Topic started by tamilan (@ 202.160.9.11) on Thu Dec 2 06:24:51 EST 2004.
All times in EST +10:30 for IST.
Dear Guys
ARR Much Awaited Swades tamil version Desam released all over tamil nadu..Today moring the audio release function take place at Satyam Theatre..Vaali release teh fist CD and our Mastero Arr Get the first copy.
Responses:
- Old responses
- From: notooimpressed (@ 192.23.120.163)
on: Mon Dec 20 11:10:44 EST 2004
Hi guys...watched the movie swades..here are my two cents....
1. The movie will defintely appeal to all NRI'S and NRI'S only.... becos to some extent they can identify the longing confessed by the SRK character....
2. People in india will find it touch becos ..they have seen it all..and there is nuthing to root for in the movie... basically there is no element for srk to fight with ....
3. The pace of the movie reeminded me of 'Autograph' very calm and unassuming.. but these things are very risky .... should be able to reach the masses...swades will flater badly on this front...
3. This movie is a techincal mess .... the camera and editing ..the lifeline of the movie...are total disasters.... could hlep yawning in the second half...i dont know what were they thinking when they saw the rushes....
4. Music ---- as usual Rahman comes up with trumps...
positives ---
1 the music was a relief....
2 the bhajan fitted really well in the movie....
3 yeh tara --- good
4 yun hi ----- ravishing....
5 the score when srk leaves india and when they try to produce electricity ..sounded fabulous...
negatives
1.Sometimes sound too synthesised for a movie based on a village.
2. The baba song was a disaster ...niether fitted the movie ..nor the audience wanted to hear it...
3. Overall background score --- ARR once again falters bad....
A movie like swades will never succeed if it fails to connect emotionally, to connect...we need a mucial piece which would haunt us even after we left the theatre... swades boasts of no such musical piece...that when i think of swades an year from now... i wouldnt be talking of any musical piece..rather than songs... if only he could improve.. !!
BEST -- Yeh to desh hai tera -- The song personified the whole theme..was the best fit...
Overall SRk was amazing....i think his best performance this year...
I wouldnt call it ARR best performance ever.... i still hold Dil se as his best ....
the moive could have been better..... no scope at the box office....but with SRK --who knows!!
these are strictly my views..please feel free to comment ont hem ..
- From: Vazhipokkan (@ 40.0.40.10)
on: Mon Dec 20 15:50:31 EST 2004
Swades is a Big Letdown. Songs really hinder this movie's pace. Here is a review pretty much sums up ARR score only good to listen not goes well with the movie.
"A.R. Rahman's music may sound soothing when you hear it, but when viewed with the story, most of the songs are of the 'fast forward' variety."
http://www.indiafm.com/reviews/04/swades/index.shtml
The next Anutosh Gowrikar's next movie will definitely employ new or well established MDor who would score music for the movie than movie for the music
- From: MAPILLAI (@ 70.17.108.150)
on: Mon Dec 20 20:36:25 EST 2004
Not to go off topic, but does anyone have any Mr. Romeo (in hindi) songs , I can only find .rm files of it and it cannot burn into CD. CAN Anyone help me here? :(
- From: JP (@ 203.123.16.124)
on: Mon Dec 20 20:38:05 EST 2004
Vazhipokkan....Vazhtukkal...
- From: indian (@ 202.160.9.11)
on: Mon Dec 20 21:31:30 EST 2004
Read this
http://www.bollyvista.com/article/a/32/3867?bodynum=1
- From: dinesh (@ 60.48.219.69)
on: Mon Dec 20 23:24:38 EST 2004
god,u people got no life,come & nose in ARR's albums/movies...hahaha..bravo..u cant live without ARR album!!
- From: ROCCO (@ 210.187.110.30)
on: Tue Dec 21 00:41:19 EST 2004
HAHAHAHA!KELIMBITTANGAYYA!!KELAMBITTANGAYYA!!
FOR ALL 'ANTI-ARR CLUB BASHER'WE ARR FAN WELCOME YOU WITH 'RED CARPET'.UNGALLA ELLATTIYUM PATTA ROMBA PAVAMA IRUKU!
