was a telugite,so coming to the ratings in my view are 1:the king of music ,the melodieous raja,king of rock n king of jazzz n the guy who i s none other that ILAYARAJA. 2:ARR=excellent music ,delicious to ears ,n ridiculous clarity.
3:DEVISRIPRASAD=every youth love him.
4:MMKERAVANI=sammaga untadhi.
5:SRI:vinasampuga untadhi.
- From: BeN (@ 219.95.63.162)
on: Sun Feb 8 12:15:57 EST 2004
For those so called ARR bashers, read this review of ARR's latest Hindi release, Meenaxi...
http://planetbollywood.com/Music/Meenaxi/
Then u guys will know who's the real genius is !!!
- From: Instant Acces (@ 130.225.53.16)
on: Mon Feb 9 04:27:19 EST 2004
Should we get impressed of other people's opinion? All those magazines speaks like they know hell a lot, in real they know nothing. Its common people like you and me you are the experts.
- From: ebey (@ 210.212.253.194)
on: Thu Feb 12 03:32:20 EST 2004
1. rahman
2. harris
3. yuvan
4. vidyasagar
5. bharadvaj
- From: shreeraman (@ )
on: Thu Feb 19 09:04:18 EST 2004
hi
i like hj very much he has done all his films well
though he has the mark of arr he is excellent
for eg:
minnale,majnu,kakha kakha,samy etc
- From: aishwarya (@ 218.186.102.218)
on: Thu Feb 19 09:47:04 EST 2004
connect mugalai mugalai from arasatchi and mudher kaneve from majnu...they r almost the same...he is becoming totally repetitive...hj just uses diff singers...
- From: aaa (@ 198.232.250.51)
on: Thu Feb 19 11:36:13 EST 2004
As per current demand,
1. HJ
2. YSR
3. VS
4. ARR
5. IR
- From: aishwarya (@ 202.156.2.122)
on: Fri Feb 20 05:02:20 EST 2004
and connect mugalai mugalai to yedo yedo from laysa laysa...same...
- From: Tariq (@ 213.199.33.20)
on: Fri Feb 20 09:39:40 EST 2004
Current demand is actually
1.YSR
2.HJ
3.IR
4.VS
5. ARR
- From: NIWDAH (@ 210.187.176.222)
on: Sun Feb 22 09:52:53 EST 2004
1.ILAIYARAAJA 2.YSR 3.DHINA 4.COPYCATS
1.ARR 2.VS 3.RAMESH VINAYAGAM LIST:-
1.MSV-TKR 2.KR 3.PRAVIN MANI DEVA,
1.KVM 2.HJ SAR
1.GR
THE 5TH CLASS HASN'T COME!AND I DON'T WANT IT TO COME!
- From: yasheer (@ 203.115.22.14)
on: Sun Feb 22 23:19:18 EST 2004
my wote goes to a.r.rahman
- From: Kalai (@ 203.127.53.3)
on: Mon Feb 23 01:07:55 EST 2004
My List for top five in Tamil Nadu is:
1)Illayaraja
2)AR Rahman
3)YSR
4)Vidyasagar
5)Harris Jayaraj
- From: MEENA (@ )
on: Wed Mar 10 01:39:01 EST 2004
AR RAHMAN IS THE BEST!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!harris IS A COPYCAT
- From: x (@ 156.153.254.41)
on: Wed Mar 10 02:42:15 EST 2004
IR was best is best will be the best in Tamil Nadu, India AND WORLD.
- From: Thulasi (@ 61.0.149.66)
on: Mon Mar 15 01:28:45 EST 2004
'If music is reliegion ar rahman is god".He revolutionised Indian music industry.Why top indian directors waiting outside his studio for his date?.IR could became fisrt ar rahman if he had the western music education like rahman got at trinity.IR mixed/folk melody.Rahman mixed western/melody
- From: rajasaranam (@ 210.210.33.73)
on: Mon Mar 15 06:32:12 EST 2004
Thulasi,
IR passed out with Goldmedal and Honors frm Trinity while ARR jus passed. now IS it clear who is 'GOD'.
List all pages of this thread
Post comments
Sections:
Home -
TFM Magazine -
Forum -
Wiki -
POW -
oPod -
Lyrics -
Pictures -
Music Notes -
Forums: Current Topics - Ilayaraja Albums - A.R. Rahman Albums - TFM Oldies - Fun & Games
Ilaiyaraja: Releases - News - Share Music - AR Rahman: Releases - News - AOTW - Tweets -
Discussions: MSV - YSR - GVP - Song Requests - Song stats - Raga of songs - Copying - Tweets
Database: Main - Singers - Music Director's - Lyricists Fun: PP - EKB - Relay - Satires - Quiz
Forums: Current Topics - Ilayaraja Albums - A.R. Rahman Albums - TFM Oldies - Fun & Games
Ilaiyaraja: Releases - News - Share Music - AR Rahman: Releases - News - AOTW - Tweets -
Discussions: MSV - YSR - GVP - Song Requests - Song stats - Raga of songs - Copying - Tweets
Database: Main - Singers - Music Director's - Lyricists Fun: PP - EKB - Relay - Satires - Quiz