Topic started by xml (@ 128.148.68.110) on Sat Jan 17 18:46:32 EST 2004.
All times in EST +10:30 for IST.
I want prove that apart from western artist ARR has copied many song from indian MD's.Many of the songs were composed by HJ when he was with him.Let me give the details of them.
Arasatchi: Mr.Romeo:
Saiyo Saiyo(Style,Inspried) Muthu Malai
Arasatchi: Baba:
Chant of Arasatci(Starting same) Theme
Arasatci: Mr.Romeo:
20 Vayasu(Style,Backing) Melisaiye
Arasatchi: Kadhal Virus:
20 Vayasu(Starting same) Bailamore
Arasatchi: Jeans:
Mohalai(Usage of Instruments) Hairabba
Ullam Kekumea: Muthu:
Mazhai Mazhai(Just listen) Meena's Intro(BGM)
Ullam Kekumea: Uyire:
O Maname (Backing) Poongratrile
Ullam Kekumae: Kadhalan:
Dho Dho(2nd Interlude-Same style/beat) Urvasi
Saamy: May Maadham:
Veepamaram Madras Suthi Paaka
(Style & Heavilly Inspired by Beats from ARR)
Kaake Kaake: Thenali:
Ooru Ooril(Backing -One Part) Swasame
Kaake Kaake/RHDTM: Vandhe Madharam:
Ondra Renda/Dilko(Backings) Only You
Saami: Taj Mahal:
Thirunalveli(Heavily Inspired) Thirupatchi Aruvale
Saami: Sangamam:
Idhuthana(The style & feel of the song) Marghazhi
Saami: Karuthamma:
Pudichirukku (interlude) Thenmerku
Saami: Vande Madharam:
Ithudhan(1st part) Only You
Minnale: Alaipayuthey:
Venmathiye(same instruments) Evano Oruvan
Minnale: Kadhal Dhesam:
Azhagiye Theeye(Interlude) Mustafa
Minnale: Thakshak:
Poopol(Backing) Dheem Dhirana
Majunu: Advertisement:
Mudher kanave(small part) Leo Coffe
Majunu: Alaipayuthey:
Gulmore Malare(same) Pachai Nirame
Laysa Laysa: Lagaan:
Laysa Laysa(small part) Opalanhare
Laysa Laysa: Thiruda Thiruda:
Ilimai Inimai(interlude) VeerapandiKotayille
Laysa Laysa: Rhthym:
Aval Uzhaga Azhigye(backing) Anbe
Vaasu/Vetri & RHDTM: JEANS:
OPrema & Rehna Rehna Tere(backing) Hairabba
Samurai: Kandukoinden 2:
Athithadi Appatha(interlude 1) BGM
Samurai: Thakshak/Star:
Athithadi Appatha(interlude 2) Dheem/ThomKaruvil
Samurai: Mr.Romeo:
Athithadi Appatha(interlude 3) Romeo Attam Pootal
Majunu: Pukar:
Mercury Melea(simular) Humrahi Jabho Mastana
12b: Iruvar:
Oru Punnagai(Backing) Kannai Kathi Kolathe
Songs copied from IR
Maveeran:Enswasakatre
Othungu othungu:Jimbalakka
Valter vetrivel:gentleman
Chinna rasave:ottahathai kattikko
Athma:Puthiyamugam
Ninaikkindra thendrale:Kannukku mai azhagu
Nooravathu naal:alaipayuthe
Vizhilieley:snehithane
Songs copied from MSV
Thangapathakkathin meley:Ennavizhzi azhage(kathalar dinam)
song-Sippi irukkuthu(varumaien niram sigappu):roja roja(kathalar dinam)
Song copied from YSR
Kunnuru poochatti(velai):Dolna(Parasuram)
and many more!!!
Responses:
- Old responses
- From: Piratheepan (@ 68.89.41.114)
on: Mon Jan 19 11:23:54 EST 2004
no cuz his name is never in any credits, becuz if you look in any of the credits of arr's stuff if theres a guest composer they are given credit like ranjit barot (VIP fame) and pravin mani
- From: paran (@ 203.123.16.168)
on: Mon Jan 19 21:27:07 EST 2004
dei kenne kabothi mundam naatamai & xml...
tamil audio cassete in malaysia...were never bad, it has been filled with local bands for years now....they never dried..it's ur vishiyam therinje TN-le thaan audio industry was dired...eventhough IR was producing album after album, like Dhanush, Konji Pesalam, En Mana Vaanil..these are super hits....rite?......rombe shanthosyam-ma irukupa....
yetho...pulle kuttigalode santhoshamma iruntha seri..
- From: paran (@ 203.123.16.168)
on: Mon Jan 19 21:28:37 EST 2004
and Pritaheepan....that's the best part of ARR that these guys fail to notice...ARR gives credit..
just one question..we have heard hundres, or perhaps thousands of IR's song contains tabla music....can u name the player please?....
don't just give, Madasamy, Karupusamy...but show a proof that they are the one who played the tabla?...
can u?
- From: Aswathama (@ 68.58.124.250)
on: Mon Jan 19 22:36:19 EST 2004
When ARR give credit to his players he should also give credits to each every song he copied from other MDs.
- From: paran (@ 203.123.16.168)
on: Mon Jan 19 22:41:45 EST 2004
Aswathamma...the problem is he never COPIED....but u ppl claim it's copied when u hear the same instrument, or same chorus.....
where in IR's case..u have heard millions of times the tabla sound...but u never shouted it's being repeated..why?
- From: C~P (@ 61.95.159.16)
on: Mon Jan 19 22:46:08 EST 2004
IR did not do both - no credits to his 'players' and no credits to the 'source'...ARR atleast does one of this! ... something is better than nothing
- From: C~P (@ 61.95.159.16)
on: Mon Jan 19 22:47:53 EST 2004
Paran,
there is no use arguing with them since they arent going to accept. so just accept wat they say and talk in a similar manner! Afterall crapping isn't something that tough to follow!
