Topic started by Srikanth (@ passport.proxy.lucent.com) on Mon Sep 15 10:23:15 EDT 1997.
All times in EDT +9:30 for IST.
Responses:
- Old responses
- From: ragumanfan (@ freenet.nether.net)
on: Thu Apr 29 23:15:09 EDT 1999
ananth,nicely said.make this guys understand arrs great.
read kumudam.understand how big all young peoples think of arr.arr is really great.
kovaithambi,donot say arr run out of stuff.you say you do not like padaiapa songs.but see how cassetes are selling.
all people like arr except for few guys.this guys do not like arr.because they are jealousy of him.they cannot
digest that arr achived so much in his very young age.
rajini movies always have poor songs.listen to anamalai,veera,batcha songs.only few songs are good.
but arr put excellent music for him in muthu and padaiapa.north or south or east or west arr is best.
if someone say arr is bad then that is the only reason.
- From: ragumanfan (@ freenet.nether.net)
on: Thu Apr 29 23:20:38 EDT 1999
kovaithambi,arr put music for world cup theme song.it is really a true good news for all of us.
why is it popular.because arr captured the heart of millions of fans.and they eagerly expect arr new album.
miss world is stupid function.but world cup is big event.important event.
putting music for it is prestige.some guys cannot tolerate it becaues of their
jealousy over the arr growth.when is world cup theme songs going to be
released.i cannot wait to hear it.
- From: Srinath (@ 98a90800.ipt.aol.com)
on: Thu Apr 29 23:24:05 EDT 1999
Ok bb, I give up ! Who's this nitwit ?
- From: Kovai Thambi (@ ascella.anonymizer.com)
on: Thu Apr 29 23:38:08 EDT 1999
Ragumanfan:
According to Bernard Shaw: "Cricket is a game where 11,000 fools watch 11 fools play". So do you claim yourself to be a `F__L'? I think it is your height of stupidity to call a mega event like Miss World to be a stupid event. Well, I do not want to enter into a tug-of-war with `Tamaraikanni' of this forum.
You cannot wait to hear it??? Then better not wait. Go and listen some of his recent flops of Padaiyappa for which he received threats and bashings from Rajini fans.
Why should we really feel jealousy over a person who has a `stunted growth'? (I mean his musical growth!!)If ARR gives good music, then I will listen to it. If IR gives great music, I am for it.
My Superstar Mr.Kovai Thambi made a good decision not to bring ARR for his Motherland Pictures, as he knew that this guy cannot produce the goods for Tamil cine field like IR. IR-Kovai Thambi combination is the BEST combination ever in Tamil Film History.
Coming to the topic.....ARR's new releases...Padaiyappa is a flop!! Reasons---> That is what we are here for analyzing it.
- From: ragumanfan (@ freenet.nether.net)
on: Thu Apr 29 23:47:47 EDT 1999
Kovaithambi,i am not a fool.world cup is great event.which
everyone is anxiosly expecting.do you say that every one who watch
cricket is fool.only fool call other peoples fool.
kovai thambi better not bring arr.arr already have lot of
offers.all big offers.it is better he does not put music for small banner movie
like kovai thambi.you know how much demand is for arr new album padaiapa.
I already listened to padaiapa songs.all are good only.rajini fans are always like this.they threaten all people.
- From: Kovai Thambi (@ ascella.anonymizer.com)
on: Thu Apr 29 23:54:26 EDT 1999
Ragumanfan:
Will I ever call an enlightened person like you a fool??? That would be a great sacrilege. I did not call you a fool. But Bernard Shaw did. Also he is not a fool, just because he called people playing and watching cricket as fools, as the world does not call him a fool, and if you call him a fool, then your own argument that "fools call other people as fools" will be applicable to you as well and therefore we can safely infer that you to be a fool.
- From: vijay (@ 129.252.28.47)
on: Thu Apr 29 23:54:33 EDT 1999
ROTFL :)))))))))))))
- From: ragumanfan (@ freenet.nether.net)
on: Thu Apr 29 23:57:29 EDT 1999
i did not call anyone as fool.now you are calling me fool.
so what do you mean?
- From: Kovai Thambi (@ ascella.anonymizer.com)
on: Thu Apr 29 23:59:52 EDT 1999
Ragumanfan:
Sorry, if I had called you a fool. I did not call you or others as fools. I just put it in a lighter vein, what great Bernard Shaw said. But if you say so, then I have no regrets.
