Home   Forum   Wiki   Notes   Register   FAQ   Sitemap   About Us   Contact Us  

Ilayaraja copy adiththa paadalgal

Topic started by Rajaraman (@ 192.122.136.148) on Sat Jul 26 05:27:10 EDT 1997.
All times in EDT +9:30 for IST.

---

Responses:

• Old responses
  
• From: Prakash Balakrishnan (@ gate1.ca.us.ibm.com) on: Mon Jun 22 12:20:13 EDT 1998
  
  Annaiththu IR, ARR, DEVA rasigargaLum mannipargaLaga...
  
  IR vandha N-aal Mudhal indha N-aaL vari copy adithtukonduthan irukkirar. idhu thappunu solla matten. avaripollavE ARR-um copy adikkirar. Thiruda Thiruda, Indhiyan ippadi ella padathilaiyum copy adichirukkar.
  
  DEVA-va paththi sollavE thevai illai. avarE oththukkirar thaan copy adipathaga. avarai vittuviduvom.
  
  IR 1000 padagaLukku 10000 padalgaLukku meel isai amaithirukkalam. aanal avaridam sarakku romba kuraivu. Thimir adhigam. avar thimirinal pala N-aNNbargaLai izhandhirukkirar.
  indha copy adipparagaLukku ellam kuru avarthan. Avar satharaNa dammankuthu pattukkuda English, Spanish,....etc-la irundhu copy adichirukkar. Idhai IR fans oththukkaVE mattanga. IR music poda aarambichcha bodhu MTV, V-Chanel, VH1 ellam kidaiyadhu. Internet kidaiyadhu. Avar pattukku copy adichu music pottu thaLLi kittu irundhar. ippo vandhirukkiravanga music-a copy adikkum podhu romba easy-a theriyudhu.karaNaam melE sonna TV channelgaLthan..
  
  'Recycle' paNNuvathil IR, ARR-viada N-andragavE saikirar. I saw a song in the films "Kabhi Na Kabhi"... (Anil Kappor, Pooja Bhut starer). Song is recycled from Duet's "anjali, anjali pushpanjali". Hindi-la sagikkala, En endral pattukkum scene sequence-kkum samandhamE illai. ivangaLukku ellam 'isai puyal'-nu pattam vEra??
  
  Mastro, Gyani, Pyal, Raga Vendhan indha madhiri endha title-kkum indha 2 perukkum arugathaiyE illai. ellorum sollalam. Summa indha aaLu vENNunE IR-a paththi pesaran. Rajamadhiri indha music poda mudiyuma? andha music poda mudiyuma?-nu kekkalam.
  aavangaLukku oNNu sollarEn. Rajavai vida avar thammbi N-allaVe music podarar.
  
  sambandhame illama oru vishyam sollaporEn. aanal adhukkum indha copykkum samandham uNNdu.
  
  "aasai" vandha poththu pyangara ARR fan oruthar ARRthan andha padaththukku music pottar, Income Tax problem-thunala Deva perai pottutanganu sonnar. Appuram paththa padathila vandhirukkira ella pattum English albums-la irundhu copy adichchadhu. Oru vELai ARR-than music pottaar. appadinna avarum copy-thanE.. idhE madhiri Kumudhthila oru News(Kisukisu??!!) when Raja was on peak. MSV pala padagaLukku music podaradhavum, Raja perai potta than padam odumnu avar perai podaranganum vandhirundhadhu. Gangai Amaran IR-kitta 1994-la saNdai pottukittu vandhittar. appola irundhu Rajavukku irangu mugam. enna GA- music poduvar, adhai IR- sari parpar. Title-la IR-peru vandhidum. GA-vai yaro eththi vittutanga. avar "N-an Pondicheri Aravinda aasaramam ponEn. adhula irundhu uNNmai pesaradhnu mudivu senjuttEn. adhuthan ennakum aNNanum idaivELi"-nnu bEtti kuduthar. IR saNNdai podatha Periya Director-gaLE kidaiyadhu. K.Balachandar, Baradhiraja, Manirathnam ippadi pala perkitta saNdai pottirukkar. IR music poda vandha podhu 'AnnakiLi' padaththukku L.R.Iswariya "Machanai patheengaLa" pattu pada kuppittanga. adhukku andhama "N-aan pudhu music director kizha ellam pada mattEnu" pigu paNNikittanga. IR appuram andha ammavai kadaisee vari use paNNala. avanga paadi re-recording aaramadhiri oru scene 'Pudhu Manidhan' padathila vandhathu. avangLukku kural kudthathu S.Janaki. ippadi pazhi theerththa IR, Super Goods films R.B Chowdhry first padam edukkum podhu Raja kitta vandhu kettaar. Rajavum L.R.I. style-la mudiyadhunu solla kidaichavargaLthan S.A.Rajkumar, Sirpi, Vidyasagar pondra MDs.
  
