Home   Forum   Wiki   Notes   Register   FAQ   Sitemap   About Us   Contact Us  

IR copied vande maatharam in kilakkum Merkum - Kumudam latest issue.

The movie review of kilakkum Merkum says that IR lifted ARR's Vande maatharam music in the movie's BGM. Can anyone who have seen the movie Confirm this.?? Thanks

Topic started by MSK (@ dhcp-877019741.qualcomm.com) on Tue Feb 10 14:12:54 EST 1998.
All times in EDT/EST +9:30/10:30 for IST.

---

Responses:

• Old responses
  
• From: MSK (@ dhcp-877019741.qualcomm.com) on: Mon Mar 2 16:00:19 EST 1998
  
  I agree with Mukund., The point is we wanted kumudam to justify it's stand. If we have'nt acheived that we should'nt give up until then. Our goal was not to get in print but to prove our point. I don't have any contacts with Maalan. But still i feel we are sort of feeling complacent after this made to the press. Whether they publish or not, i feel we should send in our protest abt the mis-interpretation of our discussion . If no-one else does I am going to send an email to the editor after reading the article myself - I don't care if they don't respond. We shall do our best to prove what we think is right .. Sorry if i sound too sulky.
  
  pls correct me if i am wrong
  
  
  
  
  
• From: MPR (@ dyn07.iacc-t23.ndsu.nodak.edu) on: Mon Mar 2 17:22:48 EST 1998
  
  MSK:
  
  Before doing that, first we should watch the movie and make sure that their claiming is wrong. Has anybody seen that movie yet? Atleast someone from India can help us in this matter. But somewhat I'm feeling that now in India, election is going on, press people are busy with election related news and I don't think this issue will be important to them :((
  
  
• From: pg (@ client-116-24.bellatlantic.net) on: Tue Mar 3 18:01:52 EST 1998
  
  Guys checkout this : (excerpts from Kumudam)
  
  http://www.kanian.com/Tamilnews/package34/802w3_music.htm
  
  
• From: MSK (@ dhcp-877019741.qualcomm.com) on: Tue Mar 3 19:52:55 EST 1998
  
  PG.,
  
  Looks like we need special fonts for it. It's not Anjal I guess.!!
  
  
• From: Rajaraman (@ 192.122.135.224) on: Tue Mar 3 20:12:03 EST 1998
  
  MSK,
  you need Tamilnet Kanian fonts. See
  
  http://irdu.nus.sg/tamilweb
  
  
• From: pinchi srinivasan (@ 1cust11.tnt5.nyc3.da.uu.net) on: Wed Mar 4 05:51:12 EST 1998
  
  Dear Friends,
  I did see "Kiz..Mer" movie on video last week , but unfortunately I never listened to ARR's "Vande Maatharam" album, especially after listening to the screeming of namba chinna paayyan ARR in the title song , I wonder if he had any disease (any problem with his vocal cords) at that time. By the way "Kiz .. Mer " movie is a below average movie from the movie's point of view , but some of the songs are very very pleasant, I am still not able to enjoy Bhavatharini's voice .
  
  
• From: Mukund (@ internet-gw1.hea.com) on: Wed Mar 4 14:23:25 EST 1998
  
  Thank you for posting this pg. As I can see it is not edited inappropriately as far my comments are concerned. "IR kappiydichirukka mattar nu ennoda karuththu" appadinnu potirukkanga. Which is what I had exactly written here !!
  
  I am releived.
  
  Thanks
  Mukund
  
  
• From: MPR (@ dyn07.iacc-t23.ndsu.nodak.edu) on: Mon Mar 9 12:08:19 EST 1998
  
  For those who couldn't read the article in Kanian news site, visit kumudam's website at:
  
  http://www.kumudam.com/internet.htm
  
  
• From: MPR (@ dyn07.iacc-t23.ndsu.nodak.edu) on: Mon Mar 9 12:08:43 EST 1998
  
  For those who couldn't read the article in Kanian news site, visit kumudam's website at:
  
  http://www.kumudam.com/internet.htm
  
  
• From: bs (@ www1.access.bt.com) on: Mon Mar 9 14:54:39 EST 1998
  
  MPR:
  Thanx a lot for the link...
  Its just superb.. Kudos to Ravi for giving the much required exposure of our TFM-DF.. Its good to see that Kumudam has also taken the adverse comments sportively.. All in all, a satisfying thing for our TFM-DF..
  