- From: hardcore_fan_of_ragumanfan (@ abd0dfe3.ipt.aol.com)
on: Fri Apr 30 00:51:12 EDT 1999
raguman fan,
i really enjoy your posts.....really funny...
IR fans Ku NALLA AAPPU...
continue
fan of AR.RAHMAN and ragumanfan
- From: Kovai Thambi (@ ascella.anonymizer.com)
on: Fri Apr 30 01:06:52 EDT 1999
hardcore_fan_of_ragumanfan:
suyamAA onnum discuss panna theriyathaa unga vargathukku....???
Better start a new webpage for ragumanfan and then start a thread over here, so that you can earn more fans for your dear `ragumanfan'.
The topic here is not that. OK?
- From: Shankar (@ webgate0.mot.com)
on: Fri Apr 30 01:08:30 EDT 1999
kovai brother,
Please refrain from responding to that character. Let's not digress from the topic. He'll stop once he finds nobody responding to him.
I suspect RF is a seasoned DFer trying to play around with others. Now, don't call me paranoic :-)))
- From: ARR Fan's Guru;-)) (@ master.hyd.deshaw.com)
on: Fri Apr 30 01:11:45 EDT 1999
Shankar: Yaaru adhu? Enakku mail anuppaen.....;-))
(Amam, indha thread-la material irundha digression enn varudhaam;-)) )
- From: eden (@ 202.54.71.136)
on: Fri Apr 30 01:36:23 EDT 1999
Raj! Like the emptying out of what little stuff ARR had, his fans too are running out of stuff - otherwise no sane guy with some sense of music will say there had been no good songs in Veera! That album was a Oasis in that desertlike year! (Konji Konji, Malaikkoil are both great songs appreciated by all music loving people. Maadaththile was a jolly song.) Probably the last good album for a Rajini movie (now that he is quite adamant in not choosing IR)!
Fun to watch people comparing Padayappa songs with Veera songs!!
- From: IR Dasan (@ ppp-08-ts7.nerdc.ufl.edu)
on: Fri Apr 30 02:12:01 EDT 1999
Kovai Thambi:
I think these fake fans of ARR are trying to whip up passions over here. Better be on the alert. As Shankar said, try to ignore them so that they will feel that their arguments are pointless in this forum.
ragumanfan:
Next time better be not intoxicated while visiting this forum. `paguthaRivu' ullavargalukku vEEra viRkum padayappAAviRkum vithyAAsam kandu kolla theriyum.
- From: Sincere ARRahman fan who likes IR too (@ 202.144.10.93)
on: Fri Apr 30 07:43:36 EDT 1999
Hi,
Even though Iam going out of the topic , I'm compelled to congratulate ragumanfan for his improvement in English.Just see his posting begin with a capital letter !!!!!!!!!
- From: Sincere ARRahman fan who likes IR too (@ 202.144.10.93)
on: Fri Apr 30 07:44:18 EDT 1999
Hi,
Even though Iam going out of the topic , I'm compelled to congratulate ragumanfan for his improvement in English.Just see his posting begin with a capital letter !!!!!!!!!(dated April 29)
- From: leena (@ host-209-214-33-227.mco.bellsouth.net)
on: Fri Apr 30 12:00:45 EDT 1999
I dont understand why this fans are writing trashand wasting precious time of other people who visit this forum.There is no doubt that ARR is the best in the present circumstances,,IR is historyJust lastweek ARR got best music award (filmfare), and wait till you listen the music of TAAL, a sure shot winner,In Chennai all the street microphone is thumping out VETRICODI from PADIAPPA, What does this prove?
- From: IR Dasan (@ 128.227.216.59)
on: Fri Apr 30 12:38:13 EDT 1999
Leena:
Please do not tend to brand `dissent' as trash. If you think that your time is too precious, then I frankly feel that you should not complain about that, after all you are also wasting your own precious time by browsing here.
- From: Mr.Assertive (@ 202.41.117.101)
on: Fri Apr 30 14:20:38 EDT 1999
Hello Leena, IR is history and Padayappa songs are blaring in street corners - know something , even Daler Mahendi's albums scream out from most audio shops- there are some janmams who get DMahendi's albums recorded !!
BTW, you know that ARR needs Rajini's name to boost his album - in Tamil Nadu, everything now is HYPE OVER HYPE with very little substance.....
