Topic started by Common Friend (@ 203.197.141.187) on Sun Jul 8 08:28:27 EDT 2001.
All times in EST +10:30 for IST.
These are two films by HJ and Bharani respectively. I was in a VCD shop today in the outscirts of Chennai, where I came thru these two cassettes. When I enquired, the women there said that Manju is Ok but L&G is really good. She was insisting this again and again. Also, CHOCOLATE has nothing better other than a 5-star chocolate with the cassette. She said that overall STAR songs are hit and its sales is in the peak. Theabouve mentioned two films are new releases and please, put your opinions about them here.
Responses:
- Old responses
- From: mahabs (@ 203.197.138.163)
on: Thu Jul 19 04:21:06 EDT 2001
what did balaji mean 'hit' actually? movie or the songs?
i thought he meant songs! he was referring to the album only.
anbudan
mahabs
- From: NagaS (@ 202.169.188.186)
on: Thu Jul 19 05:57:37 EDT 2001
mahabs,
Yes, I also felt he talked about songs, Semparuthi songs are hit for sure., (By Popularity of songs - a measure which seems to be the darling of everyone thesedays :-)
NagaS
- From: Balaji (@ webproxy03qfe0.sbi.com)
on: Thu Jul 19 08:26:01 EDT 2001
I meant the songs in the films !!!!
Mahabs (& Nags), you were right on your list. I was wrong! I also realized that the songs were hit in 1. Parthen Rasithen
2. Appu (some songs were unfortunately!!)
I am taking back my statement
Balaji
- From: Common Friend (@ 203.197.141.187)
on: Sat Jul 21 10:10:54 EDT 2001
Parthen Rasithen , I think is a genuine hit. It was also a good film.
- From: sabesan (@ adsl-64-163-214-64.dsl.snfc21.pacbell.net)
on: Sat Jul 21 14:56:57 EDT 2001
vaikasi poranthachu and Kaathal Kavithai were also hits..... vanna vanna pookal had very good songs, but i think was a flop (junk movie)....
- From: Comments (@ ac94f379.ipt.aol.com)
on: Sat Jul 21 16:45:08 EDT 2001
IMO, Majnu is a definite winner for Harris. Doesn't have a chartbuster like vaseegara and does indeed bear resemblance to earlier songs. But it is still a decent effort and worth a buy!
- From: Raja (@ proxy.sna.netsetter.com)
on: Sun Jul 22 14:27:37 EDT 2001
Golmore Malare..i listen this to this song..and pretty similar to "Pachai Nirame" any body accepting this idea...is it the music or the raaga.
?????Music....
Raja
- From: Common Friend (@ 203.197.141.183)
on: Mon Jul 23 07:44:33 EDT 2001
>>>Golmore Malare..i listen this to this song..and pretty similar to "Pachai Nirame" any body accepting this idea...is it the music or the raaga.
Its probably a decent copy.
Also, "Mericury mele" songs pallavi is lifted from "Hum raahi jab ho mastana" from pukaar. Its available in the net. Check it out.
- From: ramas (@ c1714858-a.bvrtn1.or.home.com)
on: Sun Jul 29 21:26:14 EDT 2001
Harris Jeyaraj is just another music director. Nothing fresh in Majnu. Each and every song is a mix of lots of recent and little bit old Rehman songs. I thought he will give something different after Minnalae.
Golmohar malarae, is the same as pachai niramae.
Pada pada pattampoochi, is in the lines of Varaga nathikaraiyoram and Uppu karuvadu ooravacha soru.
Mudhar kanavae, is in the lines of Ival yaaro, ival yaaro vandhadhu enakkaga.
Pinju thendralae resembles thenkizhakku cheemayilae sengatru boomiyila and a song from kadhal desam and an old song. Other songs are not that good. It is a pity a music director does not have fresh songs for jsut the second movie. But what i fear the most is, this guy will also be put high in the TFM and he will go around with an attitude, and act as if he is a great music director.
In the days when IR was at his peak. We listen to the song, at the first hearing, we will love it and follow it. Now a days we are following the songs(listening to it 100 times)and obviously getting used to the song and then trying to love it. Anyways, this is the fate of TFM i think. I don't know when again TFM will get a music director to the standards of IR.
