Topic started by Srikanth (@ passport.proxy.lucent.com) on Mon Sep 15 10:23:15 EDT 1997.
All times in EDT +9:30 for IST.
Responses:
- Old responses
- From: hihi:-) (@ psiphi.umsl.edu)
on: Fri Nov 12 16:37:53 EST 1999
udhayA :-)
- From: Priya (@ 195.101.0.171)
on: Sat Nov 13 09:39:16 EST 1999
LISTEN TO MUTHALVAN TAJMAHAL & ALAIPAUTHEA SONGS HERE IN ENGALPAKKAM.AND PLEASE ALSO LEAVE IN YOUR COMMENTS IN THE GUEST BOOK !
THANK YOU !
Engalpakam " target="_top">http://engalpakam.8m.com">Engalpakam
- From: Raveen (@ 195.101.0.171)
on: Sat Nov 13 09:42:43 EST 1999
Engalpakam " target="_top">http://engalpakam.8m.com">Engalpakam
VISIT ENGALPAKAM TOLISTEN TO TAJMAHAL , MUTHALVAN & ALAIPAYUTHEA.THANK YOU ..PLZ DO NOT FORGET TO SIGN THE GUEST BOOK !
- From: Withya N. Rajah (@ gatekeeper.cognos.com)
on: Sat Nov 13 17:19:30 EST 1999
I personally believe that everyone actor/director/producer/singer are special in some way. So we people should not critize one another.....Beside we are all tamilans right?
So people, do you really think that actors and singers would view these comments..?
Indian Rasigai
- From: Ramkumar Perumanam (@ hoproxy1.proxy.lucent.com)
on: Sat Nov 13 21:46:04 EST 1999
Hi Shashi,
Actually the similarity between "Kurukku" and "Nallavarkellam" is more pronounced in the charanam. I can give you couple of lines from the charanam and let me see if it rings any bell. Ramki would be the best person to complete the lyrics for this song.
Andavan ariya nenjil oru thuli vanjam illai
Avan indri enakku veru aarudhal illai
Manidhan amma mayangugiren
............ || Nallavarkellam ||
Nadhi vellam kazhndhu vittal nadhi seitha kutram illai
Vidhi seidha kutram indri veru aagumo
Paravaigale badhil sollungal
.............
.............. || Nallavarkellam ||
In fact the melody for rest of the charanam has more resemblance to the Mudhalvan song. Hence I feel structure as well as the transition of ragam from Pallavi to Charanam in both the songs to be similar.
- From: STSrinivasan (@ snfcba06-08.splitrock.net)
on: Sun Nov 14 04:52:23 EST 1999
Friends,
Please visit my site for Yuvan Shankars latest film Unakkaka Ellam Unakkaka and songs from the album The Blast, IRs Time, ARRsand <Mudhalvan at my site.
http://stsrinivasan.tripod.com/TamilSongs
Regards
STS
- From: Ramki (@ ptp141.telsoft.net) on: Sun Nov 14 14:16:22 EST 1999
The starting lines by Harini in 'azhagaana rakshashi' (ar..meenukku ...)is exactly similar to
'paruvam sumandhu vandha paavai varuga
pudhavai anindhu vandha kolam varuga' from 'yaaro ezhudhiya kavidhai'
Ramkumar check your hotmail
- From: ragumanfan (@ grex.cyberspace.org) on: Mon Nov 15 00:15:59 EST 1999
arr is superb in tajmahal songs.mudhalvan songs are also good
arr is best.
- From: ARR Rasigan-Critic (@ bkj-cache83.jaring.my) on: Mon Nov 15 01:35:28 EST 1999
ella songs'um nalla irukku in Muthalvan and Tajmahal butt'e as a tradition, ARR palaya paatu eduthu (especially MSV's) puthusa western sethu brand new song mathiri tharaaaru. SO ARR will be the 1st MD in India. But bear in mind, ARR is a geniuso-copier guy...!
