Topic started by Srikanth (@ passport.proxy.lucent.com) on Mon Sep 15 10:23:15 EDT 1997.
All times in EDT +9:30 for IST.
Responses:
- Old responses
- From: Die hard fan of ARR (@ 203.116.186.39)
on: Thu Nov 18 22:44:50 EST 1999
Hi mapillai,I already appologised to you for my harsh words.If you are still not satisfied we can settle this. Anyway i want to let this matter rest.You have to accept the fact that ARR is the no 1 music director in india.Bye and take care.
- From: mapillai (@ 195.101.0.170)
on: Fri Nov 19 11:51:03 EST 1999
a r r is the best of the best
- From: AntiARR!!! (@ lab241-419.carleton.ca)
on: Fri Nov 19 13:48:05 EST 1999
Ya right MAPILLAI!!and Courous!@!!!
ARR is the best of the best in copy anothers music.
He takes 6 months to compose 6 songs for one movie and still he cant do BGM. If he want to do BMG for that movie, then he need another 6 months........
hahahaha ARR is a funny guy!! I can laugh loud and loud.
Our Isaichakkaravarththy, Isaipperarasan, Isaignani ILAIYARAJA could compose 6 songs within 24 hours. He proved it and it became extreme chartbuster in 80's, and still he doing.
I am all music directors fan and I listen every music directors songs.
But, I can say that even SIRPI can make hit songs such as MU\dhalvan and etc if he spent 6 months to compose. I wonder if SIrpi do like this, then maybe he will be the ISAIPPUYAL too.
hahaha I couldnt stop laugh !!!
On the other hand, think about.... if ILayaRajah take 6 months for 6 songs......................
Ohhhhhhhh MY GOD>.......... It should be the 8TH WONDER IN THE WORLD......
VAALHA ALL NON COPYCAT MUSICIAN AND OTHERS, PLS TRY TO THINK YOUR OWN.....
NB: Shakalaka baby is a copied from Hungary song!!
- From: sandai karan (@ 216.32.18.74)
on: Fri Nov 19 14:25:02 EST 1999
isai puyal adhicha athule...Isaichakkaravarththy, Isaipperarasan, Isaignani --- everything flew away, and
isaipuyal was given with the above reason, it is not a like mastero --- is given to people who had publised a symphony...musically, not just verbally.
- From: Srikanth (@ 216.32.18.74)
on: Fri Nov 19 16:39:49 EST 1999
AS per your request Ms
Thanks to your claim on Shaklaka baby, I tried pondering into the song yesterday night and found out few interesting facts, I know many will not agree by the following are my thoughts,
One of the major things I noted
1. No no no -- humming score : Rahman repeats the same score for the 3rd time, can anyone tell me the previous occurences of this notes! (atleast 1...)
2. There is a raga bedam like stuff involved, moves towards some madyamavathi or Sri scales,
3. Singer vasudra has done it well,
4. Beat pattern is good, has some brand new sounds
5. Pallavi has good minor harmomies, check the words shaka la baby it has a 3 part harmony that moves with the EMinor, Gmaj, Amin progression.
6. The saranam suddenly moves to a major -- moham
7. Vasundara's opening blues like start is good,
8. Recording is very clear...
9 Basically the song is very fast
10 It is a simple score, and I liked it, can be played in any party!...makes me hum the lines.,
Cons:
Unwanted spanish stuff and a sumo scream in the middle, (need to watch the movie might be the directors request.)
Male Chorus in the second half, some what confused, there was a gap.
The same Dolki like sound used in all the songs.
Any comments.
- From: ME (@ 212.114.32.234)
on: Sat Nov 20 17:05:10 EST 1999
has arr signed up for any new tamil projects??
- From: srikanth (@ vdslppp102.sttl.uswest.net)
on: Sat Nov 20 17:50:23 EST 1999
Currently he is on bench!...
just joking!, as far as I know has few new hindi movies in his tray
- From: ganesan (@ tp-71-197.tm.net.my)
on: Sat Nov 20 23:13:22 EST 1999
ok
- From: Die hard fans of ARR (@ 203.116.186.39)
on: Wed Nov 24 03:33:28 EST 1999
Stupid anti ARR,better watch your words.ARR is a geniues of both north and south india.IR and co are only good enough for village songs.ARR fans are everywhere in the world.We have fan club of ARR everywhere.So mind it...........