- From: G.Ragavan (@ 164.164.94.115)
on: Mon Jul 30 09:08:59 EDT 2001
I listend majnu songs. "Pinjchuth thenrale" is good. But the songs are very simillar to ARR songs.
- From: Common Friend (@ 203.197.141.183)
on: Mon Jul 30 13:27:30 EDT 2001
>>>Pinju thendralae resembles thenkizhakku cheemayilae sengatru boomiyila and a song from kadhal desam and an old song.
I too thought so.
Also, the "mercury mele medai idu" is a pakka lift of "ham raahi jab ho masthana" from pukar.
- From: Bhagavathar (@ inehou-pxy06.compaq.com)
on: Mon Jul 30 15:27:14 EDT 2001
thenkizhakku cheemayilae sengatru boomiyila is from Kizhakku Seemaiyilae not Kadhal Desam.
- From: suresh kumar joseph (@ 203.106.178.73)
on: Tue Jul 31 09:58:15 EDT 2001
I think all the songs in Majnu worth listening to.
By the way, the music for "mudher kanave" resembles "minsara kanna", from padayappa.
I'm happy because Sandya, the P. Susila sound alike is back in action.
I think "Vaseegra" would have been a hit also if rendered by harini, Swarnalatha, nithya Sri, Kavitha Subramaniam,Anuradha Sriram, Sujatha or Chitra.It became a hit because of the music and lyrics, and not because of the singer, Bombay Jeyashree.Her voice does not suit heroines.Does anyone agree with me???
- From: S T S (@ 63-93-98-227.oak.dial.netzero.com)
on: Sun Aug 5 12:36:52 EDT 2001
Whether HJ inspired/copied or not, it is going to be a sure fire hit. Though all song reminds me of his own or other MDs, he packaged it so well that TFM lovers will like it.
Some how Ladies and Gentleman is not that catchy.
Cinema Paarkalaam, Rukku, Jeya are mediocre songs. Alai Alaiyaai (reminds me another song). Vennilaave Vennilaave is good.
- From: ramesh (@ 61.11.33.50)
on: Mon Aug 6 05:57:18 EDT 2001
another superb album from harris jayaraj,i think now HJ starts pulling back the tfm to his side by his instaneus hits,because now everybody starts accepting MAJNU as an incredible one.even the vijay tv chikku bukku places the album in no.1 position from the day of cassette release followed by star and chocolate .ultimately the expectation for 12b has been hipped up.
now,we fans has to wait for the cassette release which was announced for 15th of this month....may god bless tfm.
- From: ramesh (@ 61.11.33.50)
on: Mon Aug 6 05:57:28 EDT 2001
another superb album from harris jayaraj,i think now HJ starts pulling back the tfm to his side by his instaneus hits,because now everybody starts accepting MAJNU as an incredible one.even the vijay tv chikku bukku places the album in no.1 position from the day of cassette release followed by star and chocolate .ultimately the expectation for 12b has been hipped up.
now,we fans has to wait for the cassette release which was announced for 15th of this month....may god bless tfm.
- From: Common Friend (@ 203.197.141.187)
on: Mon Aug 6 13:25:24 EDT 2001
>>>vijay tv chikku bukku places the album in no.1 position from the day of cassette release followed by star and chocolate
This is a news for me.
- From: S T S (@ 63-93-98-191.oak.dial.netzero.com)
on: Tue Aug 7 16:18:33 EDT 2001
Ramesh,
I am NOT surprised, at all! This is what I said in my previous postings. God Bless.
- From: ~~arochordidae~~ (@ 204.50.249.133)
on: Tue Aug 7 21:39:26 EDT 2001
Whatz with everyone?? Okay, maybe its just me...But I really didn't like the pinju thendrale song. Actually, to be honest, it sucked big time.
Maybe its just my weird taste for music, mucachos and muchachas?!