  N-eenga ennakai kalla adichalum sari. IR-ai kaNNmudithananama paratradhu sari illai. Avarthan osaththi mathavanga ellam mattam. avarukku idagumanu ellam keekaradho IR mattum than copy adichara? mathavanga adikkalaiya? appadinu summa vetti saNdai podama. avar pattai rasiyungo.
  
  ippavum sollarEn Raja-vala 'pattukku mettu' podaNum-na payangrama kashta paduvar. avar pattukku mettu pottu hit-aana padalgaL miga miga kuraivu.
  
  melum oNNu sollikirEn. KaNNadhasan padalgaL miga arpudha manavai. avaroda padaLgaL miga sirappa innaikkum pesapadaraththu karaNam avar kalathila irundha KVM, MSV, MSV & Ramamoorthy, Vedha, V.Kumar... pondra 'pattukku mettu podara' isai amaipaaLargaLthan. PadalgaLukku jeevan kudukkaradhuthan oru isai ammaipaaLarin velai. andha velaiyai Raja sariya saiyala. aavar appadi senjirundha innikku Radio-la avar isai ammaicha pala pazhaya padalgaLai makkaL virumbi kettpaga.appadi yarum ketpadhaga theriya villai.
  
  ippadi ezhuthhinadhala ennai indha TFM discussion group-la irundhu 'Ban' ellam paNNa mudiyadhu. I have rights to talk and write.It is open to all.
  
  Now stones are mostly welcome.
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
• From: pg (@ gate02.merck-medco.com) on: Mon Jun 22 13:51:34 EDT 1998
  
  rAjA was a front for MSV.
  rAjA was a front for G.K.Venkatesh.
  rAjA was a front for Gangai Amaran.
  
  So what else is new ?
  
  
• From: Rajesh (@ pdxss902.jf.intel.com) on: Mon Jun 22 14:36:37 EDT 1998
  
  Prakash,
  
  I agree with some of your comments that IR is sometimes arrogant and stuff. But RB.Chowdhury incident is news to me. Anyway my guess is IR was
  too busy at that time. Infact if he had insulted RBC, he would not have gone back to him now. This
  is my opinion. About Raja not able to compose tunes for songs, I beg to differ. He infact composed some tunes like that(one song in marupadiyum and some more) and they are hits. I do not know the list of songs done like that. Well you cannot say he will be miserable at that. Infact there are very few songs today that are composed after song is written. I think it is just the norm of the day. I do not think that in any way indicates that no MD is capable of compsing tune for a song. If it comes to that, I guess all
  MDs would still be successful. GA may have composed some tunes but to say that IR was living
  based on his brothers tunes is a little too much.
  GA have reunited with his brother now and I dont
  think even when he was not in good terms he ever
  claimed that he composed most of tunes for IR.
  Again I amnot throwing stones at you but guess I
  have the right to write what I feel
  
  
• From: RV (@ avntfw.avanticorp.com) on: Mon Jun 22 14:40:14 EDT 1998
  
  Vijay: Sorry, didnt see your response to "Manguyile Poonguyile" earlier.
  
  If the rhythm, beat, tune become identical, what is left ? How will the Raga be different ? I am a layman, I dont understand the song technically, so I would like to know.
  
  
• From: Pagalavan (@ bbn-cache-3.cisco.com) on: Mon Jun 22 14:42:18 EDT 1998
  
  Prakash,
  
  Your assumption that IR was the MD for the film puthu manithan is incorrect. MD for that film is Deva.
  