  
• From: bs (@ www1.access.bt.com) on: Mon Mar 9 14:56:14 EST 1998
  
  MPR:
  Thanx a lot for the link...
  Its just superb.. Kudos to Ravi for giving the much required exposure of our TFM-DF.. Its good to see that Kumudam has also taken the adverse comments sportively.. All in all, a satisfying thing for our TFM-DF..
  
  
• From: suresh (@ bowerbird.qut.edu.au) on: Tue Mar 10 07:04:44 EST 1998
  
  friends,
  congrats on handling the kumudam issue so well, and adding another feather to the TFM cap..
  
  
• From: Yoga Balaji (@ 209.4.52.253) on: Fri Mar 13 10:52:10 EST 1998
  
  Kumudhathai Udhaitha anbu nanbargalukku
  
  Ilayaraja mel konda peranbaal neengal ellorum serndhu kumudhathai oru vaangu vaangiyadhai veguvaaga paaraattugiren. Mikka magizhchi. Ilayarajavin isayai oru podhum kuraivaaga edai podakoodaadhu ennum ungal vaadham internet tamizhargalin nenzathil kilarchiyai undu panniyadhu enraal aadhu migai aagaadhu.
  
  Yaarukkum saaraamal nadunilai vagippadhu pathiraigalil perum pangu enbadhu oorukke therindha unmai. Netrikkan thirappinum kutramenru kooram paangai than pathiragaigal eppodhum kadaipidikka vendum.
  Idhai than Kumudham seidhulladhu. umudham eppodhum ilayarajavaye vimarsippadhu polavum, matra kalaignargalai vaarthaigalaal pugazh maalai mattum soottuvadhaagavum ungal vaadhangal unarthugiradhu. "Neengal avarai paaraatta vendaam summa vittaale podhum" - enru neengal solli iruppadhu, "thavaru seidhaalum kandu kolla koodaadhu" enbadhan marmamaana artham allaamal veru enna? Ilayaraja andha beat'I ARR paattil irundhu kaapi adithaar enro, illai enru nan ingu vaadhida villai. Oru pathiragayin sudhanthirathai ingu neengal thavaraaga vimarsithiruppathai dhan kandikkiren.
  
  Idhe kumudham ethanayo murai ethanayo padangalil ARR music'iyum vimarsithirukkiradhu. Yaarayum vittu vaithadhu illai indha kuzhu, adhe samayathil yaarayum paaratta thavariyadhillai enbadhayum nan aanithanamaaga solven. Kadandha vaara thalayangathil coimbatore vedi gundugalai seyalizhakka seidhavargalai paaraatti iruppadhu endha pathirigayum seyyaadha saadhanai enben.
  
  Nayagan padathil ore paadal javvu madhiri irudhadhu enru kumudham ezhudhiyadhadhil endha thavarum iruppadhaaga enakku padavillai. Andha padal nalla paadal dhan, arumayaana isai dhan ellorukkume theriyum dhan. Adhai keduketta paadal enru avargal ezhudhi irundhal ungalukku naanum serndhu thalai aattuven. Arumayaana paadalaaga irundhaalum adhai adikkadi poduvadhu abathamaanadhu enru dhane koorinaargal. Padathil ore murai oliparappaagi, makkalin manadhil idam pidithaal dhan adhu super duper hit paadal. Pala dhadavai kettal endha paadalum hit aagividum enbadhu inraya isai kalaignargal'in commercial idea. (THEN PANDI SEEMAYILE oru murai vandhirundhaalum hit aagi irukkum, enbadhu veru vishayam) Aaraindhu paarthal adhil unmai vilangum.
  