- From: veruppu (@ sisko07.slip.yorku.ca)
on: Wed Nov 24 04:52:13 EST 1999
he he he...
- From: AntiARR (@ lab241-414.carleton.ca)
on: Wed Nov 24 09:01:45 EST 1999
DIE HARD FANS OF ARR!!
Aiyooo paavam nee!!
Why shouting??
hahahaha ....... north hahaha south hahahaha
- From: Kitcha (@ ipa216.miami15.fl.pub-ip.psi.net)
on: Wed Nov 24 19:57:38 EST 1999
Who do you think Sanuji was scathing about??? :)
"....Almost child-like, unassuming and generally accessible, Sanu is anything but a diplomat. He scathingly attacks an over-hyped composer from South whom he would rather not sing for ("I told this to his assistant so bluntly that she was shell-shocked!") ..."
http://www.rediff.co.in/cgi-bin/ncommerce3/ExecMacro/TheRediffMusicShop/music_content.d2w/report?fname=2411sanu.htm
Sorry about posting this twice( made this posting also in the IR's new albums thread), but I was not sure where to do it!
- From: Ada Chee (@ ts3-18t-18.idirect.com)
on: Wed Nov 24 22:27:14 EST 1999
Was listening to 'kurukku chirithavale'.
And it dawned on me!
The 'pallavi' of this song is a direct lift from the sixties song 'oru peNNin manathai thottu pooravare'.
The interlude in that song before the verse 'ennai vittu pirinthu en anbe nee poogathe', is the exact same as the pallavi of 'kurukku sirithavale'. ARR has set it to a different rythm though.
Also, the begining of the song 'chotta chotta nanayuthu Taj Mahal' is a carbon copy of 'kaNgalile oru kaathal ula' by SAR in 'Pistha'.
Does the No 1 MD in India compose anything that's his own?
- From: Annoymous (@ 203.116.186.39)
on: Thu Nov 25 02:41:57 EST 1999
Hello,ada chee,don't waste your time finding fault in the brilliant music of ARR.I can also point out on other md's such as IR,deva,and co.so what i want to say is in the first place DO YOU KNOW WHAT IS MUSIC?bye..........
- From: Reagan Moodley (@ proxy1.eskom.co.za)
on: Thu Nov 25 07:50:08 EST 1999
I am from South Africa, I am a Great fan of ARR. I would love to correspond with other ARR fans all over the world, my email is Reagan.Moodley@eskom.co.za
Dont u think that the songs from Sangamum are great!
- From: ANONYMOUS (@ 202.9.149.234)
on: Sat Nov 27 09:57:29 EST 1999
WHO DO U THINK ARRAHMAN IS.HE IS THE NO.1 MD.
AND THE HEAD-WEGHT ILLAYARAJA CANNOT TOUCH HIS FEET.HE IS A NO.1 COPY-CAT FROM ARR'S MUSIC,THOUGH HE WAS A CLASS MD BEFORE ARR.IF ARR HAD COME BEFORE HIM,THEN THE WORLD WOULDNOT HAVE KNOWN I'RAJA.IT IS ANYWAY UPTO U TO DECIDE WHO IS THE BEST MD.U CHOOSE.
- From: Music mad (@ 202.188.135.147)
on: Sat Nov 27 14:30:26 EST 1999
ENAF FIZZ ENAF FIZZ IS ENAF HEHEH...........
- From: neruppu (@ t16-18.ra.uc.edu)
on: Sat Nov 27 16:41:29 EST 1999
havent seen such profound postings for a while!
- From: veruppu (@ kirk14.slip.yorku.ca)
on: Sat Nov 27 17:45:56 EST 1999
he he he
veruppu
- From: senthil (@ sja-179-170.tm.net.my)
on: Sun Nov 28 02:30:58 EST 1999
what happen to kk
- From: Valgha Tamil MDs (@ 195.101.0.170)
on: Tue Nov 30 11:11:57 EST 1999
Dei pachangala,
dont compare and waste ur time try to admire the Md's work okkkkkkkkkkk !
