Home   Forum   Wiki   Notes   Register   FAQ   Sitemap   About Us   Contact Us  

Alka Yagnik or K S Chitra. Who sings better?

Topic started by analyst (@ 203.200.32.197) on Sat Jun 29 14:35:34 EDT 2002.
All times in EST +10:30 for IST.

The first thing that came to my mind when I saw KSC & KK comparisn was that it was unfair. This I think anyone can judge. My vote goes to KSC. I will announce the result on 7th July 2002 based on the max no of votes

---

Responses:

• Old responses
  
• From: Maharashtrian (@ 203.124.129.146) on: Thu May 6 01:36:23 EDT 2004
  
  Dear Aruvi,
  you listen that song(ninnukkori once again) with good music player.Or you check your ears with an ENT specialist.
  OFCOURSE,that song is one of the best song sung by Chitra with Ilayaraja music.
  I strongly deny your opinion on this song.
  You know,in this song you can enjoy karnatic flavour also.This song is entirely different than other regular songs.
  
  As of today,I don't find any comparative female singer to Chitra.
  
  Be a good listner and enjoy!!!
  
  Good luck!!
  
  
• From: 888 (@ 203.124.129.146) on: Thu May 6 03:30:33 EDT 2004
  
  *****
  
  
• From: cho (@ 209.47.143.226) on: Thu May 6 11:05:41 EDT 2004
  
  Looks like whoever is adding 'Ji' to the end of the name dont seem to appreaciate south indian singers...saying ninnikkori is a bad rendition is so pathetic!...When ears are shut, whats the point in arguing.... Just ignore this Aruvi (whoever he is) and let him live in his own world..
  
  
  
• From: Aruvi (@ 170.92.1.104) on: Thu May 6 12:13:15 EDT 2004
  
  Idiots like cho and Maharashtrian do not know anything about music. CHitra sang out of tune even in Asoka. Dont come North, Southie baddies. Do not come to the kingdom of Alkaji.
  
  
• From: SRILANKAN (@ 134.74.56.29) on: Thu May 6 16:06:23 EDT 2004
  
  Just Because Alka gets almost everysong in Bollywood it doesn't mean that she is the best.
  Most of the hindi songs sung by Alka, sound very monotonous.Comparing singers is a total waste!
  Alka is as good as Chitra, but lacks versatality.
  FRom:
  SriLankan (who gives equal importance to tamil songs as well as HIndi songs)
  N.B:Hindi songs are played for more than an hour almost everyday in every Sinhalese radio station in SL. So I hope my knowledge of contemporary hindi songs is quite O.K to pass remarks about Alka.
  
  
• From: cho (@ 209.47.143.226) on: Fri May 7 10:02:20 EDT 2004
  
  Chitra singing out of tune... ha ha ha!! ARR did the music for Asoka. You mean to say that he couldn't notice her singing out of tune?? Brilliant-da nee!
  
  Aruvi, forget about music.. obviously you don't seem to know much about it. Why do you want to talk about something that you don't know?
  
  North-la nalla mazhai peiyudha? Orrula enna vishesham?
  
  
• From: Ashish (@ 172.133.209.49) on: Fri May 7 19:54:33 EDT 2004
  
  Hey Guys,
  Just leave that ignorant aruvi(the fake one).. Let him do his blaah blaaah.. do we care? Just coz some psycho is passing some comments is never gonna change our opinion on Chithra.. Alka is a good singer. but someone had pointed out earlier, she lacks the versality.. If u listen to Chithra's songs in hindi(I'm giving the eg of hindi songs just to open the eyes of the so-called hindi baboos, who had asked the 'south baddies' to keep off the kingdom of Alka).. like.. Raat ka nasha(Ashoka) or Mere dil ka tumse hai kehna(Armaan) to Hum Tumse na kuch keh paye(Ziddi) or Bole re mann mora dole re(AgniVarsha).. u can easily see the range this amazing singer has.. i think noone has that .. and for your kind information, Lataji had invited only Chitra to sing for her on her 75th B'day celebrations in Bombay.. and mind you .. she is the only playback singer in India to get the National Award for the best playback singing for 5 times(Not even lataji had got that award that many times).. Do i have to say more.. i guess not...
  
  
• From: Aruvi (@ 65.29.14.103) on: Fri May 7 22:39:27 EDT 2004
  
  Slaves like Ashish should not post here. The very fact that Lata calls upon Chitra for her b'day celeberations has been used by this ignoramus to bolster his stance. Talk music here my man. Chitra is a typical Mallu singer who herself knows her limitations and is a secret admirer of Alkaji. F00ls like Ashish should keep away from music forums. Have you heard 'dard mein jaltA huA', a duet by Alkaji and Chitra ? Alkaji's alaap in Chaaya naat (that is a raaga :) would have given Chitra a massive complex. Stay away ignoramus
  
  
• From: asi revanth katta (@ 61.95.211.129) on: Mon May 10 04:04:26 EDT 2004
  
  alka is a good singer but not to be compared with chitra chitra ji is chitra ji after lata ji only chitra ji is to be mentioned none other.nobody in the present trend are capable to be compared at chitra ji
  she may not be famous as alka in north .but still see for example she sung 8 songs in 'main prem ki deewani' 1 in 'armaan' 1 in 'koie mil gaya' one in funtoosh total of 11 songs and she was nominated in 5 different film awards as best female play back singer .she did not get any award in the 5 selections because northern singers are afraid of loosing their respective market but one day bollywood will recognise chitra ji .so nobody cant stop chitra ji
  me being a greatest fan of chitra ji want to start a fan web site for chitra ji if madem gives me permission
  chitra fans be ready for that
  
