Topic started by TFM Group on Tue Jan 27 15:47:28 EST 1998.
All times in EDT/EST +9:30/10:30 for IST.
Responses:
- Old responses
- From: aruvi (@ spc-isp-tor-uas-75-62.sprint.ca)
on: Sun Dec 20 18:46:40 EST 1998
Hey Karthi
Malargal Malarnthana is a great song by PS.
- From: Ragapriyan (@ 202.54.37.18)
on: Sun Dec 20 22:52:33 EST 1998
Karthi & Ramki:
We have already made a very detailed list of PS
songs before! Check one of the threads/tfm pages.
- From: Shanmugam Murugappan (@ 208.236.83.6)
on: Mon Dec 21 18:42:43 EST 1998
Karthi,
Thanks for the lyrics of "malargal nanaindhana..." song.
BTB, have you heard of this song, "enna paarvai undhan paarvai... idai melindhaal indha paavai...". Can you tell me the name of the film and the hero/heroine of the same?
Have you heard this song from the film "Velli Vizha"?
"kai niraya choli kondu vandhaen thozhi
kaayai vettalamaa kann vizhikkum naazhi... kann vizhikkum naazhi"
It was sung by both PS and LRE. While I liked PS' voice so much in the song, I, however, didn't like LRE's voice in this song. It was a bit irritating.
- From: RR (@ uc.cache.nlanr.net)
on: Mon Dec 21 21:07:58 EST 1998
shanmugam,
enna paarvai unthan paarvai - kaathalikka neramilllai (Muthuraman,Kanchana were featured in this song. This movie also has Ravichandran and Rajashree)
- From: Sriram Lakshman (@ ifmxlenx.na.informix.com)
on: Tue Dec 22 11:01:52 EST 1998
Guys, have you heard "Thithikkum Paaleduthu Deivathodu" from "Thaamarai Nenjam"?
A superb song.
- From: Shanmugam Murugappan (@ 208.236.83.16)
on: Tue Dec 22 15:13:37 EST 1998
Hi RR,
Thanks for that clarification. (Oh God, how can I forget the songs in "Kaadhalikka Neramillai"?!).
Sriram,
Real good song from a really good movie ("Thaamarai Nenjam").
Karthi,
How about these songs from PS?
"ninaikka therindha manamae unakku marakka theriyaadhaa...
pazhaga therindha uyirae unakku vilaga theriyaadhaa... uyirae... vilaga theriyaadhaa"
"andru oomai pennallo indru pesum pennallo
aiya unnai kandu Thamizh paadum pennallo"
"kattodu kuzhalaada aada... aada....
kann endra meenaada aada... aada"
"andru vandhadhum adhae nila...
indru vandhadhum idhae nila...
endrum vandhadhu ore nila...
iruvar kannukkum ore nila..."
"madi meedhu thalai vaithu vidiyum varai thoonguvom... maru naal ezhundhu paarpom"
"paalirukkum pazhamirukkum... pasi irukkaadhu...
panjanayil kaatru varum... thookkam varaadhu... thookkam varaadhu"
- From: Sriram Lakshman (@ ifmxlenx.na.informix.com)
on: Tue Dec 22 15:53:12 EST 1998
A real PS stunner is "Oru NaaL iravu" from "Kaviyathalaivi". The song has a tremendous impact. This is one of my personal favourites but I dare not record it because it gets me all choked up....no exaggeration.
For Raaga enthusiasts, this song is set to "Rasikapriya" the 72nd Melakartha. Well Done MSV and PS!
- From: karthi (@ lab7.theatrium.net)
on: Tue Dec 22 23:26:06 EST 1998
Shan!
I like all those songs you've mentioned. I love the song 'kattodu kuzhalaada aada'.
Sriram, I have not heard the song 'Thithikkum Paaleduthu'. I know another song from the same film: 'Aalayam Enbadhu Veedaagum'.
Hey Sriram, 'Oru Naal Iravu' is a classic. PS has exhibited her bhaavam in a very controlled manner which is possible only by her. I am moved to tears whenever I hear the lines:
Ennuyir Thaaye Neeyum Sugamo
Iruppadhu Enge Sol Endren
Annai Mughamo Kaanbadhu Nijamo
Kanavo Nanavo Sol Endren
- From: Ragapriyan (@ 202.54.37.18)
on: Sat Dec 26 08:32:48 EST 1998
Karthi and Sriram:
Include me in the fan list for the oru naaL
iravu pagal pOl nilavu song. A great song
that contains so much of emotion!!