  'NAYAGAN PADA PAADALAYE……' enru nayaganukku neengal oru azhutham koduthiruppadhai paarthal, super hit aagum padathin paadalgalai pathirigaigal vimarsippadhu perum paavam enbadhu pola therigiradhu. Pathirigaigalukku hit padam,actor,director,musician erna bedham ellam illai. Eppadi irundhadhu enra karuthai dhan avargal ezhudha mudiyum, ezhudha vendum. NAYAGAN padam enraal adhai vimarsikka koodaadha??
  
  ILAYARAJAVIN PAADALGALIL INDHA BEAT ERKANAVE VANDHIRUKKIRADHE - enbadhan moolam, avarin pakkathai neengal safer side'aaga kanbippadhan moolam, ungalil sila per ilayarajavin rasigargaaalga therigiradhe thavira, isai rasigargalaaga enakku thondra villai. Idhu eppadi nadandhirukkalaam enru neengal aaraindhirundhaal andha sandhegam enakku vandhirukkaadhu.
  7 raagangal mattume konda isayil inru dhinam 70 paadalgal pirandhu kondulladhu. Endha isayai kettaalum 'idhai engayo kettadhu pola irukke' enru koorum nilamai undaagi vittadhu. So idhu avarukke theriyaamal nadandhadhaaga en irukka koodaadhu?? Ella paadalgalayum kettu vitta avar compose seigiraar?? Idhu ponra vaadhangalai neengal yaarume ezhuppa villai. Ungalin kuri ilayarajavai vimarsitha KUMUDHAthai adippadhu dhan.
  
  Andha beat Ilayarajavudayadhu dhan enraal, kandippaaga avar vilakkamalippar enru nan nambugiren Enakku adhil endha sandhegamum illai. Adhan pin KUMUDHAM adhu thavaru ena therindhaal thiruthi kollavum thayangaadhu enbadhayum nan urudhiyaai solven. Avargalai udhaitha ungalin indha pazhi sorkalaye prasurithavargal, thiruthathai podaamal iruppaargala?
  
  Kumudham kadandha sila varudangalil commercialize seidhadhu ennavo unmai dhan. Adhil endha thavarum iruppadhaaga enakku padavillai. Uncompromised Sigaram K BALACHANDER'e commercial'kkaaga comprise seidhu kondu DUET eduthaare. Adhai yaarum kekta villaye. Irandume thavaru illai.
  
  Ilayaraja is a Genius enbadhai nan eppodhum maruthadhillai, marukka matten, marukka mudiyaadhu. Adhe nerathil Kumudhathai neengal pazhippadhai nan othukkola matten, mudiyaadhu.
  
  Yoga Balaji - New York
  yogabalaji@aol.com
  
  
• From: MAdhan (@ 202.41.117.3) on: Fri Mar 13 12:40:08 EST 1998
  
  Dear Mr.Balaji,
  
  NAYAGAN patri yezhudhiyadhai vimarisanam seidhadhu naan thaan - Kumudham vimarsanam yaen thavaraaga ulladhu yenbadhai suttikaattavaey naan avvaaru koorinaen - "Then paandi cheemailey" paadal andha padathhirkku uyir naadi - it is the pulse of the movie. Adhanaal thaan padam muzhuvadhum, thagundha idangalil andha paadalin soga (pathos) version idam petradhey ozhiya, andha paadalai super hit seiyya vendum yendra yennathhil illai - idhai neengal nandraaga purindhu kolla vendum. Innoru udhaaranam - "Kolangal" yendra padathhil irandu paadalgal migavum arumaiyyaaga Raja pottirundhaar - andha padathhin vimarsanathhil, paadalgalai kurai kooriyirundhadhu indhey Kumudham - yaen ? why ? idharkku ungalaal vilakkam seiyya iyalumaa ?
  
  Idhu pondru niraiyya vimarisanangalil IR potta muyarchiyai alatchiyappaduthhi, summaa sensationalise seivadharkkendru NEWS pottaal, yevvaaru poruthhukkolvadhu ?
  
  
  

---

List all pages of this thread

Post comments