Topic started by Sundar Ramanathan (@ 202.54.10.81) on Mon Aug 11 04:45:24 EDT 1997.
All times in EDT +9:30 for IST.
Responses:
- Old responses
- From: SriVidya (@ 130.39.182.218)
on: Mon Oct 22 13:41:29 EDT 2001
Hi,
For people who start comparing P. Suseela with S Janaki, (just because of Singara velane Deva) and Illayaraja,
We admire the songs of S. Janaki or other singers(say chitra) only because of the beats and music of Illayaraja(the credit should go to him or any other music director rather than the singers) but give PS a song which doesnt even is worth , but see the difference , it is the voice which is dominating.
I was so crazy that I would watch a movie if only P suseela sang ( in Telugu), not the hero or heroine
I wish she starts singing again.
My wish is to get a autograph from her.
One comparison "Raasave una kaandha nenjil " in Tamil the same was rendered by Janaki in Telugu See the difference!!!
Similarly in Chinna goundar Muthu mani malai was sung by Ps and was sung by chitra in Telugu See the difference!!
We should be proud of this legendary and great singer.
All the best to Psuseela Fans
Please write to me if U find anything interesting about her.
Thanks& Regards
SriVidya
- From: kalai (@ 202.144.106.10)
on: Tue Oct 23 01:12:23 EDT 2001
to srividya
" neela vanna kannane" is a marvari type of song which from the film "malliga" . film released in 1958. One more beautiful song by A.M.raja & Ps in that film is "varuven naan unathu maaligain vaasalukke" (pathos).
- From: kalai (@ 202.144.106.10)
on: Tue Oct 23 01:20:58 EDT 2001
to vidya
In www.tfmpage/forum there is a page "P.susheela /Ilayaraja combination " . In Ilayaraja's homepage they have metioned only 149 songs. But,I could collect around 190 songs. why cant tou add few more telugu colletion? As you are in hyderabad it may be possible for you.
- From: skk (@ 202.144.106.10)
on: Wed Oct 24 00:40:59 EDT 2001
I have PS's contact number. I talked to her twice over phone. She is such a nice lady and talked to me so nicely. She is down to earth. Very nice unforgettable moment for me.
Her tel. no : 044-4994779
I read that her birthday is Nov.13.
- From: kalai (@ 202.144.106.10)
on: Wed Oct 24 00:49:18 EDT 2001
I have read an article of Singer P.jayachandran in his shome page and he mentioned some unforgettable words on PS.
"www.jayachandransite.com/html/diffra.html"
Topic : difference.
I copy just few lines.
Views And Comments About Other Singers
Jayachandran discusses his views about other singers and musicians. To begin with he always starts his day of a busy schedule of singing by devoting a few minutes to his singing goddess P.Susheela, who had possessed a divine voice which was recognized by the whole of India, aged but an unforgettable singer.
- From: kalai (@ 202.9.150.55)
on: Thu Nov 22 10:13:22 EST 2001
Few more comments on PS from other celeberties
L.R Eashwari ( telugucinema.com - interview)
Who are your favourite singers? Asha Bhosale and Md Rafi in Hindi and P Suseela and Ghantasala in Telugu.
My ambition is to find a permanent place in the hearts of music lovers like Ghantasala and Suseela
S.P Shylaja :
As a singer who influenced you?
I like P Suseela most. I have been listening to her songs since childhood and thus my singing in Telugu is influenced by her. My brother and several others asked me why I was singing like Suseela. Later slowly I evolved my own style. I like the sweetness, clarity and underlying expression in Suseelas' voice very much. In those characteristics, there is nobody to compete her.
www.telugucinema.com/stars/interviews/sailaja.html
A.R Rahman:
His Favourite singer is PS ( His interview in Anantha vikatan, Chutti vikatan, Bommai)
Harrris Jeyaraj
Favorite singer PS ( chat)
Bhanumathi ( sakhalakala valli)
" enakku Susheela voice romba pidikkum, Susheela maathiri athukku pinnala yaaraum varalai, Thanithuvam ille " - kumudam (22-2-2001).
Sujatha ( singer)
Favourite singer : PS ( thanks : kumudam)
SasiRekha ( singer)
Favourite singer :PS ( she comments that "PS sings naturally" )
Pavatharini ( singer)
Favourite singer : PS ( thanks musictoday.)
I want to prove like susheela aunty.