In the week end I heard the following songs...
kallellaam maaNikka kallaagumaa
veedu varai uRavu, veedhi varai manaivi
pavaLak kodiyilE muththukkaL pooththaal
after a long long time and found LR Eswari's
humming in them to be awesome! Whatever anyone
may say about LRE's voice, I feel the humming
that she has given in these songs are of an
uncomparable quality! What do you guys think?
Are there other songs in which she has given
humming of a similar quality?
(Sriram: I appreciate your making comments about
ragas of old songs. Please keep sharing such
info whenever you can. BTW, what are your comments
about the handling of MMG in the kallellaam
song?)
- From: karthi (@ lab3.theatrium.net)
on: Sat Dec 26 18:45:07 EST 1998
Ragapriyan!
Here's are a few songs where LRE's humming is great:
1. 'Eattil Ezhudhi Vaithen' (Vaanambaadi)
2. 'Vanna Thamizh Penn Oruthi (Paavai Vilakku)
3. 'Maanikkath Thottil Ingirukka' (Panam Padaithavan)
4. 'Nenjathai Alli Konjam Tha Tha Tha' (Kadhalikka
Neramillai)
I don't know much about ragas. But I can sing any song after hearing it just for a few times. Just looking forward to an opportunity like a get-together here in the US where I could try my performance out.
BTW, LR Easwari voice-kku enna kuraichal? (your words, 'whatever anyone may say about LRE's voice') Infact, vayasaanaalum ilamai kuraiyaadha ore voice LRE dhaan! LRE almost kadaisiyaa paadi hit panna 'Ninaithaale Inikkum' songs-a eduthukkonga, 'Ananda Thaandavamo' and 'Inimai Niraindha Ulagamirukku'! Isn't her voice buoyant in both these songs? There are so many and many songs by LRE which are incomparable just for her voice. I am listing a few of them which you may not have heard that frequently but you have to listen:
1. Adhisaya Ulagam Ragasiya Idhayam (Gowravam)
2. Mellap Pesungal (Kasedhan Kadavulada)
3. Vennila Mugam Kungumam Perum (Selva Magal - Jai Shankar, Rajyasree)
4. Chitthira Poovizhi Vaasalile (Idhayathil Nee)
5. Kattodu Kuzhalaada Ada (Periya Idaththu Pen)
6. Yaradi Vandhaar Ennadi Sonnar (Vanambadi)
7. En Ullam Undhan Aaraadhanai (Raman Thediya Seethai - MGR movie)
8. Aarambam Indre Aagattum (Kaaviya Thalaivi - the same movie of 'Oru Naal Iravu')
9. Ammamma Kannathil Kannam Vaithu (Vallavan Oruvan - the same movie of 'Palingunaal Oru')
10. Vare Vaa Raja Idhu Indira Logam (Thee - Rajinikanth starrer)
11. Minminiyai Kanmaniyaai (Kannan En Kaadhalan - MGR movie)
- The humming by LRE in the beginning of the song - oh my, that 'lalalalalalla lalalalalalla' is just great Ragapriyan, just great! she also sings part of the song.
- From: karthi (@ lab3.theatrium.net)
on: Sat Dec 26 18:47:02 EST 1998
Ragapriyan!
Here's are a few songs where LRE's humming is great:
1. 'Eattil Ezhudhi Vaithen' (Vaanambaadi)
2. 'Vanna Thamizh Penn Oruthi (Paavai Vilakku)
3. 'Maanikkath Thottil Ingirukka' (Panam Padaithavan)
4. 'Nenjathai Alli Konjam Tha Tha Tha' (Kadhalikka
Neramillai)
I don't know much about ragas. But I can sing any song after hearing it just for a few times. Just looking forward to an opportunity like a get-together here in the US where I could try my performance out.