- From: NagaS (@ 194.149.80.1) on: Mon Nov 15 02:36:40 EST 1999
Hi all.,
This is just a question., Not a conclusion and NOM.,
Today morning I happened to listen ARR's 'KuLiruthu., ' from Tajmahal and Karthik Raja's Classic 'Veesum kaatRukku., ' from Ullaasam., There is a very good violin piece(or is it something else ? :-) in the second song which comes thro'out the song - For me it seems like the source for the first few lines of 'KuLiruthu., ' song. Am i correct ? or they both are based on same raga or something ? Yaaraavathu puriyaRa maathiri sollunga Please., thalaiyaip pichchukkalaam poola irukku., I listened to both the songs n number of time repeatedly and still ---- oNNumee puriyalai.,
Please Help.,
:-)
NagaS
- From: SangeethaArakkan (@ 212.77.192.20) on: Mon Nov 15 03:36:05 EST 1999
You'are right nagas. 'Kuliruthu' is inspired from 'veesumkaatrukku'. but 'veesumkaatrukku' is inspired from western album called 'melodious melodies' of jonathan stanche, a french composer. I had the copy of the album it was released in 89.
- From: pg (@ gate02.merck-medco.com) on: Mon Nov 15 08:54:31 EST 1999
Hi guys :
I had mentioned that
rOjA rOjA rOjA from kAdhalar dhinam is exactly the repeat of
ennai vittAl yArumillai kaNmaNiye un kai aNaikka from nALai namadhE.
So many lifts by our no 1 tn-indian-international MD and only dEvA gets flayed here.
- From: A.R.Rahuvaran (@ temagami.carleton.ca) on: Mon Nov 15 09:46:03 EST 1999
Is anybody realized that the song " SENKAATRE... SENKAATRE" from TajMahal is exactly as IlaiyaIaja's song RAASATHTHI.... RAASATHTHI UNNAI ENNI MANAM URUHI NINDRENADI........)??/ I dont remember the movie name but it is VijayaKanth movie.
Is anybody noticed??
Why ARR doing such a things??
- From: Shankar (@ netcache32.mot.com) on: Mon Nov 15 10:24:53 EST 1999
ARR,
rAsAthi is from poovarasan a karthik starrer...
- From: SIVA (@ klj-228-14.tm.net.my) on: Mon Nov 15 11:35:37 EST 1999
MUDHALVAN... The film is very good but some songs like kurukku, alagaana ratchasiye & uppu karuvaadu is not suitable for this film & BGM is very poor ..What happen to ARR....???
ANY COMMAN.............................................
- From: mapillai (@ dyn2-92.kla-tencor.com) on: Mon Nov 15 13:25:33 EST 1999
Yaa I also felt the same when I saw the movie.The BGM was very poor.Maybe ARR is slowly running out of ideas.Nowhere he is near to any IR's BGM.I hope he should do a good job and concentrate in BGM's like his songs.
- From: mapillai (@ dyn2-92.kla-tencor.com) on: Mon Nov 15 13:27:09 EST 1999
Yaa I also felt the same when I saw the movie.The BGM was very poor.Maybe ARR is slowly running out of ideas.Nowhere its not close to any IR's BGM.I hope he concentrates on his BGM's like what he does for his songs.
- From: Die hard fan of ARR (@ 203.116.186.31) on: Wed Nov 17 00:49:35 EST 1999
Hey stupid mapillai and company.I saw mudhalvan and it's BGM is not bad.Anyway i think that those who hate ARR should not be in this discussion page.ARR is a geniues.If IR is so good, why can't he show his talent in bollywood.Better think before typing as we the fans of ARR would not TAKE IT EASY.Sorry for my harsh words.Bye.
- From: shan (@ 210.212.246.118) on: Wed Nov 17 13:39:20 EST 1999
yes i go with the die hard fan of ARR tho also a great fan of IR b'coz there is nothing great abt criticizing a genius like ARR.
bye
- From: a (@ user134012.dial.netline.net.uk) on: Wed Nov 17 20:19:33 EST 1999
Veesum Kaatrukku is an exact copy of a song which was in Disney's Pocohontas, music and all!
- From: b (@ user134012.dial.netline.net.uk) on: Wed Nov 17 20:22:23 EST 1999
By the way, ARR's Bombay Dream project is well under way in London, Anderew Lloyd Webber loves him and is working with him and Shekar Kapoor!!!!!