Karthik raja ( MD)
Sangeetha ( MD deva's) daughter)
Susheela amma maathiri paadi peyar vaanga vendum (music magazene )
vairamuthu ( poet)
" kadaysi aasai enna entu kaithikalithaan ketka venduma, Kavignargalyum kelungal , Ennai kettal maranam varuvatharku mun oru P.susheela -vin paadalai olikka vittu vittu ellorum veliye poi vidunkal" Saavatharku mun naan oru murai meendum vaazha vendum" ( Intha kulathil kal erinthavargal"
vaali (poet)
Lata Mangeshkar : She appreciates PS voice in so many occations. In TFM PS thread see "cinema Express" thread. When PS got the National award ( 1st award for female singers was given to PS) , AVM felicitated her and that occasions Lata came from Bombay and praised her fro her voice.
Subbudu ( Isai vimarsagar)
Sirappaha entha isayayum paada vallamai petta P.susheela-vukku eedaga vada inthiyavil oru halaignan irukiraana?
" 28.1.2001 - Anantha vikatan in subbudu darbar"
VijayaBhaskar ( MD)
Favourite singer : P.Susheela ( The music Magazine)
Your choice was P Susheela for most of your songs?
Yes, Susheela. She could start on the second harmonium key and touch ma and pa in the next octave.
- From: raj (@ 198.151.230.253)
on: Tue Nov 27 06:52:09 EST 2001
It was An Excellent Not only these ..
Even MS has said that She likes PS's Voice..
And more that these It's a Known Fact too.
- From: kalai (@ 202.144.106.10)
on: Tue Nov 27 07:09:27 EST 2001
One interview PS told that "MGR" is her fan. ( It was in 1988 - thinathanthi).
- From: kalai (@ 202.144.106.10)
on: Wed Nov 28 06:30:30 EST 2001
why cant we discuss about her sad songs?
" Aasai kaathali maranthu po " fro puthayal and
" kanna karumai nira kanna " from naanum oru penn
her voice in first song is so innocent and other is with lots of power .
- From: raj (@ 198.151.230.253)
on: Thu Nov 29 07:25:51 EST 2001
Ya lot of Pathos Songs R there Kalai
to List a Few
1. Yenna Ninaithu yennai Azhaithayo-Nenjil Or AAlayam
2. KAakidha Odam Kadal alai meedhu-Marakamudiuma
3. Yettadukku Maaligayil Yetri veitha yen Kanavan-Navarathiri
4. Yennai MArandaden Thendrale Thendrale
-Kalangarai vilakkam
5. Kangal Irandum indru ummai kandu pesumo-
Mannadhi mannan
- From: kalai (@ 202.144.106.10)
on: Thu Nov 29 22:29:59 EST 2001
All are very good songs.
I think "ettadukku maaligayilfrom "pAtha kAnikkai"
- From: kalai (@ 202.144.106.10)
on: Fri Nov 30 02:15:57 EST 2001
" Ennai eduthu Thannai koduthu ponavan ponandi " from padagoti is one her best pathos.
" velli nila vaanathile vanthu poguthada" - ( I dont know the movie) is also a good pathos.
" kAna vantha kAtchi Enna" from BhagyaLakshmi is also a good pathos.
These four songs " ettadukku " " enni eduthu" " velli nila" and "kAna vantha " gives the same effect .ie.,
In "ennai eduthu" song " intha vayasukku ekkathai vaithu ponavan pOnAndi" - a nice hunmming along with words and it brought a painful feeling.
In " ettadukku" song,after " kaalangal ulla varai kanniyargal yArkum intha kAthal vara vendamadi" line, there is a humming with pain.
In " velli nila" song " ullathilum kAthal nila vanthu nintathada" -vai thodarnthu oru humming .
In "kaana vantha kAtchi" - ninaithu ninaithu solla vantha sethigal enna, un nilamai mari nintu vitta vethanai enna" -vai thodarnthu oru painful humming.
I the above songs are very tough to sing with the same feeling. Any more songs like this.
- From: raj (@ 198.151.230.253)
on: Fri Nov 30 03:29:42 EST 2001
One More Pathos is Idaya Veenai Thoongum Podhu Paada Mudiuma... from Iruvar Ullam
Idhu Pol yaaravadhu Paada Mudima ??
what a song & what a Rendition by PS
- From: sriram (@ 202.56.249.244)
on: Fri Nov 30 08:33:03 EST 2001
P.SUSHEELA IS THE BEST AMONG FEMALE SINGERS.