- From: curses (@ 61.1.201.86)
on: Tue Jan 20 00:39:34 EST 2004
C~P, true.
Aswathama,
check this out. http://www.iespana.es/i2fs/
- From: Fact File (@ 194.69.1.23)
on: Tue Jan 20 02:14:17 EST 2004
XML you are a sore Loser!
This is a great way of turning the tables around!
when someone you copy from someones creations, to get away from trouble all you have to do is do what you have done!
Come on xml, what makes you say HJ composed those tunes when he was with ARR! Just because HJ is a lousy composer and u are his lousy fan, who cant take facts that HJ copies from ARR, dont come up with theories of your own. Simply said HJ is a copy cat!
- From: hj sucks arr rulez (@ 166.121.36.7)
on: Tue Jan 20 03:55:59 EST 2004
Many of the songs were composed by HJ when he was with him.Let me give the details of them.
haha i can laugh. how the hell would ARR know that HJ is gonna composeb all that crap and copy from him way back in time. Romba sci-fi ya pohureengalle xml. Imperamation is wealth.Crap is nothing.
- From: C~P (@ 61.95.159.16)
on: Tue Jan 20 04:02:29 EST 2004
ithula comedy ennana he ends the topic with a "and many more!!!"!! ... ithuvaey thaangala, ithukku maela vaera vechirukkaraam!
kollunga ejamaan, kollunga..itha xml-ey ippadi thaan! ;-)
- From: jacky (@ 61.1.200.60)
on: Tue Jan 20 04:27:07 EST 2004
Ellam oru vijayakanth padathuku HJ music pottarna HJ fans ellam theligutuvanka.
- From: paran (@ 203.123.16.168)
on: Tue Jan 20 04:40:28 EST 2004
he shoudl give some good music....may be for Vanchinathan
he would remix it like
"Gi gi gi, vanji
vedi, veni vinchi, it's vaanji
he flies, he punches, he kicks THOOOOT
his Vanjiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii....nathan...."
:)
- From: paran (@ 203.123.16.168)
on: Tue Jan 20 04:40:42 EST 2004
he shoudl give some good music....may be for Vanchinathan
he would remix it like
"Ji ji ji, vanji
vedi, veni vinchi, it's vaanji
he flies, he punches, he kicks THOOOOT
his Vanjiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii....nathan...."
:)
- From: C~P (@ 61.95.159.16)
on: Tue Jan 20 05:05:28 EST 2004
ada chi! :-)
- From: jp (@ 210.214.128.164)
on: Tue Jan 20 05:34:32 EST 2004
anyway movie will be flop
apparam we will read this any tamil magazine
Vijayakanth - Harris jayaraj, enaku tamila pudikatha orey music director
HJ - Nenachu koda pakkala en career la oru eruma madu mothiruchu!
- From: curses (@ 61.1.200.129)
on: Tue Jan 20 06:11:32 EST 2004
come on guys,
how much ever i'm enjoying this (sorry xml!), I think we must give the poor guy a break..
****************
From: xml (@ 128.148.68.110) on: Mon Jan 19 10:58:27 EST 2004
Yeah
I made a mistake with the title.
It should be HJ's composed song in ARR's name.They are not copied song,but composed by HJ.Is that OK.
****************
There.. now it's a lot more prominent.
But now, i'm even confused w/ what u've written. What did u mean neway?
- From: C~P (@ 61.95.159.16)
on: Tue Jan 20 06:47:54 EST 2004
"I think we must give the poor guy a break."
What do u think we have been doing all along? An infinite intermission for the topic and the 'poor guy'! ;-)
- From: GRDG (@ 203.124.0.245)
on: Wed Jan 21 04:08:18 EST 2004
title ethukku kuzhappam. HJ's copied songs from ARR. Ok?
- From: MUSIC LOVER (@ 62.215.3.38)
on: Sat Jan 24 05:37:00 EST 2004
I SAW KOVIL,I DEFINITELY HAVE MADE MANY SINS TO WATCH SUCH A DISGUSTING MOVIE,ANYWAYS,AN IMPORTANT SCENE AND OUR GREAT COMPOSER HJ HAS TAKEN GREAT EFFORT TO COMPOSE THE BGM FOR THAT SCENE,THE BGM IS A DIRECT LIFT FROM OLD SPICE AD WHERE THE GUY IS SURFING IN THE SEA,U GUYS REMEMBER IT,WHAT A TERRIFIC EFFORT BY HJ,I THINK ITS TIME WE ALL STOP EVEN TALKING ABOUT A MUSIC DIRECTOR WHO DOESNT EVEN HAVE A CLUE OF WAT HES DOING
- From: pengal nenjai kolai kollum velai madhava (@ 195.93.73.10)
on: Sat Jan 24 06:55:29 EST 2004
ada pavigala HJ patti orui thread tirendirukiringuélé unngaluku MANAM ROSHAM EDUVOM KIDHEYADHA!!!!!!!!!!!
HJ engai ooril tea vikiréven!! avané poyi isay amapalar endhru solluringuélé
List all pages of this thread
Back to the Forum
Post comments
Forums: Current Topics - Ilayaraja Albums - A.R. Rahman Albums - TFM Oldies - Fun & Games
Ilaiyaraja: Releases - News - Share Music - AR Rahman: Releases - News - AOTW - Tweets -
Discussions: MSV - YSR - GVP - Song Requests - Song stats - Raga of songs - Copying - Tweets
Database: Main - Singers - Music Director's - Lyricists Fun: PP - EKB - Relay - Satires - Quiz