- From: c (@ user134012.dial.netline.net.uk) on: Wed Nov 17 20:30:47 EST 1999
Deva has also used the Raga Vaasanthi in the film Avvai Shanmughi - the song is Kadhala Kadhala Kadhalil Thavikkiren.
Rehman has used Vaasanthi well in Mudalvan, the song being a very big hit and loved by all, including some top directors in India and also some Sound engineers - I won't mention names!
Reason for Azlagana Ratchisiye having a Cinna Kannan sound, they are the same Raga and there's not much variation one can give to Reethigowla. Take a isten to all the numbers in the Raga, there will be similarities.
As for Sowkyama and Mayil meedu or Murali Dhara Gopala, Maand is also a Raga that cannot be elaborated on much. In Carnatic music, one will see very few compositions in these Minor Ragas, as one cannot do much Aalapana on them nor can very exclusive sounding compositions be done on these.
- From: mambo (@ qt-ce.singnet.com.sg) on: Thu Nov 18 07:30:10 EST 1999
pls. ARR is the best and IR is "TRASH"
- From: mambo (@ qt-ce.singnet.com.sg) on: Thu Nov 18 07:31:35 EST 1999
pls. ARR is the best and IR is "TRASH"
- From: u_know_who (@ netcache32.mot.com) on: Thu Nov 18 08:49:04 EST 1999
mambo,
Shut ur ..........
- From: mapillai (@ dyn2-254.kla-tencor.com) on: Thu Nov 18 11:22:15 EST 1999
Die hard fan...
Mind ur words.I have everyright to say my opinion.But you don't have anyrights to bash me by using such words.I can also start using similar words but don't wish to make this a stinky place.Mind it.
- From: chella (@ 195.101.0.168) on: Thu Nov 18 12:43:00 EST 1999
A R RAHMAN IS THE BEST !!!
and IR was good ..remember he WAS good !
- From: (@ gate02.merck-medco.com) on: Thu Nov 18 13:13:14 EST 1999
problem is BEST is not good enough.
Alai illa oorukku iluppai poo sarkarai
- From: thathuvavaathi (@ 207.18.199.140) on: Thu Nov 18 16:46:38 EST 1999
aamaam! 'aalai' repair aanadhaala ippO adhai izhuththu moodittaangalaam ! ;-))
- From: moncy (@ dialup-209.244.116.4.houston1.level3.net) on: Thu Nov 18 18:21:27 EST 1999
Every music director is very good.I like all of them. Please(we)don't compare each of the director. All of them are God's gift.They are making songs,our part is enjoying them.Personal attacks is not the solution.We must have the attitude to encourage them to make good songs.Personal attacks is discouraging the great directors to make good songs.
- From: MS (@ 129.252.22.112) on: Thu Nov 18 19:24:38 EST 1999
There is a clip available for the next release of ARR. The film is "pukaar":
http://www.indiafm.com/trailors/pukaar.zip
- From: Ramki (@ ptp141.telsoft.net) on: Sun Nov 14 14:16:22 EST 1999
List all pages of this thread
Post comments
Sections:
Home -
TFM Magazine -
Forum -
Wiki -
POW -
oPod -
Lyrics -
Pictures -
Music Notes -
Forums: Current Topics - Ilayaraja Albums - A.R. Rahman Albums - TFM Oldies - Fun & Games
Ilaiyaraja: Releases - News - Share Music - AR Rahman: Releases - News - AOTW - Tweets -
Discussions: MSV - YSR - GVP - Song Requests - Song stats - Raga of songs - Copying - Tweets
Database: Main - Singers - Music Director's - Lyricists Fun: PP - EKB - Relay - Satires - Quiz
Forums: Current Topics - Ilayaraja Albums - A.R. Rahman Albums - TFM Oldies - Fun & Games
Ilaiyaraja: Releases - News - Share Music - AR Rahman: Releases - News - AOTW - Tweets -
Discussions: MSV - YSR - GVP - Song Requests - Song stats - Raga of songs - Copying - Tweets
Database: Main - Singers - Music Director's - Lyricists Fun: PP - EKB - Relay - Satires - Quiz