- From: LEENA_TAKE_MY_ADVICE (@ 205.158.143.37)
on: Fri Apr 30 14:24:49 EDT 1999
WARNING DIGRESSION (cant resist it)
first of all let me assure you guys, I AM NOT NEW to this forum, i am a silent observer.
LEENA
a simple a solution to your problem
HERE IS A GOLDEN RULE
memorize the following lines 3 times (probably 100!!!) bfore coming to this forum.
I have grouped them into three main categories
IR, ARR/IR, ARR
VERY IMPORTANT ---IR
1. IR is music.
2. music is IR.
3. music and IR are one and the same
4. music and IR cannot be different.
5. any thing which is not by IR is NOT music.
6. in other words music without IR is utter nonsense.
7. IR is the only composer in all of history
8. composers from hollywood are INSPIRED by IR
9. IR is the only exponent of carnatic, rock, jazz, western,xxx,yyy,zzz (you can fill in the rest)
10. IR after releasing his symphony MAY redefine western classical music.
11. IR WILL/MAY BE DOING maniratnam's, shankar's (top director xxx) next movie.
( after repeating this xxx times say Repeat "IR MUSIC MUSIC IR" (another 100 times).
IR/ARR
1. any MEDIOCRE IR score is better than ANY ARR score.
2. needless to say any GREAT IR score is
definitely superior.
3. IR's "do not compare" in HTNI is a stunner while ARR's mumbai theme/thai manne vanakkam/masoom are all NONSENSE.
3. IR "USES " some ragam effectively while ARR just "COPIES" it.
ARR
1. ARR is NONSENSE. this is going to be the most difficult of all and no SANE GUY wud ever say this because bcos many critics/fans ( not only myself but many ) are convinced that ARR is a PHENOMENON, A TREND SETTER,A LEGEND and beyond doubt a musical GENIUS. may be you are insane(:-)))) like many people here. so you can alyways try it.
conclusion: this forum has never acknowleged ARR for what he really is ( and probably never will) A PHENOMENON, A TREND SETTER,A LEGEND and beyond doubt a musical GENIUS.
so leena you have two options
1. foolow my instructions
2. stay way from this forum
- From: FAN_OF_TFM A.K.A. SM (@ nat01smurugap.sgum.mci.com)
on: Fri Apr 30 14:52:32 EDT 1999
LEENA_TAKE_MY_ADVICE,
From your words, I believe you are an ardent ARR Fan. I can understand your feelings but don't you think you are taking things a little too far. Believe me, I am also an ARR fan and I am also a frequent DFer. And, from my experience here, I will say that this is the best forum you can get to get good, unbiased reviews of TFM. You seem to be under the impression that there are lot of fans/devotees of IR here and they criticize ARR for no reason. Of course, there are some people who blindly attack ARR because of their affinity towards IR's music. But, if you see the posts of MS, Raj, Srinath, RajaG, Shankar, Vijay, bb and a lot others (in no particular order), you can understand that they always substantiate their arguments and do not argue blindly. If they say IR is the best, it is not just a blind statement. They give every reasons for it. And, as far as I know, all the regular DFers have said that ARR is also a talented ability but he lacks in certain things and that is why he cannot be called the best. And, they have never failed to appreciate his good albums. So, please do not come to this hasty conclusion and blame this forum. Personally, I have learnt a lot from this forum and I can't digest someone saying that this forum is biased.
List all pages of this thread
Post comments
Sections:
Home -
TFM Magazine -
Forum -
Wiki -
POW -
oPod -
Lyrics -
Pictures -
Music Notes -
Forums: Current Topics - Ilayaraja Albums - A.R. Rahman Albums - TFM Oldies - Fun & Games
Ilaiyaraja: Releases - News - Share Music - AR Rahman: Releases - News - AOTW - Tweets -
Discussions: MSV - YSR - GVP - Song Requests - Song stats - Raga of songs - Copying - Tweets
Database: Main - Singers - Music Director's - Lyricists Fun: PP - EKB - Relay - Satires - Quiz
Forums: Current Topics - Ilayaraja Albums - A.R. Rahman Albums - TFM Oldies - Fun & Games
Ilaiyaraja: Releases - News - Share Music - AR Rahman: Releases - News - AOTW - Tweets -
Discussions: MSV - YSR - GVP - Song Requests - Song stats - Raga of songs - Copying - Tweets
Database: Main - Singers - Music Director's - Lyricists Fun: PP - EKB - Relay - Satires - Quiz