SHE DELIVERS THE SONG IN A FULL MANNER.
NO COMPARISON COULD BE MADE ABOUT HER.
EVEN SJ HAS PRAISED ABOUT HER IN HER
INTERVIEWS
SRIRAM
- From: murari (@ 202.56.249.75)
on: Sun Dec 2 08:18:59 EST 2001
kindly hear the song from anbu karangal
ungal alzagenna arivenna by ps
this song is sufficient for all debate
murari
- From: vicky (@ 63.214.94.244)
on: Sun Dec 2 14:13:17 EST 2001
I had requested that song many times...but no luck...
- From: kalai (@ 202.144.106.10)
on: Mon Dec 3 05:12:07 EST 2001
Sriram:
well said.
Without hearing PS songs properly, people started comparing her with others. Her acheivements in TFM is very high, and so far I havent find a singer nearer to her. I feel that we are insulting her just by comparing her with others. ( correct me if I am wrong).
“En vAzhvil puthu paathai kanden , Ethum thonAmal thadumAruginten – (Any one remembers the movie? ) “ - along with the lyrics she continues the humming . “ ithu kanavo, anti nanavo enathanbe nee sollayo..O…O…” ( A beautiful and powerful rendition by PS )
In palum pazhamum another song “ Intha naadagam antha medayil ethanai naal amma”, a situation song and powerfully rendered by PS. “ vaanum nilavum pirinthe iruppathu ethanai naal amma , ammamma …aa….amma..aa……). Varigalordu sernthu avar kuralum valiyodu oorvalam poi varum.
“Nilayaga en nenjil oli veesum deepam, neeya en nAlum en kAthal deepam “ from ( kalaikoil ( meenda sorgam!?) is another pathos , I don’t think anyone else can sing this song. In the second stanza “ thee intha uyir kootai erithAlum- athu nee irukkum en nenjai nerungAthu, Nee entrum vAzha vendume, antha ennam ontru pothume, athu than inbame..inbame…en inbame “ entu adi vayitilirunthu kuralezhuppi paaduvar paarungal . superb!!.
Intha maathiri ithu varai veru entha paadagigalum paadi kettathillai naan.
- From: kalai (@ 202.144.106.10)
on: Mon Dec 3 06:12:34 EST 2001
Hi raj
thank you for reminding this song.
" Ithaya veenai thoongum pothu paada mudiyuma " is a wonderful song. At the end " urugi vitta mezhuginile oliyethu, udainthu vitta silayinile azhagethu, pazhthu patta koyilile theivamathu , pazhthu patta paathayile payanam ethu" entu koil mani pol thelivaaga olippar pArungal. Romba rasithu ketka vendia paadal.
Athai pol "chithi" (?!) film-ilum "illaram onte nallaram entivar vAzhavum vida mAttar" enta paadalil , " maanam enbathu penkalukkental, penkalukken illai ?, oru varrathayinale …. Mathargal padum thollai, intha naatilum neethi illai, thamizh ettilum neethi illai " entu Ongaramai paadi vittu , kuralai appadiye thazhaithu, methuvaga mudippar parungal.. oru kai therntha nadigayai oavr kuralil kaanalam.
List all pages of this thread
Post comments
Sections:
Home -
TFM Magazine -
Forum -
Wiki -
POW -
oPod -
Lyrics -
Pictures -
Music Notes -
Forums: Current Topics - Ilayaraja Albums - A.R. Rahman Albums - TFM Oldies - Fun & Games
Ilaiyaraja: Releases - News - Share Music - AR Rahman: Releases - News - AOTW - Tweets -
Discussions: MSV - YSR - GVP - Song Requests - Song stats - Raga of songs - Copying - Tweets
Database: Main - Singers - Music Director's - Lyricists Fun: PP - EKB - Relay - Satires - Quiz
Forums: Current Topics - Ilayaraja Albums - A.R. Rahman Albums - TFM Oldies - Fun & Games
Ilaiyaraja: Releases - News - Share Music - AR Rahman: Releases - News - AOTW - Tweets -
Discussions: MSV - YSR - GVP - Song Requests - Song stats - Raga of songs - Copying - Tweets
Database: Main - Singers - Music Director's - Lyricists Fun: PP - EKB - Relay - Satires - Quiz