Home   Forum   Wiki   Notes   Register   FAQ   Sitemap   About Us   Contact Us  

Mano is better than SPB

Topic started by jonny (@ 203.199.130.32) on Fri Oct 26 06:26:41 EDT 2001.
All times in EST +10:30 for IST.

I always felt that SPB always faltered as compared to Vani Jayaram or S Janaki in Sankaraparanam. I recently heard these songs by Mano - he did them much better.

So Mano > spb. It is only Mano's humility that he says "SPB is my guru".

---

Responses:

• Old responses
  
• From: dAvAndram (@ 202.54.137.100) on: Thu Apr 1 06:30:30 EST 2004
  
  The fact I have had to explain the t-in-c remarks has got more to do with the quality of the reader than anything else. Guess, you have started seeing yourself in everybody (muddle-headed). Pretty close to culmination point in spirituality, huh ?
  I have heard all the songs you have mentioned and more. The topic of discussion is versatility (which is breadth of coverage) of KJY and SPB and the related. Hence usage of the word 'breadth' is more appropriate than what your perceiving apparatus has suggested. Guess, t-in-cis not the only thing you are not capable of understanding :) Veering away from the core issue exhibits certain qualities that you wouldn't want to flaunt consciously.
  
  Moreoever it is 'pramathavanam vENdum'. STICKLER, you can only improve, can't get worse.
  
  
  
  
  
• From: Not a/the stickler (@ 202.54.137.100) on: Thu Apr 1 06:34:30 EST 2004
  
  read 'can't get any worse'
  
  
• From: Drum-STICKER (@ 210.214.1.177) on: Thu Apr 1 12:17:25 EST 2004
  
  aiyae moonjiyaethikeenu paaraen. ennamae ithu bada bejara keethu, englipish solli kodukuraangvon thaan naan isskolakae po maataennu soltaen. innanda vantha vettikinum ottikinum rendu paeru naakkula Peter'um-mary'um poontha kanakka mari mari thittinukeerango. aiyae thoo.. othi pongada sommangatiyum sandai potnnu... appala poltation thaan itunnu povonom ungelathayum.
  
  
• From: STICKLER (@ 61.1.222.112) on: Fri Apr 2 00:00:30 EST 2004
  
  dAvAndram (@ 202.54.137.100) on: Thu Apr 1 06:30:30 EST 2004,
  .
  it is 'pramadavanam veendum (or vENdum if you wish to have it that way)' and not, 'pramathavanam vENdum'. i am pointing this out because you seem to be imagining yourself to be some kind of spellcheck program let loose in virtual reality (see all your earlier postings..). it only proves you can get worse.
  .
  
  for all i know, the confused state of mind you so proudly exhibit in your incompetent language here (i must say it is improving as you go along, where it cant' get worse), may be just a put on, and you may not be without somewhat normal intelligene in your real life.
  .
  bye, mr.dAvAndram
  
  
  
  
• From: STICKLER (@ 61.1.222.112) on: Fri Apr 2 00:08:40 EST 2004
  
  dAvAndram (@ 202.54.137.100) on: Thu Apr 1 06:30:30 EST 2004,
  .
  it is 'pramadavanam veendum (or vENdum if you wish to have it that way)' and not, 'pramathavanam vENdum'. by the way, what's 't-in-CIS'? i am pointing these out because you seem to be imagining yourself to be some kind of spellcheck program let loose in virtual reality (see all your earlier postings..). it only proves you can get worse.
  .
  
  for all i know, the confused state of mind you so proudly exhibit in your incompetent language here (i must say it is improving as you go along, where it cant' get worse), may be just a put on, and you may not be without somewhat normal intelligence in your real life.
  .
  bye, mr.dAvAndram
  
  
  
• From: dAvAndram (@ 202.54.137.100) on: Fri Apr 2 02:53:04 EST 2004
  
  STICKLER, cultivate some life beyond classicism in music and you may understand what I am trying to point out. Versatility is the core issue here and you haven't addressed it at all. All you have to do is, stick to Malayalam if you wish, but attempt going back to the mid, late 70s and focus on a composer called Salil Choudhry and let us know your findings. Listening to Baburaj's works may not be a bad idea either. The word 'focus' may not resonate with you but you could always give it a shot, some time in life you would have to.
  
  I agree with you on one thing though, this is a ridiculous topic/thread . It is almost as ridiculous as your musical perceptions and your posts.
  