- From: arrarra (@ 195.101.0.170)
on: Tue Nov 30 11:15:53 EST 1999
A R R R AAAAAAAAAAAA KOKAAAAAAAAAA
- From: Velaiyaththavan (@ 129.252.22.112)
on: Tue Nov 30 13:01:04 EST 1999
kokku
- From: AnTi IrRiTaTeR !!! (@ bat-91-122.tm.net.my)
on: Wed Dec 1 11:30:53 EST 1999
here what i want to say is please don't compare ARR and IR. because both of them got their different way in composing musics. ARR's way is totally different from IR's music. if IR still compose music as like he composed in 80's, sure no one will not listen to his music. if we see now, he also following ARR's ternd in his composing. No one can deny this. Because that is business. Last time when before ARR enter to this cinefield, all MD at that time was following IR's ternd, but now the situation was totally change. This is called as changing of time. When IR was led other MD, he was head-weight and never respect other people. But ARR is totally different from him. He knows how to respect peoples and know about humanity. This is we cannot aspect from IR. Thats why most peple like ARR. Some one say that ARR"s music is not pure and take more time. Why? He care about QUALITY not about QUANTITY. If we look at IR's music, most of the movie that he was composed with BAD music never get success. Some times eventhough the movie never get response, the songs will get BIG response and RESPECTS. Thats what happenned to ARR's movies. The movie such as 'Sangamam','Enn Swasa Kaetre','Mr.Romeo' and etc never hit the screen but ARR's music was HIT audience's ears with successfully. If you compare ARR with IR, you also should compare IR with MSV too. IR also copy MSV's music. Globally the music is we can say as 'world', whereever you go, you have to come to that point. So music also like that. what os ever you change at last you will listen that sound too. And some one compare ARR with SAR, when you people compare the bIG mountain with BiG mountain, please why you want to bring the hill enter to this topic?
- From: aRivu jeevi (@ mail1.pmc-vacc.com)
on: Wed Dec 1 12:51:14 EST 1999
ARR is a great sound engineer.
He is very good at mixing other peoples music to come up with a tune. See the Kumudam interview? Even they pointed out tunes ARR stole.
He is not a Composer. A Composer has to make 'original' music.
IR is the last 'Composer' TFM had.
ithu thaan uNmai.
I know uNmai kasakkum, but what to do.
- From: AntiARR (@ lac460-319.carleton.ca)
on: Wed Dec 1 14:20:41 EST 1999
aRivu jeevi!!
Appidi poodu!!
- From: Soodaamani (@ ys115b.steact128.yorku.ca)
on: Wed Dec 1 21:13:52 EST 1999
Pasangalaa....
Ennapaa...Welavetti illaame summaa sanda pottukinu keeringa..
Nama Ilayaraasaa sir nalla tune pottaaru Appoo..
Rahumaan Thambi Poonnthu welayaaduraaru Ippoo..
But Rahuman neraya pudhu paadagar gala interduce panni vaaraar. Nalla kunam. Periyavar Apdi illa.
- From: soodiyamani (@ on-tor-blr-a52-03-47.idirect.com)
on: Wed Dec 1 23:13:46 EST 1999
enunga soodaamani,
thambikku nalla kunamnaa, unga ponnukku kanaalam panni vainga.
athukaaga, avar 'paatai' ellaam kaekanumnu vatpuruththa venaanga pleasunga
List all pages of this thread
Post comments
Sections:
Home -
TFM Magazine -
Forum -
Wiki -
POW -
oPod -
Lyrics -
Pictures -
Music Notes -
Forums: Current Topics - Ilayaraja Albums - A.R. Rahman Albums - TFM Oldies - Fun & Games
Ilaiyaraja: Releases - News - Share Music - AR Rahman: Releases - News - AOTW - Tweets -
Discussions: MSV - YSR - GVP - Song Requests - Song stats - Raga of songs - Copying - Tweets
Database: Main - Singers - Music Director's - Lyricists Fun: PP - EKB - Relay - Satires - Quiz
Forums: Current Topics - Ilayaraja Albums - A.R. Rahman Albums - TFM Oldies - Fun & Games
Ilaiyaraja: Releases - News - Share Music - AR Rahman: Releases - News - AOTW - Tweets -
Discussions: MSV - YSR - GVP - Song Requests - Song stats - Raga of songs - Copying - Tweets
Database: Main - Singers - Music Director's - Lyricists Fun: PP - EKB - Relay - Satires - Quiz