  
• From: Srikanth (@ 161.225.48.3) on: Mon Jun 22 14:46:02 EDT 1998
  
  
  Tambi Prakash Balakrishna -
  --- Nala thandanai - Epdi Tamil with
  english scripts! ouru 1200 words composition....maadri
  We agree it is your right ...no one questions that here... but!....
  
  Please can someone translate it into something that we could understand..
  or it is the same old Raja puranam..if so don't bother...
  
  As pg says Raja is going the front before everonel ,
  but in which direction....no one is coming behind him....all of them took an exit ...as raja was in the front he missed it... (just a joke guys...
  dont pounce on me)
  Hi Geetha : I cannot talk about MSV-RAGAMS HERE! can you suggest some other thread...
  (Jest for fun - is ok to me...)
  
  
  Srikanth
  
  Srikanth
  
  
  
  
• From: Sreeni (@ 198.4.166.21) on: Mon Jun 22 15:27:37 EDT 1998
  
  Srikanth
  "Please can someone translate it into something that we could understand..or is it the same old Raja puranam..if so don't bother..."
  
  I second that,but that essay actually appears,incredibly enough,to be anti-IR.Who is this heretic and how dare he utter such blasphemies in our cosy little cyber-temple for IR?
  
  
• From: Prakash Balakrishnan (@ gate6.ca.us.ibm.com) on: Mon Jun 22 15:47:48 EDT 1998
  
  Rajesh,
  
  IR was not good 'Pattukku Mettu'.. How???
  If he composed very music for the good lyrics..
  you imm'ly list them. atlest out of those 10000+ songs you should have listed 20 to 30. It is not so. As you said Now no MD is doing 'Pattukku Mettu'. I am not at all considering them as good MDs.. so same with IR too.
  
  About GA. GA left IR in 1994. Between 1994 and now 1996 could you tell me how many successful IR films come out? and how many films succeeded in that??After both of them reunited 1997-98 Raja gave good music.
  
  Rajini, told 'padaththukku Kadhai than hero, Music than heroine. appothan padam odum' and praised Raja for his music in that film. But after that Rajini acted many films IR was not the MD why?? Then Kamal always wants IR. After Sathileevathi, IR was not MD for his own production itself. As big fan of Raja he told 'N-aan ennaga paNNattum Producers poda mattengrangaLE?' in a interview. But why he didn't use him his own movie 'Kurudhipunnal'?
  
  All these are looks like Nonsense to IR fans isn't it? if so, then the blind worship on IR is nonsense for me.
  
  "Chinna Thambi" Srikantha !!!!
  It may be thaNdaNai for you.. Sorry about that.
  It is not IR's puraaNam. It is just opposite to that.
  
  Mr.pg..
  I can't understand what are you telling..
  
  Pagalavan,
  Are you sure about pudhu manidhan??? I saw the picture. Satyaraj,Banupriya Starter.. I was thinking that IR was the MD of the film.
  If you are correct then I appologise for that.
  I am realy very Sorry. I am very much sure that S.Janaki gave voice for L.R.Iswari in that film.
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
• From: Udhaya (@ 205.218.142.217) on: Mon Jun 22 15:51:22 EDT 1998
  
  Sreeni, Srikanth, unga rendu paer kurumbu vaazhga.
  Prakash, I appreciate your honesty and emotion, but much of what you say can't be proven. Besides, when we are trying to get away from mudslinging matches that don't really explore anything besides bias and taste, you are fuelling a fire that should be put out at least temporarily so that civil postings can prevail. I'm no authority over you, this is just the humble opinion of a fellow DFer.
  
  
• From: Prakash Balakrisnan (@ gate7.ca.us.ibm.com) on: Mon Jun 22 15:52:27 EDT 1998
  
  Sorry Type-o..,,
  
  
  
  <>
  please ignore the 1996.
  
  
• From: pg (@ gate02.merck-medco.com) on: Mon Jun 22 16:00:06 EDT 1998
  
  Kamal approached rAjA for Kurudhipunal but rAjA turned him down due to lack of time. Kamal himself mentioned this in an interview in Kumudam.
  
  
• From: Ramki (@ dante.cs.wmich.edu) on: Mon Jun 22 16:33:01 EDT 1998
  
  Prakash Deva was the MD for 'pudhu manidhan'
  
  Dhool kilappu:))
  
  

---

List all pages of this thread

Post comments