  Well, as for the topic itself, Mano has a better record as a track singer than SPB because SPB wasn't one. STICKLER, this statement is not for you to understand and respond. Anyway, it was fun arguing with insularity itself :) Goodbye
  
  
• From: STICKLER (@ 61.1.222.112) on: Sat Apr 3 00:07:46 EST 2004
  
  OH, dAvAndram (@ 202.54.137.100),
  .
  BUDDY, i now know your psychology......
  *****
  DO YOU realise that the utter hollowness of your pretensions and claims- your ignorance- is easily revealed in your posts?
  *****
  your concept of 'genres' is nothing but some sub-genres subsumed in a single genre. you cannot think beyond this genre, because that is the whole universe in your imagination. moreover, i never refused to debate versatality, but rather your NARROW definition of it. nor did i posit 'depth' against 'breadth'. only i hinted that 'depth' always refers to quality; whereas 'breadth' encompasses types which may be good or bad. of course, your mind cannot grasp concepts like this.
  *****
  you were naive enough to bite the traps set by me to test your knowledge of 'their' music. of the three songs i quoted, two were traps, you fell for one of them. your re-use of "th" in place of "da' revealed your lack of familiarity with 'their' music...(can you get this?). you blithly fell for more traps, even the one set in my previous post.
  *****
  your claim that you are an expert in such and such (.. i know that and more..)is utter nonsense. a person who claims to be an expert in, say western music/pop will not drop the names of elvis or 'beatles', BECAUSE THESE ARE LEGENDS EVEN THE MOST IGNORANT WOULD HAVE HEARD OF. something like ir/msv or spb/tms in tamil. you brought in salil chaudhary and baburaj. i know you are completely ignorant of their work, except what you probably picked up right now to post here.
  *****
  your school-boyish attempts at humor are pathetic, which you must avoid if you must express better. the laboured irony, sarcasm (wit?), everything falls flat. you are just not skilled for it.
  *****
  you have been a good subject for a psychological study. BUDDY, i now know your psychology, and know that you will come back to read this.
  .
  me? i must be moving along. GOODBYE! ADIEU!
  .
  STICKLER
  
  
• From: Suresh Ramanan (@ ) on: Tue Apr 27 18:18:49 EDT 2004
  
  Stupidity, thy name is STICKLER. I have been reading through all your posts....they all wreak of one thing.....stupidity. Mr.Blockhead, MFM music sucks big time except for a few movies.
  
  
• From: Credo (@ 210.214.216.163) on: Wed Apr 28 04:36:49 EDT 2004
  
  A few good songs here and there does not make manu better than SPB. SPB is vastly superior to Manu.
  .
  By the way, Suresh Ramanan (@?), you are another addition to the dumbheads/blockheads who are coming and posting rubbish in this forum. Please keep off this place if you cannot have anything decent or relevant to say..
  
  
• From: Suresh Ramanan (@ 170.92.1.104) on: Wed Apr 28 12:00:51 EDT 2004
  
  Oh Credo, Shut up, you self-righteous git !!! Go, get a life or just stay put in the crap hole that you reside in. Bug off, Mr.Dunderhead.
  
  
• From: Credo (@ 210.214.216.173) on: Thu Apr 29 04:54:48 EDT 2004
  
  Five Fabulous Moods from SPB.
  
  1."Abishega nerathil ampalai tharisikka.."
  2."Neelavana odayil.."
  3."Vidiya Vidiya sollitharuven.."
  4."Ragangal pathinalu uruvana varalaru.."
  5."Van nila nila alla un valibam nila.."
  
  After listening to the above magnificent songs (each in a different mood) by SPB, it is clear SPB is light years ahead of SPB. The comparison is a sacrilege!.
  
  ..Suresh R, what's wrong with you? Are u nuts? don't talk gibberish.
  
  
  
  
  
  
• From: Credo (@ 210.214.216.173) on: Thu Apr 29 04:58:43 EDT 2004
  
  Oops! please read ".. SPB is light years ahead of Mano."
  .
  Sorry!
  
  
• From: IlayarajaFan (@ 209.69.221.61) on: Fri Apr 30 11:49:51 EDT 2004
  
  Joke
  
  
• From: Suresh Ramanan (@ 170.92.1.104) on: Fri Apr 30 14:14:12 EDT 2004
  
  Credo, enuff is enuff !!! We do not need an ignoramus like you tell us about SPB. Your talking about SPB is an insult to SPB.
  