- From: MADDY (@ 202.159.243.250)
on: Tue Dec 21 01:11:29 EST 2004
mr.notooimpressed
y r u trying to forget the African style of music as the BGM when SRK enters the village and the harmonium piece.......u seem to be again a prejudiced IR-fan......y cant u see that BGM also means silence at some places....i have seen n number of times IR spoiling that silence with his "athi-medhavi" music.......where were u when IR did those things....can u pls review IR on that......
- From: Madhu (@ 61.246.245.2)
on: Tue Dec 21 01:30:07 EST 2004
i think even hindu-muslim fight running for centuries will stop! but IR fans and ARR fans???
- From: ROCCO (@ 210.187.110.30)
on: Tue Dec 21 02:41:01 EST 2004
'MAKKALAL ATHIGAM NESIKKAPADUBAVANTHAN ATHIGAM VIMARSIKKAPADUGIRAN'
-VAIRAMUTHU
- From: Vazhipokkan (@ 40.0.40.10)
on: Tue Dec 21 09:38:58 EST 2004
'MAKKALAL ATHIGAM NESIKKAPADUBAVANTHAN ATHIGAM VIMARSIKKAPADUGIRAN'
-VAIRAMUTHU
Same goes to IR as well go and see all the IR threads infested with nasty comments from ARR fans. I am a neutral fan who couldn't take this awful fights.
- From: nottooimpressed (@ 192.23.120.163)
on: Tue Dec 21 10:38:20 EST 2004
Maddy,
You definitely need to see a psychiatrist .. you see venom in every word spit out here... First you need to get IR out of your system. Then you can think constructively.
I have prejudice towards none. Just talk about the movie in question, you dont have to drag other music directors, since we are not comparing two diff scores for the same movie. You might argue the harmonium and the drum beats , you seem to be off the point i mentioned. A movie like swades needed an emotional score, the kind which will agree with ur longing for india. I am sorry I never found them in the movie. If you only needed a good african beats from ARR, then your expectation of ARR is only that much . Good for you and i am happy for you.
Regarding my take on IR bgm , we will talk about that at some other thread not here.
- From: Vazhipokkan (@ 40.0.40.10)
on: Tue Dec 21 10:52:52 EST 2004
African music walking in to the village what a great suitable BGM? Is he trying to portray Indian villages to Africa? Probably he will score Indian music for Lord of the Rings musical. Is it apt?
- From: Guess Me (@ 202.83.35.226)
on: Tue Dec 21 10:54:10 EST 2004
Dont come into conclusions before listening to the bgm. See it first and then comment.
- From: Guess Me (@ 202.83.35.226)
on: Tue Dec 21 10:55:13 EST 2004
"Same goes to IR as well go and see all the IR threads infested with nasty comments from ARR fans. I am a neutral fan who couldn't take this awful fights."
Same goes to ARR too, who is undoubtedly the most bashed composer at newtfmpage.com
- From: Vazhipokkan (@ 40.0.40.10)
on: Tue Dec 21 11:12:15 EST 2004
Sure Guess Me I will watch Swades and let u know true opinion.
- From: Ravi (@ 69.148.76.22)
on: Tue Dec 21 17:13:51 EST 2004
Yesudas sounds old in his song on the album, which FYI, is not in the film.
- From: MADDY (@ 203.94.234.115)
on: Tue Dec 21 22:40:52 EST 2004
TOI claims swades to be the best movie of the year(Hindi).....feel really proud of ARR who continues to work in projects which carries a gud message in Hindi.....in tamil, he has to work in movies like Boys and new....that's unfortunate really.....he has to cut down on this, i hope sincerely......chalega yaar, even if the movie flops, u'll have the name that u flopped with right intention......
- From: Kum (@ 66.131.251.254)
on: Tue Dec 21 23:46:34 EST 2004
Rocco..
Unka Caps key-la any problem?! Romba imsaiya..
- From: Kiran (@ 202.73.40.67)
on: Wed Dec 22 01:39:04 EST 2004
just now was listening to 'UndhaN desathil' song....aaaaah ...what a boring song man.....all the instruments are CRYING ..especially that shehnai is CRYING CRYING as if small kid cry when his toy is lost....chii...
ooff...what a pull hair song this one
this song showing rahman as kid composer
- From: ROCCO@DD (@ 202.184.41.61)
on: Wed Dec 22 02:14:35 EST 2004
KIRAN, I THINK YOU IS 'KINDERGARDEN SCHOOL'
IF YOU DONT KNOW ABOUT MUSIC,YOU TRY TO SING ,BABA BLACKSHIP,OR DEVA'S GANA SONG LIKE
'DANDANAKKA,DUBUKKU DUBUKKU.I THINK YOU WILL LOVE THIS SONGS.