- From: STUPID (@ kmr-184-156.tm.net.my)
on: Wed Aug 8 04:33:20 EDT 2001
well .......
meccury mele is like a somg from padayapa
every song he make is from arr tune
BUT it a beutiful song after he remake
- From: kannan (@ caprx01.ext.nokia.com)
on: Wed Aug 8 12:20:02 EDT 2001
Just as a change.....
y not try posting some of your comments on the official HR website or even get someone responsible for his site to look at here?
wouldn't it be interesting to find out of what the outcome is?
sometimes its more suitable to get staright to the point than beating arorund the bush!! as all in his Guest book seem to interested in one thing: i.e how excellent he is!! but will he be prepared to accept criticism too???
here's the url::: http://www.galatta.com/guestbook/viewgb.asp?site=harrisjayaraj.com
the site's credit claims that it has been hosted by bothe galatta and info gateway.... thus shall assume it not to be a hoax!!
~:-))
- From: vijay2000 (@ 203.106.78.117)
on: Wed Aug 8 23:42:43 EDT 2001
well even tough the songs are really nice to hear,but the fact is he's copying some of Rahman's tunes.
for example:-
gulmohar malare (pachai nirame)
mudher kanave (narumugaye-iruvar)
pincu thendrale (from pavithra)
so this is the things i've got on my own and I think he is not coming with any new tunes...Its all the remade from our genius,Rehman.
- From: Common Friend (@ 203.197.141.183)
on: Thu Aug 9 12:35:17 EDT 2001
why are you all missing the mercury mele song. The pallavi is an exact lift of "ham raahi jab ho mastana" from Pukaar. Did any one listen to that actually.
I tried to prove that by playing MM song from raaga.com and pukaar song from my disk in mp3 format.
- From: Common Friend (@ 203.197.141.183)
on: Thu Aug 9 12:40:08 EDT 2001
The above mentioned test worked. mercury mele song very heavyly resembles the hindi song from pukaar.
- From: rishie (@ 24.69.255.205)
on: Thu Aug 9 17:10:22 EDT 2001
who is this new MD bharani?..it sounds like he is on the talks now...
- From: i.kutti (@ 66.43.9.174)
on: Fri Aug 10 15:18:40 EDT 2001
he is the MD of.. paarvai ondrey pothumey
- From: Angel (@ )
on: Fri Jan 4 03:02:09 EST 2002
Hi,We will get bored with Majnu,the reviews i came across have all mentioned this only so this is not atall positive.Wish U will do better,even from Majnu u have some touchy catches esp.in Mutharkanave the instrumental b4 first saranam and background miruthangam kind of music this is cute but the pallavi is not that good.So take care All the Best
- From: Pras (@ 193.56.241.19)
on: Fri Jan 4 04:47:47 EST 2002
muthal kanave is really good !
good job from HJ
- From: Rathi (@ 172.191.41.205)
on: Fri Jan 4 11:10:54 EST 2002
HJ don't cheat us.Give us some original works please.
- From: prasanth (@ 202.9.167.86)
on: Wed Jan 9 12:22:54 EST 2002
hj has raped a girl of 16
and the case is under court
majnu songs are pure copy of arr song .hjsay's
he was an assistant in arr's trop,i think he was a barber ther he has been bussy cutting hair of sivamani and clinton he shoul continu doing that
- From: rani (@ )
on: Tue Feb 19 06:34:06 EST 2002
PARTHALAE PARAVASAM SUX BIG TIME
- From: suni (@ 202.156.2.92)
on: Tue Feb 19 06:35:12 EST 2002
After all simran is nooooo match for madhavan
List all pages of this thread
Back to the Forum
Post comments
Sections:
Home -
TFM Magazine -
Forum -
Wiki -
POW -
oPod -
Lyrics -
Pictures -
Music Notes -
Forums: Current Topics - Ilayaraja Albums - A.R. Rahman Albums - TFM Oldies - Fun & Games
Ilaiyaraja: Releases - News - Share Music - AR Rahman: Releases - News - AOTW - Tweets -
Discussions: MSV - YSR - GVP - Song Requests - Song stats - Raga of songs - Copying - Tweets
Database: Main - Singers - Music Director's - Lyricists Fun: PP - EKB - Relay - Satires - Quiz
Forums: Current Topics - Ilayaraja Albums - A.R. Rahman Albums - TFM Oldies - Fun & Games
Ilaiyaraja: Releases - News - Share Music - AR Rahman: Releases - News - AOTW - Tweets -
Discussions: MSV - YSR - GVP - Song Requests - Song stats - Raga of songs - Copying - Tweets
Database: Main - Singers - Music Director's - Lyricists Fun: PP - EKB - Relay - Satires - Quiz