  
• From: revanth (@ 61.95.211.129) on: Mon May 10 04:09:22 EDT 2004
  
  alka is a good singer but not to be compared with chitra chitra ji is chitra ji after lata ji only chitra ji is to be mentioned none other.nobody in the present trend are capable to be compared at chitra ji she may not be famous as alka in north .but still see for example she sung 8 songs in 'main prem ki deewani' 1 in 'armaan' 1 in 'koie mil gaya' one in funtoosh total of 11 songs and she was nominated in 5 different film awards as best female play back singer .she did not get any award in the 5 selections because northern singers are afraid of loosing their respective market but one day bollywood will recognise chitra ji .so nobody cant stop chitra ji me being a greatest fan of chitra ji want to start a fan web site for chitra ji if madem gives me permission chitra fans be ready for that
  
  --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  
  
• From: Vishnu (@ ) on: Sun May 30 13:07:43 EDT 2004
  
  She got the MTV immies for best female playback for the song Koi mil gaya
  
  
• From: Vidya DSouza (@ 206.126.163.20) on: Mon May 31 23:57:24 EDT 2004
  
  Hey guys.. No fight Please.. just understand the difference between the voices. Alka and Chitra is the best in thier own respective.Some of the songs that Alka has sung are good only with her voice and i am sure that Chitra cannot sing those songs like how Alka did. And the same way .. the singing perfection Chitra has is marverlous. She is amzing ..
  So dont fight.. Just enjoy both the singers.
  
  
• From: fan (@ ) on: Thu Jun 17 19:36:09 EDT 2004
  
  Chithra has a sweet voice, somewhat like Shreya Ghosal. But Alka's voice is like... I dont know...its as if she was born to sing. My first pick is Alka, then Shreya and Chithra(together)...There is no female singer with a voice as smooth and sweet as Alka's...Id say she is better than Lata.
  
  
• From: fan (@ ) on: Thu Jun 17 19:37:42 EDT 2004
  
  Chithra has a sweet voice, somewhat like Shreya Ghosal. But Alka's voice is like... I dont know...its as if she was born to sing. My first pick is Alka, then Shreya and Chithra(together)...There is no female singer with a voice as smooth and sweet as Alka's...Id say she is better than Lata. You should listen to her(Alka's) song "Shayarana si hai zindagi.." from Phir Teri Kahani Yaad Aay, Chithra couldn't have sung it the way Alka did...
  
  
• From: fan (@ ) on: Thu Jun 17 19:39:02 EDT 2004
  
  Chithra has a sweet voice, somewhat like Shreya Ghosal. But Alka's voice is like... I dont know...its as if she was born to sing. My first pick is Alka, then Shreya and Chithra(together)...There is no female singer with a voice as smooth and sweet as Alka's...Id say she is better than Lata. You should listen to her(Alka's) song "Shayarana si hai zindagi.." from Phir Teri Kahani Yaad Aay, Chithra couldn't have sung it the way Alka did...I also like Shreya's sad version of "O saathiya" from Saaya. It sounds like her voice is maturing.
  
  
• From: fan (@ 12.72.198.42) on: Thu Jun 17 20:48:32 EDT 2004
  
  You know in "Dil chura liya" from Saaya...The sad one sung by Shreya Ghosal....she really sounds like Alka when she says Dil Chura Liya, O Saathiya.....So I think it would have been better if ALka had sung it.
  
  
• From: fan (@ 12.72.198.42) on: Thu Jun 17 20:48:50 EDT 2004
  
  You know in "Dil chura liya" from Saaya...The sad one sung by Shreya Ghosal....she really sounds like Alka when she says Dil Chura Liya, O Saathiya.....So I think it would have been better if Alka had sung it.
  
  
• From: hari (@ 155.69.5.234) on: Sat Jun 19 02:28:02 EDT 2004
  
  
  Chitra is the best. Alka comes 80% of Chitra.
  
  Shreya's voice is awesome, and if given proper chences throughout she'll be the next LATA.
  
  
• From: ENCOUNTERSHANKARFIJIBOY (@ ) on: Mon Jun 28 19:25:36 EDT 2004
  
  YES CHITRA IS BETTER. HER VOICE HAS A JIST OF UNIQUENESS. ALKA IS OK WITHA FEMININE VOICE WITH SLIGHT IMPERFECTIONS DURING PITCH CHANGES.
  
  
• From: DAWAT RANDHA (@ 165.23.247.49) on: Mon Jun 28 19:27:03 EDT 2004
  
  ALKA IS LUCKY AND CHITRA IS NATURALLY LUCKY
  
  
• From: Nagesh (@ 61.16.168.131) on: Mon Jun 28 23:25:05 EDT 2004
  
  Hello Ashish - even PS got National Award 5 times..
  
  
• From: khAmOsh (@ 207.61.221.28) on: Tue Jun 29 15:39:57 EDT 2004
  
  Hey guys...listen to this....proves the point over and over again that Alka aunty pips Chitraji in all aspects. Alka Aunty has sung all 10 songs in the movie 'Fursat milE tO chalE AnA'
  
  http://www.alkamusic.com/latsongs/fur1.html
  
  Trust your ignorance is dissipated now, psychos.
  
  
  
• From: panks (@ ) on: Mon Jul 19 12:19:06 EDT 2004
  
  i dont think there is anyone better than alka.chitra sounds like a typical southie.she is only fit for south indian songs,but alka today is the queen of melodies in bollywood.even lataji has once called alka her successor.chitra may be good but alka is the best.
  
  

---

List all pages of this thread

Post comments