- From: ROCCO@DD (@ 202.184.41.61)
on: Wed Dec 22 02:15:23 EST 2004
KIRAN, I THINK YOU IS 'KINDERGARDEN SCHOOL'STUDENT
IF YOU DONT KNOW ABOUT MUSIC,YOU TRY TO SING ,BABA BLACKSHIP,OR DEVA'S GANA SONG LIKE
'DANDANAKKA,DUBUKKU DUBUKKU.I THINK YOU WILL LOVE THIS SONGS.
- From: ROCCO@DD (@ 202.184.38.16)
on: Wed Dec 22 02:21:17 EST 2004
kum,
tamil spellingla write panna eppditha keppingga,
englishla type panna 'haha hoho'inuvingga
my inglish very problemlah!!!!
- From: Kiran (@ 202.73.40.67)
on: Wed Dec 22 02:34:23 EST 2004
cool cool...ha ha ha haaaaa
- From: Kiran (@ 202.73.40.67)
on: Wed Dec 22 02:36:16 EST 2004
ROCCO@DD
its not
KIRAN, I THINK YOU IS 'KINDERGARDEN SCHOOL'STUDENT
KIRAN, I THINK YOU ARE 'KINDERGARDEN SCHOOL'STUDENT
Now who is what student ??
- From: ROCCO (@ 202.184.38.16)
on: Wed Dec 22 02:53:38 EST 2004
okay okay! i agree 'I AM KINDERGARDENT STUDENT'
but you is 'PLATFORM STUNNT'kiran!!!
hahahahaha!!!!!!
- From: Kiran (@ 202.73.40.67)
on: Wed Dec 22 03:16:06 EST 2004
yeah
so ...u are a kind'grt student...
and so u r idol rahman is kid composer
thats what i was saying.....from first...now u understood ha ha ha :)
- From: ROCCO (@ 202.184.41.61)
on: Wed Dec 22 03:40:59 EST 2004
YES,MY IDOL IS A.R.RAHMAN
HE IS 'GOD OF MUSIC'
- From: Kiran (@ 202.73.40.66)
on: Wed Dec 22 04:08:02 EST 2004
ok ok
but ROCCO
u r gal or guy??
by the words i guess u r gal ......
- From: Kiran (@ 202.73.40.66)
on: Wed Dec 22 04:10:32 EST 2004
Yeah indeed
RAHMAN IS GOD OF MUSIC..DOWNLOADED MUSIC hee heeheee
- From: DD (@ 202.184.38.16)
on: Wed Dec 22 04:25:35 EST 2004
hei kiran ,THEV..MAVALE..POI UN THALAIVAN SUTTA POI NAKKUDI..THEI NAYEE!!!
- From: Kiran (@ 202.73.40.66)
on: Wed Dec 22 04:56:13 EST 2004
Sorry TAMIL cannot understand ...
but i can guess u r saying something which u r doing to u r leader ....
List all pages of this thread
Post comments
Sections:
Home -
TFM Magazine -
Forum -
Wiki -
POW -
oPod -
Lyrics -
Pictures -
Music Notes -
Forums: Current Topics - Ilayaraja Albums - A.R. Rahman Albums - TFM Oldies - Fun & Games
Ilaiyaraja: Releases - News - Share Music - AR Rahman: Releases - News - AOTW - Tweets -
Discussions: MSV - YSR - GVP - Song Requests - Song stats - Raga of songs - Copying - Tweets
Database: Main - Singers - Music Director's - Lyricists Fun: PP - EKB - Relay - Satires - Quiz
Forums: Current Topics - Ilayaraja Albums - A.R. Rahman Albums - TFM Oldies - Fun & Games
Ilaiyaraja: Releases - News - Share Music - AR Rahman: Releases - News - AOTW - Tweets -
Discussions: MSV - YSR - GVP - Song Requests - Song stats - Raga of songs - Copying - Tweets
Database: Main - Singers - Music Director's - Lyricists Fun: PP - EKB - Relay - Satires - Quiz