BTW, LR Easwari voice-kku enna kuraichal? (your words, 'whatever anyone may say about LRE's voice') Infact, vayasaanaalum ilamai kuraiyaadha ore voice LRE dhaan! LRE almost kadaisiyaa paadi hit panna 'Ninaithaale Inikkum' songs-a eduthukkonga, 'Ananda Thaandavamo' and 'Inimai Niraindha Ulagamirukku'! Isn't her voice buoyant in both these songs? There are so many and many songs by LRE which are incomparable just for her voice. I am listing a few of them which you may not have heard that frequently but you have to listen:
1. Adhisaya Ulagam Ragasiya Idhayam (Gowravam)
2. Mellap Pesungal (Kasedhan Kadavulada)
3. Vennila Mugam Kungumam Perum (Selva Magal - Jai Shankar, Rajyasree)
4. Chitthira Poovizhi Vaasalile (Idhayathil Nee)
5. Kattodu Kuzhalaada Ada (Periya Idaththu Pen)
6. Yaradi Vandhaar Ennadi Sonnar (Vanambadi)
7. En Ullam Undhan Aaraadhanai (Raman Thediya Seethai - MGR movie)
8. Aarambam Indre Aagattum (Kaaviya Thalaivi - the same movie of 'Oru Naal Iravu')
9. Ammamma Kannathil Kannam Vaithu (Vallavan Oruvan - the same movie of 'Palingunaal Oru')
10. Vare Vaa Raja Idhu Indira Logam (Thee - Rajinikanth starrer)
11. Minminiyai Kanmaniyaai (Kannan En Kaadhalan - MGR movie)
- The humming by LRE in the beginning of the song - oh my, that 'lalalalalalla lalalalalalla' is just great Ragapriyan, just great! she also sings part of the song.
This morning I was just thinking of
'Kallellaam Manikka Kal Aaguma' and
'Yar Andha Nilavu'
- While the former brings tears to your eyes, TMS voice has the kind of 'kaniya vaikkum quality' in that song, the latter is such a soother to your mind! Great works by Viswanathan-Ramamoorthy, Kannadhaasan, TMS, Sivaji combo!
- From: Ragapriyan (@ 202.54.37.18)
on: Mon Dec 28 22:47:11 EST 1998
Karthi:
Thanks for the LRE humming list. I too like those
LRE songs that you mentioned. You forgot to add
pattaththu raaNi song from Sivandha Mann.
But still, there are many many who dislike her
voice.. see that LRE thread in the archives.
- From: karthi (@ lab3.theatrium.net)
on: Tue Dec 29 03:15:46 EST 1998
Ragapriyan,
I was actually hurt when I came to know through you that there are many who dislike LRE. Isn't it crazy to start a thread and show dislike for an artist who was quite established and could sell those days! I am yet to see that thread. will do sometime. There are songs which you can never imagine to hear in any other voice than LRE. It's tough to find a versatile singer like her. The specialty of her was that she had a very peculiar voice. More suited to western style rock 'N' roll and so youthful and sexy. I bet no one could have sung "Kadhodudhan Naan Paduven" especially the 1st 4 lines are a killer!
- From: Sriram Lakshman (@ ifmxlenx.na.informix.com)
on: Tue Dec 29 10:24:21 EST 1998
Karthi and Ragapriyan,
I liked LRE's humming in "Kutramalayile", the main singing done by Seerkazhi. Good examples Karthi. Additionally , there are some songs where she overshadows even the great TMS like in "Naam oruvarai oruvar" from "Kumari Kottam".
Ragapriyan, this song is based on "Vahula Bharanam" but there are some foreign notes.
"Pattathu Raani" can be sung only by LRE. Another great song "Ammamma Keladi thozhi" from "Karuppu panam".
My knowledge about Raagas is purely based on "Kelvi Gyanam" or courtesy my keyboard. "Mannikkavum" in case there are mistakes.
List all pages of this thread
Post comments
Sections:
Home -
TFM Magazine -
Forum -
Wiki -
POW -
oPod -
Lyrics -
Pictures -
Music Notes -
Forums: Current Topics - Ilayaraja Albums - A.R. Rahman Albums - TFM Oldies - Fun & Games
Ilaiyaraja: Releases - News - Share Music - AR Rahman: Releases - News - AOTW - Tweets -
Discussions: MSV - YSR - GVP - Song Requests - Song stats - Raga of songs - Copying - Tweets
Database: Main - Singers - Music Director's - Lyricists Fun: PP - EKB - Relay - Satires - Quiz
Forums: Current Topics - Ilayaraja Albums - A.R. Rahman Albums - TFM Oldies - Fun & Games
Ilaiyaraja: Releases - News - Share Music - AR Rahman: Releases - News - AOTW - Tweets -
Discussions: MSV - YSR - GVP - Song Requests - Song stats - Raga of songs - Copying - Tweets
Database: Main - Singers - Music Director's - Lyricists Fun: PP - EKB - Relay - Satires - Quiz