  
• From: Credo (@ 210.214.216.64) on: Wed May 5 03:37:06 EDT 2004
  
  eh?
  That's really childish. SR, think you hold some kind of copy right on discussing SPB?. Anyway, what made you think I was telling YOU about SPB? This is a forum where people post their views. If you do not like it that way, what prevents you from going away? From the way you post, you must be the dumbest, stupidest idiot visiting this forum. If you are a fan of SPB, that's an insult to SPB !!!
  
  
• From: Suresh Ramanan (@ 170.92.1.104) on: Wed May 5 19:53:58 EDT 2004
  
  Credo, piss off !!!!! Precisely, I am posting my views here. DO you know what the full form for SPB is ? For discussing SPB, you need class, not crass that you represent. STICKLER and you should rank as the worst low-lives-worse-than-scum-bags ever to log on to internet. Do you know music at all ? I am sure you are one of those music fans like STICKLER who know nothing about ragas and the harmony and rest of the good stuff !!!! Have you or STICKLER heard of the chord disp-c7 ? Come on, tell me what that is all about. Give me one Tamil song based on ragam Swapneswari and sung by SPB. if you cannot hide your face like the coward STICKLER.
  
  
• From: hehe (@ 24.98.53.83) on: Wed May 5 20:53:45 EDT 2004
  
  Dey Panny,
  Evanda avan Mayiru unakku enna view koothi. If u have have a view just post it to the back of ur wife.
  
  
• From: * (@ 128.88.255.34) on: Thu May 6 06:59:39 EDT 2004
  
  SPB fan v SPB fan fighta?? ellarum pesama irunga illena Raghu kitta solli unga membership kalteeruven!
  
  
• From: Kibitzer (@ 61.1.255.190) on: Wed May 12 07:59:05 EDT 2004
  
  Good fun. This is the best thread in this site for anybody interested in the strange and the wierd- infested with dumb idiots (STCIKLER), moronic faggots (Devendram a.k.a. Suresh Ramanan), half baked experts (Harikrishnan and Credo), and a few plain irritated (many). Devendram/Sur R is a problem of deep seated inferiority complex. The faggot's excited gyrations of his lovingly exposed posterior was amply rewarded with the amorous attentions of Credo and the idiot Stickler. Most of it shameful display of erectile disfunction. HK and Credo like true idiots were showing off (jacking off)their limited supply of expertise.
  So it goes on.
  
  
  
• From: Credo (@ ) on: Wed May 19 09:11:36 EDT 2004
  
  SRamanan, for all I care, you can take your CHORD DISP-C7, put SWAPNESWARI on top of it, granish it with crushed glass (and some pepper if you wish so, for enhanced pleasure) and shove the whole thing up that part of your anatomy where you seem to enjoy it most.
  Spare us the rest.
  
  
  
• From: Credo (@ 61.2.192.79) on: Wed May 19 09:14:45 EDT 2004
  
  That goes for Kibitzer too.
  
  
• From: * (@ 161.114.1.182) on: Wed May 19 09:31:09 EDT 2004
  
  GRE General Test and Subject Test are passe, ETS has now brought in the Insult Test ;)
  
  
• From: Suresh Ramanan (@ 63.231.161.141) on: Wed May 19 10:00:30 EDT 2004
  
  Credo, you are blocking that part of my anatomy. You need to vacate it fast as Kibitzer wants to occupy it desperately.
  
  
• From: Credo (@ 61.1.255.31) on: Mon May 24 03:29:04 EDT 2004
  
  SR, if you crane your neck and look behind you, you will see I had vacated it long back. Now, it is virtually a queue out there everybody waiting their turn...
  
  
• From: Chakra (@ ) on: Tue Jun 8 00:37:03 EDT 2004
  
  Friends, this thread is an insult to our great SPB and some fools are keeping it alive by posting foolish comments here. Let us not revive this thread at any cost.
  
  
• From: Bada Boss (@ 210.214.242.85) on: Tue Jun 8 02:47:21 EDT 2004
  
  Agree with you :)
  
  
• From: C~P (@ 61.95.159.19) on: Tue Jun 8 09:31:13 EDT 2004
  
  Chakra,
  Archives-ku pona thread-a thatti ezhuppi ippadi oru dialogue thevai dhaana? :-)
  
  

---

List all pages of this thread

---

Back to the Forum

Post comments